A NAS with one drive bay could be a good fit if desk space is your priority and you also arrange a separate, recoverable copy. Two bays let you mirror drives, but mirroring is no substitute for a backup stored elsewhere. Also consider the space needed for the enclosure, cables and ventilation, and check with your school how pupil data should be stored.
Who is a desktop NAS suitable for?
Teachers who want to be able to recover files
If you want to copy lesson plans and presentations automatically, you should also keep a separate copy and test that you can restore it. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends making backups and checking that files can be restored.
Teachers with a small desk
Compare the dimensions of the enclosure, and allow for connections and ventilation space too. The size of the case alone does not tell you how much free space the whole setup will need in practice.
Teachers with pupil data in their files
If your teaching materials contain personal data, check with your school in advance which storage options and security measures are permitted. A personal NAS is not automatically suitable for these files.
What should you consider when choosing?
One drive bay
A good fit when: you have limited desk space and arrange a separate, recoverable copy elsewhere.
Trade-off: there is no second internal drive bay for mirroring; recovery depends on another copy.
Two drive bays
A good fit when: you want to be able to mirror two internal drives and the enclosure fits on your desk.
Trade-off: mirroring requires two suitable drives and does not protect against losing the NAS location or unwanted changes.
First decide how you will restore files and where you will keep a separate copy. Then compare the space available, the number of drive bays and the cost of the complete setup.
| Point to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most relevant to? |
| Recoverable backups |
Check for scheduled folder backups, a separate copy and the option to test restoring your files. |
Want to restore lesson plans and presentations after losing them? Consumers who prioritise being able to recover their files account for around 28% of the buyers concerned. |
| Desk space |
Compare the width and depth of the enclosure, and leave room for cables and ventilation. |
If your workspace is small, you will want to know whether the complete setup will fit. Consumers who prioritise desk space account for around 22% of the buyers concerned. |
| A routine you can stick to |
Check support for your computer, scheduled backups, and how to test alerts and file recovery. |
Want to make copying, checking and restoring files part of your routine? Consumers who prioritise ease of use account for around 22% of the buyers concerned. |
| Storing personal data |
Ask which storage locations and security measures your school allows for files containing pupil data. |
If your materials contain pupil data, storage must comply with your school’s policies and security measures. Consumers for whom this is a deciding factor account for around 17% of the buyers concerned. |
| Total cost |
Check whether internal drives are included, and factor in a separate backup destination. |
Want to consider the cost of the enclosure, drives and a second destination together? Consumers who prioritise total cost account for around 11% of the buyers concerned. |
Common pitfalls
-
Mistaking mirroring for a separate backup
Two mirrored drives are still in the same location. If you lose that location or unwanted changes are made, the copy could be lost too.
Also arrange a backup in another location and test that you can restore your files.
A separate destination requires extra storage and management.
-
Measuring only the NAS width
The enclosure also takes up depth, while connections and ventilation require extra clearance.
Measure the available width and depth, and leave room for cables and ventilation.
-
Assuming a personal NAS is automatically suitable for pupil data
Storing files that contain personal data requires appropriate policies and security measures. The school must be able to demonstrate that it is meeting its responsibilities.
Keep personal teaching materials separate from files containing pupil data, and check with your school in advance how the latter should be stored.
Brands to compare
Synology
The DS124 has one drive bay, while the DS223j has two. Synology says Drive supports scheduled backups of PC folders on these models.
- The different models give you a choice of one or two internal drive bays.
- The DS124 has no second internal bay for mirroring. The software features described are manufacturer claims, not the result of a comparative hands-on test.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay model worth comparing if you take the enclosure and supported drive types into account.
- According to QNAP, the model supports 3.5-inch SATA hard drives and 2.5-inch SATA SSDs.
- The case dimensions do not tell you how much room you will need for cables and positioning.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model to include in your comparison if desk space and mirroring matter to you.
- ASUSTOR lists RAID 1 and 3.5-inch SATA HDDs as supported internal drive options.
- The stated 18,6 dB figure applies when the HDD is idle and does not indicate how loud the device is during a backup.
NAS products on Joybuy
These NAS options are intended for comparison when backing up teaching materials. Check the space you have for each model, as well as which drives and backup destination you will need.
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
An option to compare if you want to store and back up computer files on a NAS.
Supplied without drives; check which compatible drives you will need.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+
A NAS option to compare if you are looking for central file storage and backup features.
Hard drives are not included; check which drives are right for your needs.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives
An option to compare if you are looking for a NAS for backups and file management.
This version is supplied without hard drives; also allow space for connections and ventilation.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
A NAS option to compare for file management and backups from multiple devices.
Before buying, check that the enclosure will fit, with enough room for connections and ventilation.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 on a NAS the same as a backup?
No. Mirroring across two internal drives can help if one drive fails, but you should also keep a separate copy in another location and test that you can restore your files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups; this is not a legal requirement for every buyer.
What should you test after setting up your NAS?
Check that the backup software reports a successful backup, and carry out a restore as well. Open a few restored files to make sure your teaching materials are back.
What extra costs should you expect beyond the NAS enclosure?
Check which suitable internal drives you still need, and how you will arrange a separate copy in another location. The total cost depends on the drives and destination you choose.
Can you store pupil data on your personal NAS?
A personal NAS is not automatically permitted or prohibited. If files contain personal data, the school must be able to demonstrate that it has appropriate technical and organisational measures in place; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains schools’ accountability obligations. Ask your school which storage and backup destination it allows before copying any such data.