Start by sorting the negatives by format, then decide whether your group mainly wants to view images quickly or needs more control over scanning and editing. A standalone scanner can simplify operation without a computer, while a specialist 35mm scanner offers more scanning settings; a suitable flatbed scanner can also handle larger film formats. If you have a large or delicate collection, consider using a scanning service too, and agree how the group will store and share files.
Who is this guide for?
Collection manager with a range of film formats
You’re bringing together negatives from several families, so first you need to identify which formats and holders will actually fit. Manufacturers such as reflecta, KODAK Photo Plus and Epson list different format support for each model.
Volunteer who wants to assess scans carefully
You want to be able to assess and correct important 35mm images, even if that takes longer to operate. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a 35mm scanner with scanning settings and an infrared channel.
Group archive coordinator
You organise who scans the images, checks the files and gets access to them. In its preservation imaging guidance, Metamorfoze distinguishes between preservation files and access copies.
What should you look for?
Start with the formats the scanner needs to handle, then weigh up the level of control you want, volunteers’ time and file management.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Film formats and holders |
Compare the formats supported and holders supplied with the exact model against sample strips from the collection. |
If I’m bringing together negatives from different families, I want to know which strips will actually fit. Around 33% of consumers prioritise format compatibility. |
| Scan quality and correction |
Compare the output file you want with the available correction options. The reflecta x66-Scan has 22 MP interpolated output from a 14MP sensor; that is not the same as 22 MP of original sensor detail. |
I want to be able to assess and correct important images, even if it takes extra time. Around 27% of consumers prioritise control over the scan. |
| Processing and operation |
Test the total time needed to produce a checked file, and find out whether a computer is required and how much loading is done by hand. reflecta lists automatic transport of 3 to 40 images for the RPS 10S; this is not a measure of the total project time. |
If several volunteers are processing the collection, I want a workflow they can follow without unnecessary steps. Around 20% of consumers prioritise processing and operation. |
| Storing and sharing files |
Agree on file names, checking, transfer and access. Assess privacy and rights separately before images are shared or published. |
I want scans to be easy to find, with clear rules about who can view or share them. Around 20% of consumers prioritise archive management. |
Pitfalls to avoid when buying
-
Assuming all family negatives are 35mm film
Scanners and holders don’t all support the same formats; choosing the wrong format could mean that some of the collection won’t fit.
List the formats in advance and compare them with the specifications and holders supplied with the exact model.
-
Confusing interpolated megapixels with sensor detail
reflecta specifies a 14MP sensor for the x66-Scan, as well as an interpolated 22 MP output mode. These two figures don’t describe the same thing.
Compare the sensor specification and output file, and try sample scans of your own negatives rather than looking only at the largest number.
-
Treating a discontinued flatbed model as a standard new purchase
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued and no longer available through its Dutch product page.
If you’re considering a specific unit, check that it works, that the film holders are included and that the software is compatible with your group’s computer.
-
Assuming archiving means you can share images without restriction
People who can be recognised in photos may be covered by privacy rules. Digitising a photo also doesn’t automatically mean the group can publish it.
Control access to the preservation files and assess privacy and any rights separately before publication.
Brands to compare
The brands listed here relate to the models and product ranges described below; their inclusion says nothing about availability.
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a specialist option for 35mm negatives if scanning with computer software suits your workflow.
- Plustek specifies 7200 dpi, an infrared channel and SilverFast SE Plus software supplied with this model.
- These are manufacturer specifications, not independently verified evidence of better image quality. The stated support is for 35 mm, not a mixed collection that includes 120 film.
reflecta
The x66-Scan and RPS 10S offer different workflows: a standalone scanner and a model with automatic film transport.
- According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card and supports certain 120 formats. For the RPS 10S, the manufacturer lists automatic transport of 3 to 40 images.
- The x66-Scan’s 22MP mode is interpolated from a 14MP sensor. The RPS 10S transport specification says nothing about the total time needed for checking and editing.
KODAK Photo Plus
The Slide N Scan with a 5-inch screen is a standalone option for the formats listed for the specific variant.
- The product page lists support for 135, 110 and 126 negatives, a 14MP sensor, an interpolated 22MP mode and SD storage.
- You’ll need a memory card for this workflow. Check the exact variant and its holders, as specifications can vary between versions.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner for film and prints.
- Epson specifies film holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF output, among other features.
- Epson Netherlands lists this model as discontinued and no longer available. If you’re considering a second-hand unit, check the holders, that it works and that the software is compatible.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Should we identify all the film formats first?
Yes. Compare sample strips with the format and holder specifications for the exact model. Plustek lists 35 mm support for the OpticFilm 8200i SE; reflecta also lists certain 120 formats for the x66-Scan. Don’t assume other formats are supported unless the model specifications say so.
Is a quick scan to an SD card enough for the group archive?
No. You should also agree who will transfer and check the files, and which versions will be kept or shared. In its preservation imaging guidance, Metamorfoze distinguishes between preservation files and access copies. This is a useful distinction, not an automatically compulsory standard for your group.
Can the group put digitised family photos online?
Not automatically: digitising a photo doesn’t, in itself, give you permission to publish it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that people who can be recognised in images are personal data, so privacy law applies. The Dutch government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or publishing photos; assess rights and privacy separately for the intended use.