Who is this choice relevant to?

Volunteers preserving unique films

You want to preserve submitted recordings, manage separate copies and check that files remain unchanged. The Digital Preservation Coalition describes copies and checksums as part of digital preservation.

Archive managers with a growing collection

You receive films regularly and want to weigh up usable capacity, the number of drive bays and expansion options in advance.

Teams sharing films under controlled access

Several volunteers need to be able to find or view files without automatically receiving the same access rights. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that identifiable people in footage may be considered personal data.

What should you look for in a NAS for a film archive?

Start with your preservation plan and expected growth, then work out what capacity and access settings your volunteers need.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Backup and file integrity Plan a separate copy and check that restoring files and carrying out regular checksum checks are practical. If I’m preserving unique films, I want more than one storage location and a way to check whether files have changed. Around 33% of consumers give this protection top priority.
Capacity and growth Assess your collection and expected incoming films; calculate the usable space for your chosen drives and configuration. When films keep being added, I want to plan for more space without mistaking raw drive capacity for available archive storage. Around 27% of consumers put future storage space first.
Volunteer access Decide who can submit, edit and view files; check that your chosen setup lets you assign these permissions separately. If several volunteers are working with films featuring identifiable people, I want to be able to tailor access to each task. Around 20% of consumers make controlled collaboration their top priority.
Management and complete setup Check what’s included, which drives are compatible and who will manage backups and recovery tests. If our team is responsible for buying and maintaining the storage, I want a setup that suits our resources and way of working. Around 20% of consumers put practicality first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking drive mirroring for a complete backup

    A mirrored volume is still a single storage location. The Digital Preservation Coalition describes separate copies as a distinct safeguard for community archives.

    Plan a separate copy alongside the NAS, and agree how you’ll carry out recovery and file checks.

  • Mistaking raw terabytes for usable archive space

    The space available for films depends in part on the drives and the configuration you choose. Also check whether the enclosure comes with or without HDDs; the DS1525+ offer reviewed did not list any HDDs as included.

    Calculate the usable capacity for the complete setup and check what’s included in the specific offer.

  • Assuming all NAS drives are the same

    According to Western Digital, the WD Red family includes both SMR and CMR models. Manufacturer support may also vary by drive model and NAS.

    Check the full HDD model number and compatibility with the manufacturer of your chosen NAS.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ and DS1525+ offer a comparison between a two-bay enclosure and a model with more room for internal expansion.

  • Synology specifies one built-in 2.5GbE port for the DS225+ and two for the DS1525+. These are product specifications, not performance figures measured in a community archive.
  • Check compatibility with the exact HDD model. Support may vary between listed drives and other models.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model to consider when comparing compact storage setups.

  • QNAP specifies two SATA drive bays and one 1GbE port for the TS-233.
  • The model has 2 GB of non-upgradable memory. These specifications alone don’t determine transfer speeds or suitability for every archive workflow.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay option for shared film storage.

  • ASUSTOR specifies two 3.5-inch SATA HDD bays and one 1GbE port for this model.
  • The model has 1 GB of non-upgradable memory. Check for each model that the drives and features you need suit your workflow.

Seagate

The IronWolf range is worth considering as a standalone HDD option, provided the exact model is supported by your chosen NAS.

  • Seagate specifies CMR for the models in the IronWolf data sheet consulted.
  • Availability of the recovery service mentioned in that data sheet varies by country. Check the terms for the exact model and for the Netherlands.

Western Digital

WD Red is another HDD range to consider if the exact model suits your NAS.

  • Western Digital lists both SMR and CMR models within the WD Red family.
  • The family name alone doesn’t tell you which type you’re choosing. Check the exact model and the NAS manufacturer’s recommendations.

NAS drives at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are internal HDDs for a NAS setup, not complete NAS enclosures. Before buying, check that the exact drive model is compatible with your chosen enclosure.

Synology SATA HDD 16TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

An internal drive for a compatible Synology NAS; on its own, it doesn’t provide shared network access or volunteer permissions management.

Capacity: 16 TB.

Interface: SATA.

Rotational speed: 7,200 rpm.

View at Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6TB with 256MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB (256 MB cache)

An internal NAS drive, not a complete enclosure; check that the exact model is compatible with your NAS drive bay and support requirements.

Capacity: 6 TB.

Cache: 256 MB.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to preserve unique home movies?

No. Mirroring can help you keep access to files if one drive fails, but it isn’t a separate backup. The Digital Preservation Coalition advises community archives to keep copies on different media, including at least one copy at another location.

Can you put existing drives containing films straight into a new NAS?

Don’t assume so. The Synology DS225+ installation guide warns that an installed drive containing data may be formatted and erased. Make another copy first and follow the instructions for the exact NAS model.

How can you check later that submitted films are still intact?

Record a checksum for each file when it arrives, then compare it with a newly calculated checksum during later checks. The Digital Preservation Coalition describes this method for detecting changes; a checksum doesn’t tell you what caused a file to change.

What should you check before sharing films online?

Assess privacy and copyright separately before making films public. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in footage are personal data; Auteursrechtnl states that digitising and making protected work available online generally requires permission, with exceptions that come with their own conditions.

Do you need to buy drives as well as a NAS enclosure?

Check the specific offer and its package contents. The DS1525+ offer reviewed stated that HDDs were not included. Also check that the drive models are compatible with your NAS, and include separate backup storage in your plan.