Who is a NAS for a society archive suitable for?

Volunteers who need to be able to restore documents

If you manage meeting minutes or other society documents, you’ll want to be able to restore a usable version if something is deleted, changed or affected by a fault. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends automating backups and keeping copies in multiple locations.

Administrators of confidential membership records

You may store personal data, so you’ll need to decide who has access and how long it needs to be kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that personal data must be properly secured.

Administrators of a growing collection

For an archive containing scans and photos, for example, it helps to consider its current size, expected growth and how much room you’d like for expansion. Synology offers models with different numbers of drive bays, including the DS1525+.

What should you look for when choosing?

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit when: the calculated usable capacity is enough for your archive and expected growth, and you also have a separate backup.

Bear in mind: there’s less room for internal expansion. RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

NAS with more drive bays

A good fit when: a larger collection or expected growth calls for more room to expand internally.

Bear in mind: additional drives and bays require more capacity planning and management. You’ll still need a separate, restorable backup.

What to consider What to check before buying Who should prioritise this?
Restorable backups Check whether you can schedule tasks, which versions are retained, where a separate copy is stored and how to test a restore. If I need a usable version quickly after a mistake or fault, I put recoverability first. Around 33% of consumers give recovery top priority.
Access and privacy Check user and folder permissions, administrator accounts, updates and encryption where appropriate for your chosen storage setup. Also record the purpose and retention period for each type of data. If membership records contain personal data, I want to limit access to people who need it for their role. Around 27% of consumers put confidentiality first.
Usable capacity and expansion Plan for the archive’s current size, expected growth, the version history you want to keep, the number of drive bays and compatible drives. Raw drive capacity is not the same as usable storage. If scans and photos keep accumulating, I want to plan for enough usable storage without relying on raw drive capacity alone. Around 20% of consumers put archive growth first.
Management that can be handed over Check whether backup tasks can be scheduled, whether errors are visible and whether restore steps can be clearly documented. If volunteers take turns, I want a successor to be able to check that backups are running and understand how to restore files. Around 20% of consumers give easy handover of management top priority.

Common pitfalls when choosing a NAS for a society archive

  • Thinking two drives amount to a complete backup strategy

    RAID can help if a drive fails, but it won’t protect against every situation in which documents are lost or become unusable. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping backups in multiple locations.

    Set up a separate backup and test that you can restore both a file and the backup itself.

  • Calculating storage from raw capacity or assuming drives are included

    The storage configuration you choose and the space used for retained versions affect how much storage is usable. According to QNAP’s official specifications, the QNAP TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. Check this for the specific version you’re considering.

    Calculate usable capacity for your chosen configuration and check which components are included with the model.

  • Keeping all membership records indefinitely

    The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that the GDPR does not set a specific, general retention period for personal data. Rules for government archives do not automatically apply as retention periods for society records.

    Separate your archive into categories and record the purpose, access arrangements and justified retention period for each one.

Brands to consider

Synology

Worth considering if you want to compare document and backup features in models with two or more drive bays.

  • Synology describes the DS225+ as suitable for backing up multiple endpoints. The DS1525+ has five drive bays.
  • Check the hard drive compatibility information for the model you choose. The number of bays alone won’t tell you how much capacity your society needs.

QNAP

Worth considering if you want to explore a two-bay NAS with configurable backup tasks, such as the TS-264-8G.

  • QNAP lists two drive bays and two 2,5GbE ports for the TS-264-8G. According to QNAP, Hybrid Backup Sync supports scheduled backup tasks.
  • The official specifications state that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. Also check that your chosen setup and restore steps are suitable for your archive.

TerraMaster

Worth considering if you want to compare different built-in copying options in a two-bay NAS, such as the F2-424.

  • For the F2-424, TerraMaster lists features including Centralized Backup, Snapshot and CloudSync.
  • Feature descriptions don’t guarantee that a backup task or restore will work for your archive. Test your chosen setup yourself.

ASUSTOR

Worth considering if you want to set up local, off-site or cloud backups using NAS management software.

  • ASUSTOR documents backups through ADM to an external USB drive, another ASUSTOR NAS or supported cloud services.
  • Check which features are available for the specific model and what support status applies.

NAS models at Joybuy

This Joybuy selection is aimed at societies looking to plan for extra room to expand their archive’s internal storage.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

An option for a society archive that needs more room to expand its internal storage.

Synology lists five drive bays, expandable to fifteen with an expansion unit. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option for a society looking to plan for plenty of internal expansion as its collection grows.

The product information lists file-sharing and backup options through DSM.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

An option for a society weighing up expandable internal storage for a collection that may grow.

The product information lists four drive bays, expandable to nine with a DX525 expansion unit. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about a NAS for a society archive

Is RAID the same as a backup?

No. The National Cyber Security Centre explains that RAID can help if a drive fails, but it doesn’t replace a separate backup. Make sure you also document how to restore an individual file and a full backup.

How do you set up a NAS for volunteers?

Give users access only to the documents they need for their role, change the default passwords during setup and decide carefully whether internet access is necessary. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends avoiding direct access to a NAS over the internet wherever possible.

How long should membership data stay in the archive?

The GDPR does not set a specific, general retention period for personal data, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. Decide and document how long each type of data needs to be kept. Different rules may apply to certain documents.

What else should you consider as part of your setup?

Check whether hard drives are included and plan for a separate backup. The official specifications for the QNAP TS-264-8G state that this model is supplied without hard drives. The extra storage you need will depend on your setup and the version history you want to keep.

Do you need a data processing agreement for a cloud backup?

If a service provider processes personal data on behalf of your society and acts as a processor, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says a written data processing agreement is required. First establish the role of the specific service provider.