A NAS is a good fit for a group that wants to share recipes in one managed location, provided someone is responsible for accounts, updates and backups. Focus on access controls and recovery options when comparing models. RAID can provide data redundancy, but it is not a backup, which is why the NCSC and Synology recommend keeping a separate backup. If no one can maintain the device, compare shared cloud services too, and review their terms and data processing practices.
Who is a NAS for sharing recipes suitable for?
A group compiling recipes
You want to bring contributions from several members together in one place and decide who can read or edit files. Check user accounts and folder permissions; Synology and QNAP describe features for file sharing and access management.
Recipe archive administrator
You want to be able to retrieve previous files and manage a backup stored separately from the NAS. The NCSC warns that centralised storage is not a backup in itself; drive redundancy does not replace a backup either.
A group with personal data
If documents contain names, contact details or allergy information linked to individuals, consider who needs access and how long the data should be kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists allergy information as a possible type of personal data.
What should you look for when choosing?
Own NAS
Best suited when: the group wants to manage its own files and someone can take care of accounts, updates and backups.
Keep in mind: setup and ongoing management, plus a separate backup destination.
Shared cloud service
Best suited when: no one in the group can set up and maintain a NAS on an ongoing basis.
Keep in mind: access management, recovery options, data processing and the ongoing costs of the service you choose.
| What to consider |
What to check before buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Sharing recipes with appropriate permissions |
Check individual accounts, folder permissions and access from group members' devices. |
If several members contribute recipes, I want to collect their contributions without giving everyone unrestricted editing rights. Around 31% of consumers prioritise shared access with appropriate permissions. |
| Recovering files |
Check whether you can retrieve previous versions, where a separate backup is stored and who checks the recovery process. |
I want to be able to retrieve a recipe after it has been deleted, changed by mistake or lost because of a faulty drive. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recovery options. |
| Access to personal data |
Consider which files contain personal data, who needs access and how long the group keeps them. |
If documents contain names, contact details or allergy information linked to someone, I want to be able to restrict access appropriately. Around 25% of consumers prioritise restricted access to personal data. |
| Purchase and management |
Check whether drives are included, which drives and backup destination you will need, and who will install updates. |
I want to know in advance which components and management tasks the group will need to organise. Around 19% of consumers prioritise the total cost and management workload. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming RAID is a complete backup
Drive redundancy does not protect against every cause of data loss. A deleted file or unwanted change can also affect mirrored storage.
Plan recoverable backups to a destination separate from the NAS, and agree who will check that files can be restored.
A separate backup destination also needs to be managed and checked regularly.
-
Giving all group members the same account or permissions
When login details are shared, it is harder to link access to individual members and their roles.
Decide in advance who will have read-only, contributor and administrator access, and give accounts only the permissions they need.
-
Making a faster network port the deciding factor
ASUSTOR lists a 2.5-Gigabit Ethernet port for the Drivestor 2 AS1102T. This specification alone does not prove there will be a practical benefit for small recipe files.
First decide whether the group will also transfer larger files, and check that the rest of the network can make use of the connection.
You may also need other compatible network equipment to make use of the higher network speed.
Brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay model for storing, sharing and backing up files, including documents.
- Synology lists Drive for browser access and file sharing, and describes support for multiple backup destinations.
- Check the drive configuration and set up a backup outside the NAS. The features mentioned will not protect files automatically unless they are configured.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay model for sharing and synchronising files.
- QNAP lists features for account security and snapshots.
- According to QNAP's specifications, the TS-233 has 2 GB of non-expandable memory and one Gigabit Ethernet port. Focus on how its document and backup features match the group's needs.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay model where the network connection may be a factor.
- ASUSTOR lists 2.5-Gigabit Ethernet and several backup options for this model.
- This specification does not guarantee a measured performance benefit for small recipe documents. Check that the entire network connection supports the higher speed.
NAS products on Joybuy
These NAS models from Joybuy are designed for centrally managing and sharing files. Check which drives are included with each model and how to set up a separate backup.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+
A model to consider if the group values file sharing and room to expand.
The description lists five drive bays, expandability and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included; plan a separate backup outside the NAS too.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
A model to consider if the group wants to use accounts and shared folders for collaborating on recipes.
The description lists two drive bays and RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD as configuration options. This is a diskless NAS, so drives are not included. RAID does not replace a separate backup.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
A model to consider if the group needs plenty of drive bays and file-sharing features.
The description lists eight drive bays, expandability and two 2.5GbE ports. Set up a separate backup outside the NAS as well.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
A model to consider if the group wants to combine file sharing with room to expand its storage.
The description lists four drive bays, expandability to nine bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included; plan a separate backup.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does a NAS with two mirrored drives also count as your backup?
No. Mirroring is not a substitute for a separate backup. The NCSC explains that RAID can help if a drive fails, but it is not a backup. Keep copies in a separate location and agree who will check that recovery works.
How do you set up a NAS for a group whose members change over time?
Create individual accounts and give members only the permissions they need. The NCSC also recommends changing the default settings and passwords during setup, keeping the NAS up to date and, preferably, not making the device directly accessible over the internet.
What costs should the group allow for beyond the NAS enclosure?
Check whether drives are included, and factor suitable drives and a separate backup destination into your setup. Agree who will maintain the device too; the components and management tasks required depend on the configuration you choose.
Does the GDPR apply to your recipes?
It depends on what they contain: names, contact details and information about someone's allergies may be personal data. If the group processes personal data, it must decide on appropriate security measures. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period for personal data, so the group must assess how long it is necessary to keep it.