Who is this relevant to?

Listeners of quiet nature recordings

You want to hear wind, water and birds during your train journey without continually turning up the volume. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy situations. None of the models mentioned has been tested specifically with your recordings on a train.

Travellers who want to hear announcements

You want to be able to switch modes when travel information or your surroundings need your attention. Check how to use ambient mode on the exact model you’re considering; NS says that trains provide announcements with up-to-date travel information.

Listeners on long journeys

You wear your headphones for extended periods, so consider how they fit and how long they play for with the settings you use. The Consumers’ Association assesses wearing comfort and battery life separately.

What should you look for when buying?

Start with the fit and the level of noise cancellation you need for quiet recordings. Then consider how easily you can switch to ambient sound.

What matters What to look for when buying Who is this important to?
Reducing train noise Look at the fit and seal, and find information about the noise cancellation on the exact model. If I want to listen to quiet nature sounds without continually turning up the volume, I prioritise reducing train noise. Around 33% of consumers say noise reduction is their top buying priority.
Being able to hear announcements Check that ambient mode is easy to use; don’t assume it will make every announcement clear. If I want to keep an eye on travel information during my journey, I want to be able to switch quickly between listening and ambient sound. Around 27% of consumers prioritise being able to hear travel information.
Adjusting the sound Check whether the model has sound settings or an equaliser, and how to use them. I want to adjust the sound of my nature recordings to suit my preferences. For around 20% of consumers, adjusting the sound is their top buying priority.
Comfort and battery life Consider how the headphones fit during extended wear and compare playback time using the same noise-cancelling setting. If I’m travelling for a long time, I want headphones that stay comfortable and have enough playback time for my journey. Around 20% of consumers say long-lasting comfort and playback time are their main priorities.

Common buying mistakes

  • Comparing maximum playback times directly

    One model’s stated maximum may be with noise cancellation on, while another’s may not specify the setting. That means the figures aren’t necessarily comparable.

    Only compare playback times when the usage settings are described in the same way, and check which version you’re looking at.

  • Assuming ambient mode guarantees you’ll understand announcements

    A mode that lets in ambient sound doesn’t guarantee that you’ll understand every announcement on the train.

    If necessary, pause your recording and listen out for important travel information.

  • Confusing an optional protection plan with your statutory rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between your statutory guarantee and a guarantee provided by the seller, manufacturer or provider of an additional plan.

    Check which additional risks a paid plan covers, and bear your statutory rights in mind.

    An optional paid plan comes at an extra cost; your statutory guarantee applies even without one.

  • Confusing versions with nearly identical model names

    The JBL Tour One M3 Smart Tx is a separate version that comes with an audio transmitter. It isn’t the same package as the Tour One M3.

    Before buying, check the full model name and which accessories are included with that version.

Relevant brands to consider

Sony

The WH-1000XM6 and WH-1000XM5 are closed-back over-ear models with an ambient sound mode.

  • Sony states that both models offer up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancellation on.
  • These are model specifications, not independent measurements of train noise reduction or wearing comfort.

Bose

The QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are worth considering if you want to switch between Quiet and Aware modes.

  • Bose states that they last up to 30 hours on a full charge and describes the two modes.
  • Having these features doesn’t prove that nature recordings sound better on this model than on others.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless combines adaptive noise cancellation, a transparency mode and adjustable sound.

  • Sennheiser states that they offer up to 60 hours of playback time.
  • Don’t compare this maximum directly with a figure for noise cancellation on unless the usage settings are the same.

JBL

The Tour One M3 and Tour One M3 Smart Tx are different versions; the Smart Tx is offered with a transmitter.

  • JBL states that the Tour One M3 has adaptive noise cancellation and offers 70 hours of total music playback.
  • The stated 70 hours hasn’t been confirmed as playback time with noise cancellation on. Also check which version and accessories you’re choosing.

Joybuy products

This selection features over-ear headphones for listening on the train. Features such as ambient mode, adjustable sound and stated playback time vary by model.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, white

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, white

A good choice if you want to switch to ambient sound while listening and adjust the sound to suit you.

The product information lists adaptive noise cancellation, a transparency mode and an equaliser. Sennheiser states that they offer up to 60 hours of playback time; don’t compare this figure directly with playback times for noise cancellation on.

View at Joybuy
Sonos Ace, black

Sonos Ace, black

A good choice if you want to combine active noise cancellation with a mode that lets in ambient sound.

The product information lists active noise cancellation, an Aware mode and up to 30 hours of use with active noise cancellation on.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-1000XM5, silver

Sony WH-1000XM5, silver

A good choice if you’re looking for wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancellation for listening to nature recordings on the go.

Sony states that the WH-1000XM5 offers up to 30 hours of battery life with noise cancellation on.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen), black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen), black

A good choice if you want to switch between listening with noise cancellation and hearing ambient sound while travelling.

Bose describes Quiet and Aware modes and states that they last up to 30 hours on a full charge. This version doesn’t include a charger; the product information recommends a compatible 1.8 W to 2.5 W charger and states that PD fast charging isn’t supported.

View at Joybuy
CMF by Nothing Headphone Pro, Dark Gray

CMF by Nothing Headphone Pro, Dark Gray

A good choice if you want to combine noise cancellation with a transparency mode and adjustable sound.

The product information lists adaptive ANC, a transparency mode, an equaliser, up to 48 hours of playback time with ANC on and a weight of 283 g.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I turn up nature sounds if I can’t hear them clearly on the train?

Not as your first solution. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy situations. Keep the volume low and take listening breaks; this doesn’t guarantee that every quiet recording will be easy to hear on every train.

How can I make sure I hear announcements on the train?

Before setting off, check how to use ambient mode and switch it on, or pause your recording when you’re expecting travel information. NS says that trains provide announcements with up-to-date travel information, but a transparency mode doesn’t guarantee you’ll understand every announcement.

Can other passengers hear my nature recording on an NS train?

According to NS’s house rules, you must not disturb other passengers anywhere on the train with loud music; the quiet zone must remain quiet. Keep the sound to yourself and prevent it from leaking out. These are NS rules, not a set rule for every Dutch train operator.

Which marking should I check on wireless headphones?

Check that the specific product has the correct CE marking. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure lists wireless headphones as equipment that requires this marking; the model name alone doesn’t show that the specific product has it.

Do I have a cooling-off period when buying online in the Netherlands, and do I need extra cover?

For a standard online purchase, you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. Your statutory guarantee also applies if, under normal use, a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect from it; a paid protection plan doesn’t replace those rights. ACM ConsuWijzer explains these rights and conditions.