Choose a NAS based on how quickly you expect your archive to grow, the number of drive bays you need and the network connection required to retrieve or share projects. Also plan a separate physical backup at another location, and test whether you can restore your files from it: RAID alone is no substitute for a backup. Before buying, check drive compatibility and whether drives are included with the model.
Who is this buying guide for?
Creator with a growing project archive
You want to store raw footage and completed projects in an organised way, so you can find them later. Work out how much usable capacity you need now and how much room you want for expansion. Synology and Neat Video explain some of the considerations around expansion and capacity.
Creator who puts recovery first
You want to avoid relying on cloud storage and are able to keep and test a separate backup. Drive redundancy alone isn’t enough. Synology and the National Cyber Security Centre highlight the importance of backups and recovery tests.
Small video team
You share large project files locally, so you need to assess the network connection and access permissions as well as capacity. QNAP and UGREEN describe network options, while the National Cyber Security Centre covers security measures.
What should you look for when buying?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovery without the cloud |
Can you keep a second physical storage device at another location and test recovery regularly? |
If you don’t want the NAS to hold the only copy of your video projects, prioritise recoverability; around 33% of consumers consider this their main concern. |
| Usable capacity |
Work out the available space for your chosen drives and storage configuration; check the number of bays and any expansion options. |
If your archive is growing, you’ll want to know how much space will be left with your chosen configuration and whether you can expand later; around 27% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Local transfers |
Compare the network ports on the NAS, workstation and any intermediate equipment with how often you retrieve or share large files. |
If you regularly transfer large files or share them with others, consider the connections across your entire local network; around 20% of consumers prioritise this kind of access. |
| Management and privacy |
Check whether drives are included, who will have access, and what security and backup arrangements you’ll need to manage yourself. |
If you manage storage locally, you’ll want to know who can access your files and which tasks are your responsibility; around 20% of consumers put managing their own storage and privacy first. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming raw terabytes are the same as usable archive space
Your chosen RAID configuration and volume use storage space, so the room left for files may be less than the combined capacity of the drives.
Work out the usable space for your planned drives and configuration before choosing a NAS enclosure.
Allow for the drives you need and, with some models, a separately sold expansion unit.
-
Using a NAS with RAID as your only backup
RAID doesn’t protect against every kind of file loss or the loss of the entire NAS. What’s more, an untested backup gives you no certainty that you’ll be able to recover your projects.
Keep a physical copy at another location and test recovery using files from your video archive.
A separate backup device, along with maintaining and testing the copy, requires extra management.
-
Assuming a high network specification guarantees editing speed
The speed of a NAS port doesn’t tell you how fast the complete connection or your workflow will be. Manufacturer measurements apply to specific configurations.
Choose a faster connection only for a specific transfer or sharing scenario, and check that the rest of your network can support it.
You may also need to upgrade your workstation or network equipment.
Brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS925+ reviewed here has four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Synology also explains local versions and backups to a separate destination.
- Synology describes an expansion option using the separately sold DX525.
- Check drive compatibility. Published throughput figures are based on manufacturer tests and aren’t a guarantee for your setup.
QNAP
The TS-464 reviewed here has four drive bays and two built-in 2.5GbE ports. QNAP also mentions an optional 10GbE expansion card.
- The connection options described may be useful if you share or retrieve files locally.
- HDDs and SSDs for the configuration described are sold separately. QNAP’s speed claims apply to specific configurations.
ASUSTOR
The AS5404T reviewed here has four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports for locally accessible archive files.
- ASUSTOR lists expandable system memory.
- The speed quoted for SMB Multichannel is a manufacturer measurement taken under specific conditions, not a prediction for every setup.
TerraMaster
The F4-424 Pro reviewed here has four drive bays and, according to the specifications, supports 3.5-inch SATA HDDs and 2.5-inch SATA HDDs or SSDs.
- The official specifications list 32 GB of installed system memory.
- The maximum raw storage capacity may change; usable space also depends on the RAID configuration you choose.
UGREEN
According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP4800 Plus reviewed here has a 10GbE port and a 2.5GbE port.
- The 10GbE connection may be useful if the rest of your local network equipment supports it.
- UGREEN states that the model reviewed here is supplied without storage drives. The network specification isn’t an independent workflow test.
NAS models at Joybuy
These models are designed for a local video archive that can grow over time; the versions described differ in their drive bays, included drives and network options.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
Well suited to a growing local archive if you’re looking for multiple drive bays and a network option for local transfers.
Five drive bays; according to the product description, expandable to 15 drives.
Two 2.5GbE ports. HDDs aren’t included; check that your chosen drives are compatible.
A NAS configuration isn’t a substitute for a separate physical backup at another location; test recovery from that copy.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS423+
Well suited to a central video archive if you value included drives and the ability to restore earlier file versions.
Four bays with four included 12 TB HDDs; the product description lists 48 TB.
The product description mentions Btrfs snapshots and two 1GbE LAN ports. Snapshots aren’t a substitute for a separate physical backup at another location.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS
Well suited to an archive where you need plenty of drive bays and options for sharing or retrieving files locally.
Eight drive bays; the product description mentions expansion using an expansion unit.
Two 2.5GbE ports; a 10GbE card is listed as an optional upgrade.
Also plan a separate physical backup at another location and test recovery.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID enough to back up my video projects?
No. Drive redundancy can help with certain drive failures, but you should also keep a separate copy at another location for recovery. Test whether you can open files from it.
Can I keep a backup at another location without using the cloud?
Yes. You can store a physical external drive or another separate storage device elsewhere. Plan how often you’ll update the copy, keep it secure and test recovery.
What should I check when installing NAS drives?
Check that your chosen drives are compatible with the exact NAS model, and work out the usable space for your storage configuration. Western Digital recommends Red Plus and Red Pro CMR drives for ZFS systems; also check the drive requirements set by the NAS manufacturer.
What else do I need besides the NAS enclosure?
Check whether the model includes HDDs, and allow for a separate backup device. Depending on the model, you may also need an expansion unit or changes to your network.