Who are the different approaches suitable for?

Collection manager with mixed film formats

Wants to check which formats and film holders are needed to scan the portraits in the collection.

Volunteer who wants to scan 35mm portraits carefully

Wants to control the settings and edit the scans, even if that takes longer than a simple scanning routine.

Coordinator of a large scanning project

Wants to weigh up manual feeding, automatic transport and outsourcing for a large number of images.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, take an inventory of the film formats. Then decide whether compatible holders, control over the scan or less manual work matters most.

What to consider What should you check? Who pays extra attention to this?
Format and holder Make a note of the film formats in your collection and check that both the exact model and the holders supplied are compatible. If I have portraits in different film formats, I want to avoid finding that some of them won’t fit in the scanner. Around 36% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Detail and correction Compare test scans, software compatibility and the file format you need. Also check that dust correction is suitable for the type of film you have. When I want to edit selected 35mm portraits carefully, scan control and output quality matter more to me than keeping handling time to a minimum. Around 29% of consumers share this priority.
Workflow speed Count the images and strips, then compare the steps involved with automatic transport or a quote for outsourcing. If there are lots of 35mm images to process, I want to know how much time sorting, loading and checking will take in addition to scanning. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on the overall speed of the workflow.
Small film formats Check that an adapter is available for the exact model and that the selected output format suits your needs. For a standalone scanner, also check which memory card you need. If I mainly have 110 or 126 negatives, I want to be able to select them easily without overlooking the need for a compatible adapter. Around 14% of consumers prioritise these formats and ease of use.

Which buying mistakes can you avoid?

  • Assuming a high megapixel or dpi figure means better scans

    A quoted resolution alone doesn’t tell you what a portrait will look like as a scan. For example, reflecta distinguishes between the x66-Scan’s 14 MP sensor resolution and its interpolated 22 MP output; the Consumentenbond notes that basic scanners generally deliver lower image quality than good film scanners.

    Compare test scans of representative negatives and check that the output file and correction options suit the intended use.

    Test scans and editing take extra time, even when the scanning itself is straightforward.

  • Choosing a scanner before checking all the film formats

    The scanners reviewed support different formats. A model designed for 35mm may therefore be unsuitable for other negatives in the same association collection.

    Take an inventory of the formats and compare them with the specifications and holders supplied with the exact version.

    You may need a second scanning method for negatives that won’t fit in your chosen scanner.

  • Assuming every scanner is ready to use straight out of the box

    Epson says that the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued. For the European Kodak Slide N Scan, the manufacturer says an SD card is required but not included.

    Check whether the example being sold comes with the necessary holders, software, connections and storage.

    A missing holder, required SD card or software that doesn’t work with your computer may mean extra preparation is needed.

  • Confusing scanning with permission to share portraits online

    Digitising portraits doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish images of identifiable people or copyright-protected photographs. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable people in images as personal data; photographs taken by others may also be protected by copyright.

    Before publishing, define how the association intends to use the images and check the applicable legal basis for processing personal data and the rights to the photographs.

Relevant scanner brands for reference

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option for formats including 35mm film and 120/220 negatives. Epson says the model has been discontinued and is no longer available from Epson.

  • Epson lists support for TIFF and DIGITAL ICE.
  • If buying a second-hand or remaining-stock model, check that it comes with the right holders and working software.

Plustek

According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35mm negatives and mounted slides, with scanning carried out using a computer and scanning software.

  • Plustek specifies 7200 dpi and a built-in infrared channel. These figures aren’t an independent comparison of visible scan quality.
  • The model is designed for 35mm film. According to software maker LaserSoft, infrared correction doesn’t work on traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The x66-Scan is a standalone scanner for the film formats specified by reflecta; the RPS 10S connects to a computer and offers automatic transport for 35mm strips.

  • reflecta lists JPEG as the x66-Scan’s storage format and says the RPS 10S can transport strips containing 3 to 40 images.
  • The RPS 10S’s specified scanning area isn’t designed for medium format. Check which formats the x66-Scan supports against your negatives.

Kodak Photo Plus

The European Slide N Scan with a 5-inch screen is a standalone option for the 135, 110 and 126 film formats specified by the manufacturer.

  • According to Kodak Photo Plus, adapters for these film formats are included.
  • An SD card is required but isn’t included. The specifications given don’t in themselves demonstrate an independently measured quality advantage.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to check first whether the portraits are on 35mm, 120, 110 or 126 film?

Yes. Take an inventory of the film formats before choosing a scanner. The models reviewed support different formats and holders, so compare the formats you find with the specifications for the exact version.

Does automatic infrared dust correction also work on old black-and-white negatives?

Not with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. Software maker LaserSoft says infrared light can’t pass through this emulsion; careful handling and any software-based correction are separate steps.

What do volunteers need to get started with the European Kodak Slide N Scan with a 5-inch screen?

According to Kodak Photo Plus, adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film are included, but an SD card is required and isn’t supplied. The manufacturer says it supports SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB; check that you have the right card available.

What can I do if a scanner I’ve bought turns out to be faulty?

According to the Dutch government, the seller must provide a solution if there’s a problem with a product. In the Netherlands, there’s no fixed statutory warranty period; what you can expect from a product depends, among other things, on the product itself and whether it’s new or second-hand.

Can our association put digitised portraits online without checking anything else?

No. Digitising portraits doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish them online. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in images are personal data, and an organisation needs a legal basis under the GDPR to process them. The regulator says consent is required in most cases for online publication. Also check the rights to the photographs: the Dutch government says copyright-protected photographs taken by others can’t be distributed or made public without the creator’s permission.