Choose a scanner based on the film format and holder that match your originals. Also decide whether you want to scan negatives, mounted slides or printed photos. For a small, one-off selection, borrowing or hiring a scanner, or having the images digitised, may be more practical than buying one. If you want to adjust and edit your own 35mm images, you’ll have different needs from someone who simply wants to create JPEG files quickly, without using a computer.
Who this guide is for
Student who doesn’t know the film format yet
Wants to check whether their old portrait negatives or slides fit in a scanner holder before choosing a device. The Dutch Consumers’ Association, reflecta and Epson describe different scanning methods and supported media.
Student who wants to preserve detail
Has suitable 35mm film and is willing to spend time adjusting scan settings and editing important portraits. The Dutch Consumers’ Association discusses the trade-off between time and image quality; Plustek lists model-specific features for the OpticFilm 8200i SE.
Student working to a tight deadline
Wants a small selection available digitally quickly and is weighing up scanning the images themselves against borrowing a scanner or using a service. The Dutch Consumers’ Association discusses these alternatives; reflecta describes a standalone scanning method for compatible originals.
What to consider when buying
According to the Dutch Consumers’ Association, the best scanning method and choice of equipment depend on the number of images, how important image quality is and how much time you’re willing to spend. First check the format and holder, then compare the process, file types and costs for your project.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Compatible film format and holder |
Check whether your original is a negative, a mounted slide or a printed photo. Compare its exact format with the scanner’s specifications and the holder supplied. |
I want to check first that my negative or slide will fit in the scanner; around 36% of consumers therefore prioritise the format and holder. |
| Usable detail and correction options |
Look at the scan settings and output file; don’t treat the stated resolution or megapixel count as an independent measure of quality. |
For important portraits, I want to be able to assess detail and use settings or editing, even if it takes extra time; around 29% of consumers prioritise detail and correction options. |
| Time to a file you can share |
Check whether you need a computer, where files are saved and which memory card or cable your chosen workflow requires. |
With a tight deadline, I want to be able to share a usable file without unnecessary steps; around 21% of consumers prioritise a quick turnaround. |
| Cost of a one-off project |
First count the images you want, then compare buying, borrowing, hiring or using a service for the same quantity and desired file quality. |
For a small, one-off project, I don’t want to spend more than necessary; around 14% of consumers prioritise the total cost. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming a high megapixel count proves the scan will capture more detail
KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14 MP sensor for the Slide N Scan, as well as an interpolated output of 22 MP. These are different specifications.
Compare the stated sensor specification with how you plan to use the finished image, and don’t treat interpolated output as independently measured extra detail.
-
Choosing a 35mm scanner before checking the film format
Supported formats and holders vary by model. reflecta specifies that the x33-Scan supports 35mm strips and mounted slides; the x66-Scan also supports certain 120 film formats.
Identify your original first, then check both format compatibility and which holder comes with the scanner.
-
Buying a second-hand flatbed scanner without checking the holders or software
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you’re buying one second-hand, check which holders are included and whether it works with the computer and software you plan to use.
Before buying, check which holders are included and whether the scanner and software work with your computer.
Brands to consider
reflecta
The x33-Scan is designed for compatible 35mm strips and slides; according to reflecta, the separate x66-Scan also supports the listed 120 film formats.
- According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card.
- The x33-Scan and x66-Scan are different models. Check that the holder suits your original; reflecta’s image quality claims are not based on independent testing.
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a specialist scanner for 35mm negatives and mounted slides.
- According to Plustek, this model has an infrared channel to detect dust and scratches.
- The model’s specifications don’t guarantee results for every damaged original; don’t present this model as a scanner for 120 film.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner with holders for formats including 35mm and 120/220 film, and is also suitable for printed material.
- According to Epson, its holder support provides a way to scan different film formats and printed photos.
- Epson Netherlands lists this model as discontinued. If you’re buying one second-hand, check the holders, that it works and that the software is compatible.
KODAK Photo Plus
According to the product information, the Slide N Scan is designed for formats including 135, 110 and 126 negatives, and the corresponding slides.
- KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14 MP sensor.
- The stated 22 MP is interpolated output, not the specified sensor resolution. The product information doesn’t confirm availability in the Netherlands or on Joybuy.
Related products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can I scan a printed portrait photo in a negative holder?
No. A printed photo doesn’t need to go in a film holder; place it on the glass of a flatbed scanner instead. Epson specifies that the Perfection V600 Photo supports documents and photos as well as film holders; Epson Netherlands lists this model as discontinued.
How should I handle old negatives carefully?
Touch the image area as little as possible, and hold the negative by its edge or sleeve. The Library of Congress advises handling photographs by their edges or protective material wherever possible.
Do I need to buy a scanner straight away for a small project?
No. Borrowing or hiring a scanner, or having the images digitised, are alternatives discussed by the Dutch Consumers’ Association. Ask a scanning service about resolution, file format and any dust and scratch correction before you book. Compare the costs for the same number of images and the file quality you want.
Can the school post recognisable portrait photos online without asking?
No, not without checking first. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that permission may be needed to store or publish recognisable photos of pupils: according to its guidance, for pupils under 16 the school must ask a parent for permission, and from age 16 it must ask the pupil. Whether this applies to the old portraits and the intended use depends on who is pictured and what the school does with the photos. Copyright in photos taken by others is a separate consideration; the Government of the Netherlands states that permission from the creator is required to use copyright-protected photos.