Who is a NAS suitable for?

Spreadsheet user who needs to restore files

You regularly edit important workbooks and want to be able to restore an earlier version if something goes wrong. The National Cyber Security Centre discusses the importance of backups, while Synology explains version control for the DS225+.

Self-employed professional with multiple devices

You want to protect document folders on more than one computer automatically, and manage security and access yourself. Synology describes PC folder backups for the DS223j; the Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that appropriate security depends on the circumstances.

User with limited desk space

You’re looking for a NAS setup for documents and need to consider the space available, the drives you’ll need and the cost. ID.nl’s buying guide and the product specifications from QNAP and ASUSTOR can help you compare models and setups.

What should you look for when buying?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restoring an earlier version Check for version control or snapshots, and try restoring a spreadsheet. If I need a usable version after overwriting or deleting a file, I focus on the recovery options; around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to restore files.
Automatic backups Check that your computer is supported, along with the folders you’ve selected, the schedule and notifications if a task fails. When I regularly edit workbooks, I don’t want to rely on copying files manually; around 27% of consumers give automatic backups top priority.
Desk space Compare the dimensions of the exact model with the space available, allowing room for connections and ventilation. With limited free space, I want to know whether the enclosure will fit comfortably without cluttering my workspace; around 20% of consumers focus mainly on where the NAS will sit.
Total cost of the setup Check whether drives are included and what additional storage you’ll need for your chosen configuration and a separate backup. If I’m paying for the whole backup setup, I want to include the drives I need and any second storage location; around 20% of consumers prioritise the total cost.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking RAID or a single central storage location for a complete backup

    Drive mirroring doesn’t protect against every cause of file loss. A deleted or edited spreadsheet may also be missing from, or changed on, the other mirrored drive.

    Plan a separate copy as well, and try restoring a spreadsheet to make sure it works.

    A second storage location means extra storage costs, and testing recovery takes time.

  • Assuming the price of a diskless NAS is the total cost of the setup

    The UGREEN models mentioned don’t include storage drives. The enclosure alone isn’t a complete storage setup.

    Compare configurations that include the drives you need and any storage for a separate copy.

  • Mistaking the standby noise rating for the noise level during backups

    ASUSTOR quotes 19 dB for standby; this doesn’t tell you how loud the NAS is during an active spreadsheet backup.

    Check the conditions under which the measurement was taken, and think about where you can place the NAS with enough ventilation.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS223j and DS225+ are models worth comparing if you’re looking for document backups and recovery options.

  • Synology describes PC folder backups for the DS223j and version control for the DS225+.
  • For the DS225+, check that your chosen drives and DSM version meet your requirements.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model. QNAP describes HBS 3 as a tool for backup, recovery and synchronisation tasks.

  • The software includes backup, recovery and synchronisation tasks.
  • When setting it up, distinguish between synchronising files and creating a backup that lets you restore older files. QNAP lists one gigabit network port for the TS-233.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model with backup and snapshot features.

  • The manufacturer lists snapshot and backup features.
  • According to ASUSTOR, the quoted 19 dB applies to standby, not an active backup. Also check drive compatibility and how you’ll restore files.

UGREEN

The NASync DH2300 and DXP2800 offer different features and networking options.

  • According to UGREEN, the DXP2800 adds features including 2,5GbE and extra application options.
  • The product pages mentioned state that storage drives aren’t included. Only choose extra features if you need them.

NAS models at Joybuy

These NAS models at Joybuy offer backup options along with extra drive bays or expansion options. Check that their size and features suit your desk and how you plan to use them.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

This NAS is worth considering if you want to combine spreadsheet backups with extra drive bays and room to expand.

Five drive bays, expandable to fifteen. The product information lists backup tools in DSM and desktop placement. Dimensions: 165,5 × 241 × 297,9 mm. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

This model could suit you if you need several drive bays as well as spreadsheet backups; compare its dimensions with your desk beforehand.

Eight drive bays and two 2,5GbE ports. The product information lists DSM tools for files and backups, as well as desktop placement. Dimensions: 45 × 36 × 30 cm.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

This version is worth considering if you want to combine backups with several drive bays; check the stated dimensions against the space you have available.

Four drive bays, expandable to nine, and two 2,5GbE ports. The product information lists DSM backup features and desktop placement. Dimensions: 29 × 26 × 24 cm. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up your spreadsheets?

No, RAID 1 doesn’t replace a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping an extra copy and testing recovery so you can check that you can restore the file you need.

How can you check that your NAS backup is working?

Check that the backup task completes successfully, then restore a test file. Open the restored spreadsheet to make sure its contents are usable; the National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing recovery in practice.

What costs should you expect on top of the NAS enclosure?

Check whether drives are included and factor in the drives for your chosen configuration. Also allow for storage for a separate backup if you need one.

Does the GDPR set requirements for your spreadsheet backups?

If your organisation processes personal data, you must protect it appropriately. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that the right measures depend on the circumstances; the contents of your workbooks and how you use them are relevant too.

Does your NAS need to be accessible over the internet?

No, you don’t need internet access for a local backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends avoiding direct internet access to a NAS where possible, because it creates an additional security risk. First decide whether you really need remote access.