Who is this choice relevant to?

If you want to scan piles of newsletters

If you have lots of loose pages, some of which may be printed on both sides, compare the ADF capacity and check separately whether the model scans both sides automatically.

If you want to preserve fragile originals

Folded, bound or brittle items need careful handling. The Dutch National Archives describes quality control as a separate step in the digitisation process.

If you also print project materials

If you want to print as well as scan, weigh up your need for colour against how much you expect to print. The Dutch Consumers’ Association notes that inkjet printers can use a relatively large amount of ink for cleaning if you print infrequently.

What should you look for when choosing?

ADF with duplex scanning

Suitable for: loose stacks printed on both sides. Epson lists duplex scanning for the EcoTank ET-4951, as does HP for the OfficeJet Pro 9132e.

Bear in mind: an ADF is not automatically the right solution for fragile originals. Also check the capacity of the exact model’s feeder.

Flatbed scanner

Suitable for: bound, folded or brittle pages that you would rather place individually on the scanner glass.

Bear in mind: placing pages individually involves more manual work. Canon lists both a flatbed scanner and an ADF for the PIXMA TR4755i.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Scanning lots of pages Check the ADF capacity and original sizes; look separately for duplex scanning. If you want to process piles of loose, double-sided newsletters, you’ll want to spend less time feeding or turning pages by hand. Around 33% of consumers considering this type of project put handling large numbers of pages at the top of their list.
Fragile originals Check whether the model has a flatbed scanner and assess a test scan for completeness and legibility. If you don’t want to feed brittle or bound items through a document feeder, you may prefer to place pages individually. Around 27% of consumers considering this type of project give protecting originals top priority.
Colour and images Check that it scans in colour and view a test file; choose colour printing only if you need it. If coloured layouts or illustrations matter to your digital project, you’ll want to be able to assess them in the scan. Around 20% of consumers considering this type of project put colour reproduction first.
Costs if you print infrequently Compare cartridges, toner or ink bottles, and factor in your expected print volume and maintenance. If you’ll mainly be scanning and only printing occasionally, take the ongoing cost of consumables into account when making your choice. Around 20% of consumers considering this type of project put the cost of occasional printing first.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming an ADF means automatic duplex scanning

    A document feeder, duplex printing and duplex scanning are different features. So, a model that prints automatically on both sides won’t necessarily scan both sides of a sheet automatically.

    Check the specifications for the exact model and look specifically for duplex scanning.

    If the feature isn’t available, you may need to turn over double-sided pages yourself and feed them through again.

  • Feeding every original through the document feeder

    For fragile or bound items, placing each one individually on a flatbed scanner may be more suitable. Check scans for missing pages and legibility.

    Make a test scan of a suitable item and check the result before processing a whole stack.

    Scanning pages individually involves more manual work; an incomplete or illegible scan may also mean doing the work again.

  • Considering only the upfront cost of a colour inkjet printer

    If you print infrequently, an inkjet printer can use a relatively large amount of ink for cleaning. Also check which cartridges are compatible with the model; HP lists dynamic security for the OfficeJet Pro 9132e, which may block cartridges without a compatible HP chip.

    Compare consumables and maintenance costs with your expected print volume, and read the cartridge terms for the model you choose.

Brands to consider

Canon

Canon lists a flatbed scanner and a 20-sheet ADF for A4 paper for the PIXMA TR4755i; the MAXIFY GX4050 has a 35-sheet ADF for A4 paper. These are specifications for these models, not features of all Canon printers.

  • Canon lists automatic duplex printing for both models.
  • Duplex printing doesn’t confirm that a model scans both sides automatically; check for this feature separately.

Brother

According to Brother, the MFC-L2800DW is a monochrome laser printer with a 50-sheet ADF.

  • For this model, Brother lists automatic duplex printing and multi-page scanning via the ADF.
  • The features described don’t confirm automatic duplex scanning; the model also doesn’t print in colour.

Epson

Epson describes the EcoTank ET-4951 as a colour ink tank printer with a duplex ADF and duplex scanning.

  • The listed duplex scanning feature may be useful for stacks of pages printed on both sides.
  • Epson’s savings claims aren’t an independent cost test based on your print volume; compare the model with your own needs.

HP

HP lists an ADF and duplex scanning for the OfficeJet Pro 9132e.

  • The stated scanning feature may suit loose, double-sided newsletters.
  • HP lists dynamic security for its cartridges: cartridges without a compatible HP chip may be blocked, and firmware updates can affect how they work.

Joybuy printers for scanning and project work

This Joybuy selection includes colour multifunction inkjet printers for scanning and printing project materials. Check whether each model’s scanning features suit the condition and quantity of your newsletters.

Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S

An option if you want to scan and copy documents as well as print in colour.

The product name specifies an A4 inkjet printer with 4800 x 600 DPI.

Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305

An option if you’re looking for a colour printer with scanning and copying functions.

The product name specifies duplex printing. Automatic duplex scanning isn’t available, so you’ll need to turn over double-sided originals by hand.

Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005

An option if you want to place originals individually on a flatbed scanner and also print or copy.

This model has no automatic document feeder and doesn’t scan both sides automatically, so stacks and double-sided pages need to be handled manually.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is duplex printing the same as duplex scanning?

No, check the scanning feature separately. Canon lists automatic duplex printing for the PIXMA TR4755i, while Epson explicitly lists duplex scanning for the EcoTank ET-4951.

How can I check that my digital archive is usable?

Make a test scan and check that all pages are there, legible and in the right order. The Dutch National Archives treats quality control as a separate step in digitisation. If you want searchable files, also check separately whether OCR or searchable PDF is available, and assess the result.

Which ongoing costs should I compare?

Compare the compatible cartridges, toner or ink bottles for your expected print volume, and factor in any maintenance. The Dutch Consumers’ Association notes that inkjet printers can use a relatively large amount of ink for cleaning if you print infrequently; this isn’t a cost calculation for a specific model.

Can I share scanned newsletters or publish them online?

Not automatically. The Dutch government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or making copyright-protected work available to the public. For identifiable images of pupils published by a school, the Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights consent and security; for pupils under 16, parental consent is required. What applies in your situation depends on the content and how you intend to use it.