Voice memo listeners
You want to replay sections and make out words over the sound of an aeroplane at a comfortable volume. The Consumentenbond assesses speech reproduction and noise cancelling as separate considerations.
Start by checking how clearly you can hear your own recording at a comfortable volume, and whether the headphones fit well enough to wear for a long time. Assess speech reproduction and noise cancelling separately. Then consider battery life with ANC on, the controls, and how the headphones connect to your phone, laptop or seat console. The Consumentenbond notes that noise cancelling can help reduce low engine hum, but that doesn’t mean every word in your memo will be clear.
You want to replay sections and make out words over the sound of an aeroplane at a comfortable volume. The Consumentenbond assesses speech reproduction and noise cancelling as separate considerations.
You wear your headphones for hours and want a comfortable fit, even with glasses. Comfort varies from person to person, so consider any pressure around your ears and on your head.
For example, you might listen on a phone and a laptop. Check which wireless or wired connection is compatible with your devices.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who should prioritise this? |
|---|---|---|
| Speech clarity | If possible, listen to your own memo and assess speech and ANC separately, at a comfortable volume. | I want to make out the words in my recording without constantly turning up the volume; around 31% of consumers prioritise speech clarity. |
| Wearing comfort | Try the headphones for an extended period, with glasses if necessary, and check for pressure around your ears and from the headband. | I want to wear the headphones on a long journey without uncomfortable pressure; around 25% of consumers prioritise fit and comfort. |
| Connectivity and controls | Check how your device connects and whether pause and rewind work with your chosen connection method. | I want to start, pause and replay my recording easily on my own device; around 19% of consumers prioritise connectivity and controls. |
| Battery life with ANC | Compare the stated battery life with ANC switched on, taking your listening time and charging options into account. | I want to keep listening later in the journey without stopping to charge; around 13% of consumers prioritise battery life. |
| Awareness of your surroundings | Try how quickly you can pause, lower the volume or take off the headphones. | I want to respond quickly to an announcement or instruction from the crew; around 12% of consumers prioritise awareness of their surroundings. |
Noise reduction and the reproduction of speech are two separate considerations. Reducing background noise doesn’t guarantee that a recording with unclear speech will be easier to understand.
If possible, listen to your own memo and assess speech reproduction, ANC and fit separately.
Stated battery life can vary depending on whether ANC is on or off. Manufacturers’ figures may also be based on different conditions.
Check the ANC setting for each figure, and only compare battery life figures that have been stated on the same basis.
Bose says that the buttons on the QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are disabled when you use the audio cable.
Check the controls and compatibility for the connection method you plan to use when replaying your memo.
The JBL Tour One M3 Smart Tx is a version that the manufacturer lists with a Smart Tx transmitter. This package is different from the standard Tour One M3.
Check the full model name, what’s included in the package and the output on your audio source before choosing a transmitter.
The WH-1000XM6 is worth considering if a wired fallback, multipoint connectivity and an ambient sound mode are important to you.
The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless is worth a look if the stated battery life is a key consideration.
The Tour One M3 Smart Tx is worth considering if you need a transmitter for a compatible audio source without Bluetooth.
The Space One Pro is an over-ear option to compare if foldability and stated battery life matter to you.
The QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are worth considering if you’re thinking of listening both wired and wirelessly.
This selection includes headphones to consider for replaying a voice memo on a long journey. For each model, check that the connection and controls suit your playback device and how you plan to use it.
No image available
Worth considering for replaying memos; check that the connection and controls suit your playback device.
No image available
The stated battery life may be useful on a long journey; also check that the controls suit the way you replay memos.
Sennheiser states a maximum of 60 hours. This is a manufacturer’s figure, not a comparison based on equal testing conditions.
No image available
The product name describes wireless noise-cancelling over-ear headphones for anyone who wants to replay memos without a cable.
The product name states a battery life of 24 hours; check that it suits how long you listen and how you use the headphones.
No image available
This version lists both wired and wireless listening; check which connection and controls you need to replay recordings.
Bose says the headphone buttons are disabled when you use the audio cable.
No image available
The product name lists Bluetooth; check that this wireless connection is compatible with the device your memo is stored on.
No. Noise cancelling can help reduce low engine hum, but recording quality and speech reproduction still matter. The Consumentenbond assesses speech reproduction and noise reduction separately. If possible, listen to your own memo beforehand at a comfortable volume.
Connect the headphones to the device your memo is on and try pausing, rewinding and switching listening modes. If you’re using a wired connection, check whether the controls on the headphones still work; Bose says the buttons are disabled when you use the audio cable with the QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen).
That depends on the rules for your flight. EASA emphasises that passengers must follow the crew’s instructions and that the airline is responsible for the use of portable electronic devices. Check your airline’s policy in advance.
Compare battery life with the same ANC setting, and treat figures as manufacturers’ claims unless they were measured under comparable conditions. Sennheiser states a maximum of 60 hours for the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless; soundcore quotes up to 40 hours for the Space One Pro with ANC on and 60 hours with ANC off.
Start at a comfortable volume and try a well-fitting pair of noise-cancelling headphones. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to help you avoid turning the volume up in noisy surroundings; it’s still sensible to take listening breaks.