Student who wants to be able to recover RAW files
You want to be able to retrieve original files and project versions after a mistake or drive problem. A separate backup is more important for this than RAID alone.
A NAS is a good fit if you want to access RAW files regularly from several devices or share them centrally with a project group. If you mainly use one computer and only archive files occasionally, an external drive may be simpler. Work out the usable space before choosing your drives: with RAID 1 and two drives of the same size, QNAP says you’ll have roughly the capacity of one drive available before system overhead. RAID isn’t a separate backup, so the National Cyber Security Centre recommends planning an additional copy.
You want to be able to retrieve original files and project versions after a mistake or drive problem. A separate backup is more important for this than RAID alone.
You take lots of RAW photos and want to work out how much storage you need, and how much will actually be usable, before choosing a NAS and drives.
You want to access files from several devices and control access according to who needs to view or edit the photos.
Choose this if: you want to store RAW files centrally so you can access them from several of your own devices or work collaboratively, and you’re happy to manage the device, drives and user permissions yourself.
Consider: you’ll need to manage storage and access, and arrange a backup on a separate destination.
Choose this if: you mainly use one computer and only copy or archive files occasionally.
Consider: to access files from other devices, you’ll need to move the drive or share the files separately. You’ll also need a separate, recoverable copy.
When storing RAW files for a school project, the main considerations are recovery, usable space, the complete setup and access.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverability | Plan a copy on a separate destination and check that you can restore files from it. | If I want to retrieve my original files after a mistake, I need a copy outside the NAS. Around 31% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Usable space | Estimate the number of RAW photos and how much your collection is likely to grow, then check the usable capacity of your chosen configuration. | If I have a growing archive, I want to make sure there’s enough space for my files. Around 25% of consumers prioritise usable archive space. |
| Complete setup | Check which drives are included with the model and factor in a separate backup destination. | If I want to plan the whole setup, I need to know which parts I’ll need in addition to the enclosure. Around 25% of consumers focus on the complete purchase. |
| Sharing access | Check that your devices are supported and set user permissions; consider internet access only if you need it. | If my project group needs files on different devices, I want to share access without making everything available to everyone. Around 19% of consumers prioritise shared access. |
QNAP says that with RAID 1 and two drives of the same size, around half of their combined nominal capacity is available before system overhead. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
RAID can help if a drive fails, but on its own it doesn’t provide a separate copy that you can use to recover files after other types of data loss. The National Cyber Security Centre emphasises that RAID doesn’t replace a backup.
Before buying, decide where you’ll keep a separate copy and check that you can restore a file from it.
The available space depends on your drive configuration. With RAID 1 and two drives of the same size, QNAP says around half of their combined nominal capacity is usable before system overhead.
Estimate the size and growth of your own RAW archive, and check that the drives are compatible with your chosen model.
The enclosure may not be the complete setup: some models are sold without drives, and you’ll also need a destination for a separate backup.
Check what’s included with the specific model, and factor the required drives and backup storage into your choice.
The National Cyber Security Centre says that internet access increases security risks. Privacy protection may also be relevant for identifiable school photos.
Start with access on your own network and limited user permissions. Consider separately whether external access or publication is necessary and appropriate.
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-drive option to consider for central photo storage and access across multiple platforms.
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a model for home users who want to store and share photos centrally.
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-drive model to consider for shared storage.
The NASync DXP2800 is a model to consider if you’re looking at a two-drive option with 2.5GbE.
The Joybuy products shown are Synology NAS systems for central storage and file sharing. Check which drives are included with your chosen model and arrange a separate backup as well.
Image unavailable
A good fit if you want to manage and share project files centrally. Hard drives aren’t included; plan a separate backup on another destination as well.
Image unavailable
A good fit for a project group that wants to manage files centrally. This model is diskless, so storage media aren’t included; a NAS doesn’t replace a separate backup.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for central project file storage and sharing across devices. Plan a separate backup on another destination as well.
Image unavailable
A good fit if you’re looking for central storage with file and photo management. Hard drives aren’t included; plan a separate backup as well.
No, not as your only protection. RAID 1 can protect you against one drive failing when you have two drives, but the National Cyber Security Centre says RAID is no substitute for a backup. Keep a copy on another destination too, and check that you can restore files from it.
Adobe describes a network drive as a possible location for photo files. Check separately where the Lightroom Classic catalogue can be stored; don’t assume photos and the catalogue have the same storage requirements.
Create accounts and give each group member only the permissions they need. The National Cyber Security Centre advises checking default settings and passwords during setup, and preferably not making a NAS directly accessible over the internet.
For identifiable images published by a school, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says that pupils aged 16 and over must give their own consent, while parents must give consent for younger pupils. This doesn’t necessarily mean that the same publication rule applies to every RAW file stored privately; for your project, establish who takes, processes and publishes the photos.
No. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that statutory rights exist alongside any manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty. What you can expect in terms of product lifespan and the circumstances of a fault both matter; contact the seller if a product is faulty.