Story listener on a noisy train
You want to follow dialogue and clues without constantly turning up the volume. So compare speech quality and noise reduction separately; the Consumentenbond includes speech clips in its headphone tests.
Start with a fit that stays comfortable throughout your train journey, then compare how clearly voices come through, the ANC and the controls for ambient mode. ANC can help reduce train noise, but it won’t automatically block out every conversation or announcement. Also check the stated battery life with ANC switched on.
You want to follow dialogue and clues without constantly turning up the volume. So compare speech quality and noise reduction separately; the Consumentenbond includes speech clips in its headphone tests.
For regular or longer journeys, you prioritise a comfortable fit and enough battery life with ANC on. The Consumentenbond also points out that over-ear models take up space in a bag.
You want to be able to pause a story easily to hear what’s happening around you, so look for ambient mode that’s easy to use. Check how to activate the feature on the model you’re considering.
For a detective story on the train, a comfortable fit and speech that’s easy to follow are key considerations. Then assess ANC and ambient sound for the situations in which you need them.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Speech and train noise | Compare a speech clip and ANC separately; don’t expect ANC to block out every voice. | When I listen to a detective story, I want to follow the dialogue without constantly turning up the volume. Around 33% of consumers say clear speech is their main reason for buying. |
| Comfort during the journey | If possible, try the fit for a similar length of time to your usual listening session and, if you wear glasses, try them on with your glasses. | On a long train journey, I want to keep my headphones on without the fit becoming uncomfortable. Around 27% of consumers give long-lasting comfort their top priority. |
| Hearing your surroundings | Check how to switch between ANC and ambient mode, and whether the controls are practical for you. | If I want to notice an announcement or someone speaking to me, I want to be able to hear my surroundings easily. Around 20% of consumers put awareness of their surroundings first. |
| Battery life with ANC | Compare battery life using the same setting. Sony Netherlands states up to 30 hours with NC on and 40 hours with NC off for the WH-1000XM6; JBL’s 70-hour figure for the Tune 770NC is with ANC off. | When I take my headphones with me often, I want to know how long they last with the settings I use. Around 20% of consumers weigh up battery life and purchase price first. |
Manufacturers may state battery life for different settings. Sony distinguishes between NC on and off for the WH-1000XM6; JBL’s 70-hour figure for the Tune 770NC is with ANC off.
Compare the stated battery life using the same ANC setting and check the manufacturer’s conditions.
A shorter battery life with ANC on may mean you need to charge your headphones more often than you’d expect from the highest figure.
ANC doesn’t reduce every type of surrounding noise in the same way. The Consumentenbond treats speech quality and noise reduction as separate considerations.
Assess speech, ANC and ambient mode separately, and don’t assume every announcement will be clear.
On-ear headphones can put more pressure on your ears, while over-ear models take up more space in your bag. Glasses can also affect how headphones feel.
Take your usual journey length, whether you wear glasses and the space in your bag into account when choosing.
If the fit isn’t comfortable on longer journeys, you may find yourself taking your headphones off sooner.
The WH-1000XM6 is an over-ear option for anyone looking for ANC, ambient mode and the ability to switch between devices.
The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless is worth considering if stated playback time and a transparency mode are priorities for you.
According to JBL, the Tune 770NC combines a foldable over-ear design with ANC and Ambient Aware/TalkThru.
The Space One and Q20i are separate over-ear options, both with ANC and a transparency mode.
These Joybuy products are worth considering for train journeys when you’re looking for ANC, with over-ear and in-ear options available.
Image unavailable
An over-ear option for anyone who values noise reduction on a train journey; assess speech quality separately.
Image unavailable
An over-ear option to consider if you want to be able to hear your surroundings while listening; check that the controls suit the way you use your headphones.
Image unavailable
An in-ear option if a compact listening solution is important to you; check that they fit securely and feel comfortable.
Image unavailable
An over-ear option to consider for longer train journeys when noise reduction matters; compare the speech quality with your own listening needs.
Image unavailable
An over-ear option for anyone looking for ANC on longer journeys; check whether the stated battery life and features suit the way you use your headphones.
No, ANC alone can’t guarantee that. Also compare how natural voices sound and whether the headphones fit comfortably; the Consumentenbond assesses speech and noise reduction as separate parts of its tests.
Before you set off, find out how to switch between ANC and ambient sound on your model. Sony, JBL and soundcore list these features for the models mentioned, but don’t assume they’ll automatically make every announcement clear.
The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to play audio louder in noisy situations. Listening exposure also depends on volume, duration and frequency, so take breaks.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, for a standard online product purchase you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. This is separate from your rights if a product is faulty: according to the Dutch government, products must be of satisfactory quality, but the Netherlands does not have a fixed statutory two-year guarantee period. The retailer is your point of contact if a product is faulty.