Who is this NAS setup for?

Manager of a long-term video archive

You want to be able to find and restore source files, final versions and their context in the future. The National Archives describes organising and describing material as part of digital archiving, so storage space alone does not make a collection easy to access.

Editor of large video files

You regularly move large project files and want to take the connection between your NAS, workstation and network into account. QNAP, ASUSTOR and UGREEN list different network ports for their models, but the entire connection matters.

Coordinator of shared access

You need to give colleagues access without making every file available to everyone. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites permissions and software maintenance as examples of security measures. Footage featuring identifiable people can also raise privacy questions.

What should you look for when buying?

First, calculate how much usable space you need, including expected growth. Then plan for recovery and organisation. Assess network ports only in combination with your workstation, switch and cabling.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should consider this?
Recovery after loss or an error Check for version recovery and a separate backup destination; test that you can restore files. If irreplaceable source footage needs to remain recoverable, you should not rely on a single copy. Around 29% of consumers say recovery is their main concern when buying.
Usable capacity and room to grow Compare the space available after choosing your drive configuration, and allow for new projects. Check drive compatibility for the exact model. If source videos, project files and exports are all growing, you’ll want enough usable space for future projects. Around 23% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Transfers during editing Assess the NAS port, workstation, switch and cabling as one connection; a port specification does not guarantee real-world speeds. If you regularly move large files while actively editing, the entire network route matters. Around 18% of consumers give transfer speed top priority.
Controlled collaboration Check accounts, folder permissions and software maintenance; separately decide which footage may be kept or shared. If several creators contribute, you’ll want to make files accessible without giving everyone the same permissions. Around 18% of consumers prioritise managing shared access.
Finding files over the long term Decide who selects and describes the material, and how source files and final versions will be organised. If you want a future archive manager to be able to locate and understand the material, you’ll need a workflow as well as storage. Around 12% of consumers prioritise being able to find files.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying a NAS for an archive

  • Mistaking maximum raw capacity for project storage

    As Synology points out, the amount of space you can actually use depends on your chosen drives and RAID configuration.

    List your current files and expected growth. Then calculate the usable capacity of your planned drive configuration before choosing a model.

  • Treating RAID or snapshots as a complete backup plan

    A drive configuration and local versions do not protect against every risk, such as accidental deletion or damage to the storage itself. The National Archives also stresses that archiving involves selecting, organising and describing material.

    Set up a separate backup destination, test file recovery and agree who will organise and describe the collection. Synology recommends backing up to a separate destination.

  • Choosing a fast NAS port without checking the rest of your network

    The NAS port is just one part of the connection. The product specifications from QNAP, ASUSTOR and UGREEN do not, on their own, indicate the editing speeds you’ll achieve.

    Check the entire connection between your NAS and workstation, including the switch and cabling, before comparing port specifications.

    Depending on your existing setup, a faster connection may also require a suitable switch, cabling or workstation connection.

  • Making all footage accessible as soon as the NAS is up and running

    If people are identifiable, the GDPR may apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites permissions and software maintenance as examples of appropriate security measures.

    Set access permissions for each group and check the rights to images and sound before sharing a public version.

NAS brands to compare

Synology

Synology describes the DS225+ as a two-bay model with a 2.5GbE port, and the DS925+ as a model with four drive bays.

  • Synology documents backup destinations and version recovery, though these features need to be configured appropriately.
  • Check drive compatibility for the exact model. Usable capacity also depends on the drives and configuration.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-464 as a four-bay NAS and lists two 2.5GbE ports.

  • QNAP lists file management, backup and collaboration among the model’s uses.
  • Your choice of drives and configuration, along with a separate backup, will all help determine how well the setup suits an archive.

ASUSTOR

According to the official specifications, the AS5402T has two drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports and four M.2 slots.

  • This combination may appeal if you’re looking for both a compact enclosure and faster network ports.
  • Two drive bays offer less internal room to grow than the four-bay models listed here. A port specification does not guarantee the editing speeds you’ll achieve.

UGREEN

UGREEN lists four drive bays for the NASync DXP4800 Plus, along with both a 10GbE and a 2.5GbE port.

  • The 10GbE port is worth comparing if your workstation and network can also support that connection.
  • Port specifications are not an independent measure of transfer speeds in your project setup. You’ll also need to consider the drives separately.

Joybuy NAS models for project storage

These models are designed for central storage and sharing of project files, with different setup options. Check which drives, configuration and network connection are right for your archive.

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Consider this model when comparing options if expansion capacity and shared project files are important. Match the drive configuration and network connection to the way you work.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1525+

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

This option could suit an archive setup where expansion capacity and shared project files matter. Hard drives are not included and must be chosen separately.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology describes the DS925+ as a four-bay model, making it worth comparing if you want to plan for future storage needs. Hard drives are not included; check which drives are compatible with this model too.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about NAS devices for video archives

Is a mirrored drive the same as a backup?

No. A drive configuration that can protect you if a drive fails does not replace a copy on a separate destination to guard against issues such as accidental deletion or damage. Plan for version recovery and test that you can restore a file.

How do I work out how much storage my video archive needs?

Add up your source files, project files and exports, and allow for future projects. Then compare the usable capacity of your chosen drives and configuration. The raw capacity of the drives will not necessarily all be available for project storage.

What should I look for in a NAS with a fast network port?

Check the entire connection between your NAS and workstation, including the switch and cabling. A fast NAS port alone does not guarantee higher transfer speeds if the rest of the network does not support that connection.

Can our community archive store and publish footage featuring identifiable people?

It depends on the material and how it is processed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that a GDPR legal basis may be needed to create and publish images of an organisation or event in which people are identifiable. Consent is one possible example, but it is not the only legal basis. Also review access security and how long personal data needs to be retained.

Can we include other people’s music or images in a public archive version without permission?

No, not without the necessary rights. The Dutch government states that you need the creator’s permission to use copyright-protected films, photos and music. A copy for personal use does not give you the right to distribute or make the work available to the public.