Choose headphones that let you hear a voice memo clearly at a comfortable volume and easily let in the sounds around you. Noise cancellation doesn’t guarantee that you won’t hear conversations or announcements in the carriage, and ambient mode doesn’t guarantee that every announcement will be clear. If possible, try the fit and controls with a recording of your own.
Who might find this useful?
Anyone who wants to listen back to memos carefully
You want to hear speech clearly at a comfortable volume, even with travel noise in the background. The Consumentenbond explains how noise cancellation can reduce noise; the WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy environments to help reduce the temptation to turn up the volume.
Anyone who wants to keep track of announcements
You want to be able to quickly turn your attention to the carriage or travel information while listening. Ambient mode that’s easy to access can be useful, but it won’t automatically make every announcement clear.
Anyone facing a long journey or carrying a full bag
You’ll need to weigh up long-wearing comfort, storage space and battery life with noise cancellation on. The Consumentenbond notes that over-ear headphones can be comfortable during long listening sessions, but take up more room in a bag.
What should you look for?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who should consider this? |
| How clearly you can hear the memo |
If possible, listen to a recording of your own at a comfortable volume, and check the fit and noise reduction. |
If I want to follow quieter passages without continually turning up the volume, I want to be able to assess how my own recording sounds. Around 36% of consumers put clarity first. |
| Announcements and ambient sound |
Check how to switch on ambient mode and whether the controls are easy to reach while you’re listening. |
If I want to quickly pay attention to an announcement or what’s happening in the carriage while listening to a memo, it’s important to be able to switch modes easily. Around 29% of consumers give awareness of their surroundings top priority. |
| Comfort during the journey |
If possible, try wearing the headphones for longer and check for pressure around your ears and on the headband. |
If I’m listening to memos during a longer journey, I want a fit that stays comfortable. Around 21% of consumers put long-wearing comfort first. |
| Portability and battery life |
Compare the battery life with noise cancellation on and check how the headphones can be stored. |
If I’m carrying the headphones in a full bag or want to listen on several journeys without charging in between, size and battery life matter. Around 14% of consumers give these factors top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Expecting noise cancellation to block out every voice
Noise cancellation can reduce travel noise, but it doesn’t guarantee silence or make conversations and announcements disappear.
Assess how well you can hear your memo and how easily you can switch to ambient sound separately.
-
Comparing only the longest battery life figures
Manufacturers may quote different battery life figures with noise cancellation on and off, so they’re not necessarily comparable.
Compare the stated battery life under the same conditions, paying particular attention to the figure with noise cancellation on.
-
Choosing over-ear headphones on specifications alone
Fit and pressure during extended wear are personal preferences; over-ear headphones also take up space in your bag.
If possible, try them on and check how you plan to store the headphones.
Brands to consider
Sony
The WH-1000XM6 is an over-ear option for anyone who wants to switch between a memo and their surroundings, or may want to connect two devices.
- Sony lists Quick Attention, an ambient sound mode and multipoint via the app.
- The stated maximum playback time is 30 hours with noise cancellation on; this isn’t a measurement of battery life while listening back to memos.
Bose
The QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are an over-ear option with adjustable listening modes.
- Bose describes adjustable noise cancellation and modes that let in ambient sound.
- Bose states a maximum of 30 hours per full charge; this figure doesn’t tell you how clearly you’ll hear a memo on a train.
JBL
The Tour One M3 are over-ear headphones with Smart Talk, for anyone who wants to have a conversation while listening.
- JBL lists Smart Talk and up to 40 hours with noise cancellation on.
- The general maximum playback time of 70 hours doesn’t apply under the same conditions as the figure with noise cancellation on. Both are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements taken on a train.
soundcore
The Space One is an over-ear alternative with adjustable ambient sound and a foldable design.
- According to soundcore, the Space One has five transparency levels and a stated battery life of 40 hours with noise cancellation on.
- The manufacturer bases its noise-reduction claim on laboratory tests; this doesn’t tell you how much of a particular voice memo you’ll hear on your train.
Joybuy products for listening to memos on the train
This selection includes in-ear and over-ear headphones with noise cancellation. For each model, check how you can let in ambient sound and whether the controls suit the way you like to listen.
Image unavailable
HONOR Earbuds A Pro
The in-ear design may suit you if compact portability matters and you want to switch between noise cancellation and transparency mode.
The product information lists press or app controls, a 12.4mm driver and 49dB Active Noise Cancellation. The stated total battery life is up to 42 hours with the charging case.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Sony WH-CH720N, blue
These over-ear headphones may suit you if you want noise cancellation and the ability to adjust the level of noise reduction via the app.
The stated features include a weight of 192 g, multipoint, 20 adjustable steps in the app and up to 35 hours of battery life with noise cancellation on.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Bose QuietComfort SC, black
These over-ear headphones may suit you if you want to choose between noise cancellation and a mode that lets in ambient sound.
The product description lists Quiet and Aware modes, along with soft ear cushions.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen), black
These over-ear headphones may suit you if you want to switch between noise cancellation and letting in more ambient sound while listening.
The description lists Bluetooth and a detachable cable for wired listening. No charger is included; the product description also warns about magnets. If you have a medical implant, check this warning before buying.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
CMF by Nothing Headphone Pro, dark grey
These over-ear headphones may suit you if you want to combine noise cancellation with a transparency mode that lets in ambient sound.
The product information lists multipoint, a weight of 283 g and up to 48 hours of battery life with ANC on.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does noise cancellation completely block out conversations in the carriage?
No, don’t expect complete silence. The Consumentenbond notes that noise cancellation is particularly effective at tackling the deep rumble of vehicles. Try listening to a voice recording of your own to see what you can still hear in your situation.
How can I listen without continually turning up the volume?
The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy environments, so you have less reason to turn up the volume. Listening time and sound levels also matter.
Do I need to take my headphones off to hear an announcement?
Not always: some models have an ambient mode or quick-access controls. However, check that you can actually hear the announcement in your situation; this mode can’t guarantee that you will.
Can I play a memo in an NS quiet zone?
NS asks passengers to keep quiet in the quiet zone and not to disturb others elsewhere on the train with loud conversations or music. Make sure other passengers can’t hear what you’re listening to. This is an NS rule, not a general ban on wearing headphones.
What if my headphones break too soon during normal use?
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, you have a legal guarantee in addition to any manufacturer’s or retailer’s guarantee. If the product doesn’t meet the expectations you were entitled to have, the retailer is responsible for providing an appropriate solution; this doesn’t mean every pair of headphones has the same fixed guarantee period.