Which scanning option is right for you?

Manager of a mixed-format film collection

You may be looking after both 35mm and medium-format negatives, and want to check in advance that the scanner and holders accommodate every format. Plustek says the OpticFilm 120 Pro supports 120/220 film as well as 35mm.

Volunteer with lots of 35mm strips

You want to process a large number of landscape images and are weighing up less time spent loading against control over each scan. reflecta says the RPS 10S can process film strips containing up to 40 images.

Manager responsible for long-term file storage

You want to keep scans easy to find and decide in advance which file formats, naming conventions and checks are right for your archive. The National Archives describes quality control and file management as part of digitisation and digital archiving.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the film formats in your collection, then work out how much control, throughput and file management your scanning workflow requires.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Film formats and holders List your 35mm, 120/220 and any larger originals; check that each model supports the formats and that the right holders are available. If the collection contains different formats, I want to avoid finding that some originals won’t fit the holder. Around 33% of consumers prioritise support for mixed formats.
Scan detail and corrections Assess a test scan and distinguish between sensor resolution and interpolated output. According to software maker LaserSoft Imaging, infrared correction does not work on conventional black-and-white film with a silver-based emulsion. If images may be reassessed or edited later, I want to be able to match the scan output and correction options to the original. Around 27% of consumers say scan control and detail are their main concerns.
Throughput Count the strips and images for each format; check that the strips are suitable for the feeder, and allow time for checking and post-processing. When I have lots of compatible 35mm strips, I want to spend less time loading them without skipping quality checks. Around 27% of consumers prioritise processing lots of film strips.
Files and archiving workflow Decide which output formats, filenames, storage and quality checks you need; check what the scanner and software actually provide. If volunteers manage scans together, I want files to be easy to find and check later. Around 13% of consumers put a practical archiving workflow first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming all landscape negatives are 35mm

    Landscape describes the subject of a photograph, not the format of the negative. A 35mm holder won’t necessarily fit 120 film or larger originals.

    Sort the collection by format and check which holders and film formats each model supports.

    Volunteers will still need to spend time on filenames, storage and quality checks after scanning.

Brands to consider

Plustek

Plustek describes separate models for 35mm film and for 35mm plus certain 120/220 formats.

  • The OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35mm negatives and mounted slides; according to Plustek, the OpticFilm 120 Pro also supports 120/220 film from 6 × 4.5 to 6 × 12 cm.
  • Stated resolution and quality descriptions are manufacturer specifications, not an independent comparison of scan results. Check the exact model and software.

reflecta

According to reflecta, the RPS 10S is designed for 35mm strips, while the standalone x66-Scan also supports certain 120 formats.

  • reflecta says the RPS 10S can process strips containing up to 40 images. The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card and has a 14MP sensor.
  • The x66-Scan’s 22MP output mode is interpolated. These features don’t automatically apply to other reflecta models.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro is a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for a range of film formats.

  • Epson lists support for formats including 120 film and 5 × 4 inch, as well as TIFF output.
  • Epson Netherlands lists the V850 Pro as discontinued and no longer available through its own product listing. If you’re considering a second-hand unit, check its condition, holders and compatible software.

KODAK Photo Plus

KODAK Photo Plus describes the Slide N Scan as a standalone converter for 135, 110 and 126 negatives, among other formats.

  • The product seller lists a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP mode.
  • Check that the supported formats and file workflow suit your collection and archive.

Products at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do you get started with a mixed collection without buying the wrong scanner?

First, note the film format and condition of the originals in each box or strip. Then compare the format limits and holders for the exact model you’re considering; 35mm, 120 film and larger originals don’t necessarily use the same holder.

Does infrared dust correction work on old black-and-white negatives?

Not on conventional black-and-white film with a silver-based emulsion. Software maker LaserSoft Imaging says its iSRD infrared method cannot be used on this type of film, so choose a correction method that suits the film and software you’re using.

What work is left to do after scanning?

You’ll also need to select, name, store and check the files; you may also need to correct dust or colour. The National Archives describes quality control as part of digitisation, so a scanner alone won’t complete your archiving workflow.

Can a community archive publish scanned photographs online?

Not automatically: copyright in the photograph and rules concerning identifiable people need to be considered separately. According to the Dutch government, the private-copying exception allows copies for personal use, but does not automatically permit distribution or publication for the public. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in images to be personal data; organisations need a GDPR legal basis to process it.