Who is this choice relevant to?

Keeper of one-of-a-kind photo scans

You want to know in advance how to restore scans after deletion, damage or drive failure. Synology Knowledge Centre warns that a NAS volume cannot protect against every cause of data loss.

NAS owner

You want to add or replace a drive and need to check that the full model number is supported by your NAS. Synology and QNAP publish compatibility information for their systems.

Collector with a growing scan library

You want room for your current scan folders and future additions, and you’re factoring in the space used by a mirrored setup.

What should you look for?

Internal NAS HDD

A good choice if: you already have a suitable NAS, or want to use one to store scans from your laptop in a central location on your network.

Things to consider: an internal SATA drive is not portable USB storage. You’ll need a NAS enclosure and a separate backup as part of your overall setup.

External USB drive

A good choice if: you want to copy scans straight from your portable workstation or take your storage with you.

Things to consider: a USB drive is not an internal NAS HDD, and on its own it is not an independent second copy either.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should consider this most?
Recoverable copies Decide where your original scans and backup will be stored. Check that you can restore files from the backup. With one-of-a-kind scans, I want to know how to restore files after a drive failure. Around 36% of consumers put recoverability first.
NAS compatibility Check the full HDD model number, form factor and connection against the information for your NAS model. If I’m adding or replacing a drive, I want to know first whether the exact model is supported. Around 29% of consumers put NAS compatibility first.
Room for your photo collection Compare the size of your current scans and expected growth with the capacity of the exact model. If you’re mirroring, allow for the space needed by the second drive. For a growing scan folder, I want to leave enough usable space, even if I mirror it. Capacity and room to grow come first for around 21% of consumers.
Transferring from your workstation Decide whether you’ll copy files over the network to a NAS or connect the storage directly via USB. I want to be able to copy scans straight from my portable workstation. Around 14% of consumers put direct transfer first.

Buying pitfalls

  • Mistaking a mirrored pair for a full backup

    Copies on the same NAS won’t protect against every type of data loss. Synology Knowledge Centre warns that drive failure can also lead to serious loss.

    Before you buy, decide how you’ll make a separate backup as well, and check that you can restore it.

    A separate storage destination takes extra storage space and time to check that you can restore your files.

  • Choosing by brand, series or capacity alone

    Compatibility can depend on the full drive model, the NAS model and, for some product ranges, the software version.

    Compare the full model number with your NAS’s compatibility information.

    If the combination isn’t compatible, you may need a different drive or NAS setup.

  • Ordering an internal NAS HDD when you need a portable drive

    An internal SATA drive is different from an external drive that connects directly via USB.

    First decide whether you’ll copy scans to a NAS at home or connect the storage directly to your workstation.

    An internal NAS HDD requires a suitable NAS setup; direct USB use calls for a different connection solution.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

Western Digital describes WD Red Plus as a range of 3.5-inch NAS HDDs. The manufacturer documents, among other models, the 4 TB WD40EFPX variant.

  • The manufacturer lists CMR and SATA for the models mentioned.
  • Check the full model number against your NAS’s compatibility information. Manufacturer specifications are not an independent test of a photo archive.

Synology

According to Synology, the HAT3300-4T is an internal 4 TB drive for Synology storage systems.

  • The model specifications list 3.5 inches, SATA, 5,400 rpm and a three-year manufacturer’s warranty.
  • Check your specific NAS model. The policy on third-party drives varies by product range and software version.

Seagate

Seagate describes IronWolf as a range of NAS HDDs for network storage with multiple drive bays. ST12000VN0008 is a documented 12 TB model.

  • Seagate specifies CMR for the range and SATA for this model.
  • Any data recovery service does not replace a backup, and availability varies by country.

Toshiba

Toshiba Storage Solutions describes the N300 as a range of 3.5-inch SATA drives for NAS storage, including archiving, with a 4 TB capacity option.

  • The EMEA product page lists 7,200 rpm and a three-year manufacturer’s warranty for the range.
  • Check the specifications of the exact model and its compatibility with your NAS. A range specification does not automatically apply to every model.

Products for NAS and USB storage

These product options include internal NAS drives for central storage and external USB drives for direct connection to a portable workstation.

Synology 16 TB SATA HDD, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

An internal NAS drive for anyone who wants to store a larger scan collection centrally using a Synology system.

  • 16 TB, 3.5 inches and SATA
  • 7,200 rpm and CMR

Check the full drive model against your NAS’s compatibility information.

View at Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB with 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

An internal NAS drive for anyone looking to store scans on a compatible NAS and wanting 6 TB of capacity.

  • 3.5-inch SATA
  • 5,400 rpm and NASware
  • 256 MB cache

Check the full drive model against your NAS’s compatibility information.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB NAS HDD

WD Red Plus 8 TB, CMR

An internal NAS HDD for anyone looking to store a scan collection centrally using a compatible NAS.

  • 8 TB and 3.5 inches
  • CMR, SATA 6 Gb/s and 256 MB cache
  • 5,640 rpm

Check the full drive model against your NAS’s compatibility information.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black external USB drive

Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black

An external drive for anyone who wants to save or take scans with them directly from a laptop, without copying them via a NAS first.

  • 2 TB and USB 3.2 Gen 1
  • Bus-powered with hardware AES encryption

An external drive is not, on its own, a separate second copy.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB external hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB

An external drive for anyone who wants to transfer scans directly from a computer or take them with them.

  • 4 TB and 2.5 inches
  • Micro-USB B, USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1 and bus-powered

An external drive is not, on its own, a separate second copy.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I connect an internal NAS drive directly to my laptop via USB?

No. The internal drives discussed here have a SATA connection and are designed to be installed in a suitable device. If you want to connect your storage directly or take it with you, choose an external USB drive.

Is a mirrored NAS enough to protect my photo scans?

No, a mirrored NAS is not the same as a separate backup. Keep another copy on a different storage destination and check that you can restore your files. Synology Knowledge Centre warns that drive failure can also lead to serious data loss.

Do I always need to buy a drive from the NAS brand itself?

Not as a general rule: check compatibility for your NAS model and software version. For example, Synology says there is greater support for third-party drives on certain DiskStation Plus models running DSM 7.3; other ranges may have different rules. QNAP also publishes compatibility information.

What do the manufacturer’s warranty and statutory guarantee mean when buying in the Netherlands?

The manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your rights against the seller. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands; if a product is faulty, the seller is your point of contact. A drive warranty does not mean lost photos will be recovered.

Does privately storing and sharing family photos fall under the GDPR?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, photos that someone keeps privately or shares with only a very limited group are covered by the exception for personal or household use. This exception does not necessarily apply if you share images with a wider audience or for business purposes.