For stacks of loose, suitable sheets, an automatic document feeder can be more convenient. Fragile or unusual pages are better placed on the flatbed scanner, according to the Consumers’ Association. Then choose based on whether you need colour and how much you expect to print. Measure the space with the trays open, and check specifically whether double-sided scanning is supported: double-sided printing doesn’t guarantee it.
Who is this for?
If you scan stacks of newsletters
You want to digitise several loose pages and, if they’re printed on both sides, find out whether the ADF scans both sides automatically. The Consumers’ Association says an automatic document feeder is useful when handling multiple sheets of paper.
If you have limited desk space
You want to print and scan with one device, but still need to leave room for open trays, the lid and the paper output.
If you print as well as archive
You need to decide whether you need colour prints and which consumables suit your printing volume, such as cartridges, toner or ink bottles.
What should you look for when choosing?
Colour inkjet with cartridges
When to choose it: if you’d like to print newsletters in colour from time to time and compare the stated dimensions.
Things to consider: the Canon PIXMA TR7650’s dimensions are measured with the trays retracted, so also measure the space it needs when in use. Its single-sided ADF doesn’t scan both sides automatically.
Monochrome laser with ADF
When to choose it: if you don’t need colour prints and mainly scan or print stacks of text pages.
Things to consider: the Brother DCP-L2660DW prints in black and white; double-sided printing doesn’t automatically mean it can scan both sides. Include the cost of both toner and drum in your comparison.
Colour ink tank with ADF
When to choose it: if you print in colour regularly and want to compare refillable ink with cartridges.
Things to consider: the Epson EcoTank ET-5150 and HP Smart Tank 7305 both have an ADF; double-sided printing doesn’t automatically confirm that either model can scan both sides.
For archiving, compare how you feed in the pages as well as how the printer will fit on your desk. The following points can help you choose a model that suits your paper, printing needs and available space.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Scanning a stack of pages |
Check the ADF capacity, compatible paper types and whether the ADF is explicitly stated to scan both sides. |
If I want to process stacks of loose sheets without placing each one individually, I look at the feeder and scanning function. Scanning stacks is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Desk space |
Measure the available space and compare it with the room needed for open trays, the ADF and the scanner lid. |
I want to use the printer on my small desk without its open parts getting in the way. A practical set-up is the top priority for around 27% of consumers. |
| Colour on paper |
Decide whether you only need colour in your digital archive or also want to print newsletters in colour. |
If I want to keep paper copies of newsletters in colour, I need colour printing. That’s the main buying priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Running costs |
Compare compatible cartridges, toner, drums or ink bottles for the same expected print volume and period of use. |
I want to know in advance which consumables suit my printing habits and what I’ll need to buy. Expected printing costs are a top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Comparing only the dimensions with everything folded away
The stated dimensions may apply only when the trays are retracted. When the printer is in use, the input, output and an open lid may need extra space.
Also measure the clearance needed for the trays, paper output, lid and controls.
-
Confusing double-sided printing with double-sided scanning
The ability to print automatically on both sides doesn’t confirm that the ADF can scan both sides of a sheet.
Before buying, check the separate specification for double-sided scanning.
-
Comparing only the purchase price
Total running costs also depend on how much you print and the ink or toner you need. The Brother DCP-L2660DW has a toner cartridge and drum that can be replaced separately.
Compare the compatible consumables for the same expected print volume and period of use.
-
Assuming every cartridge is compatible
HP states that the OfficeJet Pro 8132e uses dynamic cartridge security, which can block cartridges with a non-HP chip.
Check cartridge compatibility and any subscription terms for the exact model.
Brands to consider
Canon
Canon PIXMA colour inkjets may be worth considering if you also want to print in colour on a small desk.
- Canon lists a 20-sheet ADF for the PIXMA TR7650 and dimensions of around 438 × 350 × 190 mm with the trays retracted.
- Canon specifies a single-sided ADF. The stated dimensions don’t show how much space the printer needs when in use.
Brother
The Brother DCP-L2660DW monochrome laser is an option to compare if your newsletters are mainly text.
- Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF for this model, with toner and drum that can be replaced separately.
- This model doesn’t print in colour. Its double-sided printing specification doesn’t confirm that it has a double-sided scanning ADF.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-5150 is a colour ink tank printer to consider if you scan and print regularly.
- Epson specifies a 35-page ADF and a 250-sheet paper tray.
- Epson claims low cost per page, but that doesn’t prove it will be cheaper for every buyer without comparing costs on the same basis.
HP
The Smart Tank 7305 is a colour ink tank option with an ADF; the OfficeJet Pro 8132e offers a cartridge and subscription-based alternative.
- HP specifies a 35-sheet input capacity and scanning to PDF for the Smart Tank 7305.
- Double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that the Smart Tank 7305 scans both sides automatically. HP states that the OfficeJet Pro 8132e has model-specific cartridge security.
Joybuy products
These all-in-one printers have a scanning function for digitising newsletters. Check whether each model’s feeder and scanning options suit your stacks of paper and available desk space.
No image available
Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 inkjet printer
The product information lists a 50-sheet ADF, which is useful if you want to process stacks of loose pages.
The model name indicates A3 support; check that the format and available space suit your needs.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 All-in-One
If you scan stacks of loose pages and print in colour too, HP lists a 35-sheet input capacity and scanning to PDF for this model.
Automatic double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that the printer can scan both sides automatically; check this feature separately.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer
An A4 all-in-one inkjet option if you want to scan newsletters and print in colour too.
Before buying, check that the feeding method and scanning functions suit the way you want to process stacks of loose pages.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 All-in-One
If you want to scan newsletters and print in colour, this model lists scanning to PDF.
This model has a flatbed scanner without an ADF, so double-sided scanning isn’t available. For stacks of loose sheets, this means you can’t rely on an automatic document feeder.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is automatic double-sided printing enough for two-sided newsletters?
No. Check separately whether the ADF can scan both sides automatically; double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that it can.
When should I use the flatbed scanner instead of the ADF?
The Consumers’ Association recommends using the flatbed scanner for creased, thin, smooth or thick paper. A stack of suitable loose sheets is generally easier to scan using an ADF.
Will scanning to PDF automatically make my archive searchable?
Not necessarily. Scanning to PDF and using OCR to create searchable text are different functions. Check that OCR is available for the exact printer model and software you plan to use.
Can I freely share printed newsletters digitally?
Not automatically. The Government of the Netherlands permits copying copyright-protected texts for personal use, but that doesn’t give you general permission to distribute or publish copies. Businesses and organisations are subject to different permissions and reprographic rights requirements when copying and sharing.
What should I do if newsletters contain personal data?
Protect your digital archive against unauthorised access. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises taking extra care with work documents; organisations must also follow rules on security and retention periods. These rules don’t establish a standard retention period for personal archives.