Start by taking stock of the film formats in the collection, then make some test scans before choosing a scanner. If you mainly have 35mm negatives, a dedicated film scanner could be a good fit. For a mix of formats, choose a model that genuinely supports those formats and includes the right holders. A standalone JPEG scanner is best suited to creating accessible copies. For an archive, decide separately which files will be kept as preservation masters and which images may be published.
Who is this guide for?
Curator of mixed film formats
You receive negatives in different formats and want to know which formats and holders a scanner supports before you buy. The Consumers' Association notes that the amount of material, the quality you need and the time available are all factors to consider.
Keeper of archival files
You want to be able to check which files are saved as preservation masters and which are intended for viewing or sharing. Metamorfoze describes this distinction as part of preservation imaging.
Processor of large numbers of film strips
You’re weighing up fewer loading steps against the time needed to clean, check and organise files. The Consumers' Association points out that the amount of material and the time you’re willing to spend on it both matter.
What should you look for?
First, check that the scanner can handle your originals and holders. Then decide which files you want to keep and how much manual work the collection will involve.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Format and holder |
Take stock of 35mm, 120, 110 and 126 formats, where applicable. For each exact model, check which image formats it supports and which holders are included. |
If I receive negatives from different format families, I want to know whether each format can be scanned properly using the right holder. Around 31% of consumers prioritise format compatibility. |
| Preservation master |
Check the actual file output and create test files. The National Archives lists TIFF 6.0 as a preferred format for government information; this is not an automatic requirement for a community archive. |
If I’m keeping scans for an archive, I want to be able to distinguish the master from files for viewing or sharing. Around 25% of consumers prioritise control over the preservation master. |
| Processing time |
Count the images and assess the strip lengths. Also test loading, checking and organising files with a small batch. |
If I have a lot of strips to process, I want to know how much work the scanner actually saves—not just how quickly it captures an image. Around 25% of consumers prioritise processing time. |
| Operation and storage |
Check whether you need a computer and software, and whether any required memory card is included. |
If volunteers use different equipment, I want a workflow they can follow without unnecessarily complicated controls. Around 19% of consumers value ease of use most. |
Things to consider when buying and using a scanner
-
Using a quick JPEG scan as your only archival file
According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves files as JPEGs. A standalone scanner can be handy for creating accessible copies, but the output you choose should suit the archive’s needs.
Agree in advance which files you’ll keep, and assess some test scans before processing the whole collection.
-
Choosing a 35mm scanner for a collection that includes other formats
Supported formats vary by model. The Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE, for example, is designed for 35mm, while the OpticFilm 120 Pro also supports 120 film up to 6 × 12 cm, according to Plustek.
Measure and sort the originals, then compare their formats and holders with the specifications for the exact model.
-
Assuming infrared correction works for all black-and-white film
According to SilverFast, infrared detection does not work as intended with traditional silver-based black-and-white film.
Identify the type of film and assess a test scan before applying correction to a whole batch.
-
Assuming an old product page means a product is still available
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued models, so their product pages do not confirm current availability.
If you’re considering a second-hand model, check its condition, included holders and software before relying on it for your project.
Brands and models to consider
Plustek
Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a scanner for 35mm film. According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 120 Pro also supports 120 film up to 6 × 12 cm and TIFF output.
- The 120 Pro is worth considering if the collection includes both 35mm and supported 120 formats.
- The 8200i SE is not suitable for a full-frame 120 negative. Resolution specifications and image quality claims come from the manufacturer; they are not the result of comparative testing.
reflecta
According to reflecta, the x66-Scan is a standalone scanner for formats including 35mm and certain 120 formats. The RPS 10S is a computer-connected model for 35mm strips.
- According to reflecta, the RPS 10S offers automatic feeding for compatible strips containing 3 to 40 images.
- The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card; its stated 22MP output is interpolated from a 14MP sensor. The RPS 10S is specified for formats up to around 35mm.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are examples of flatbed scanners with a transparency unit for 35mm and 120 film. The V850 Pro also lists larger film formats.
- These models show how a flatbed scanner can support several film formats.
- Epson Netherlands lists both specific models as discontinued. If you’re considering a second-hand model, check the holders and software.
Kodak Photo Plus
The European Slide N Scan product page lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 negatives, as well as standalone storage to an SD card.
- The listed formats may be useful if they are actually present in the collection.
- According to the product page, an SD card is required but not included. The stated 14MP sensor alone does not tell you whether the output is suitable as the only preservation master.
Joybuy products
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is a high dpi or megapixel rating enough to choose a scanner for an archive?
No. Check the film format and actual file output, and make a test scan too. reflecta lists a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP mode for the x66-Scan; these are not two different sensor resolutions.
How should you deal with dust and black-and-white negatives when scanning?
Handle the originals with care and assess a test scan first. According to SilverFast, infrared detection does not work as intended with traditional silver-based black-and-white film; software correction is a different approach.
Can a community archive publish digitised family photos online straight away?
No. Digitising photos does not automatically give you permission to publish them online. The Dutch Government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or making copyright-protected photos public. Privacy rules may also apply when people can be identified, so assess the rights and people involved for each image.