Who is a NAS suitable for?

Volunteer safeguarding the collection

This volunteer wants to be able to recover catalogue files and photos after deletion, a fault or an incident. That makes a workable backup plan and regular recovery tests essential; the National Cyber Security Centre advises carrying out a recovery exercise.

Coordinator of a shared catalogue

This coordinator wants volunteers to work with the same files in a controlled way, with clear responsibility for access and administration. If the organisation processes personal data, it must protect that information appropriately; the Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights security as an important consideration for organisations.

Administrator of a growing image collection

This administrator needs to balance the number of drive bays and usable capacity against new photos and scans. Synology’s product specifications make clear that usable space depends on the drives and storage configuration, so it may not match the raw capacity.

What should you look for in a NAS for an archive?

First, decide how you’ll restore your catalogue and photos after data loss. Then measure the collection and estimate its growth to work out how many drive bays you need. Also make clear who is responsible for access, backups and checks.

Consideration What to look for Who is this most relevant to?
Restoring the catalogue and photos Check that the backup includes both catalogue data and linked photos, creates a separate copy and allows you to test recovery. If my main concern is preventing the catalogue and photos from being lost, I’ll prioritise recovery. Around 36% of consumers put recovery first.
Shared access and administration Check user permissions and appoint someone to handle updates, backups and recovery tests. Also establish whether the files contain personal data. When several volunteers work with the same files, I want access rights and administrative tasks to be clearly organised. Around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled collaboration.
Usable capacity and growth Measure the current files, estimate how much will be added and compare this with the usable capacity of the selected drives and configuration. If I’m expecting new photos and scans, I want to avoid running short of storage. Around 21% of consumers put future storage space first.
Administration and a complete setup Check whether drives are included, what separate backup destination you’ll need and who will carry out maintenance and recovery tests. A setup for a volunteer group also needs to remain manageable over the long term. Around 14% of consumers put ease of management first.

Common pitfalls when choosing a NAS for an archive

  • Mistaking two mirrored drives for two backups

    Mirrored drives are in the same NAS. This doesn’t automatically give you an independent copy for situations where the entire NAS or its location is affected.

    Remember to allow time to organise a separate storage location and test recovery.

    Plan a separate copy and a recovery test at the same time as setting up the NAS. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed and the National Cyber Security Centre distinguish between drive mirroring and a backup that you can restore.

  • Using the maximum raw capacity as your storage requirement

    Usable storage depends on the drives and storage configuration you choose. So a stated maximum doesn’t tell you how much space will actually be available for files.

    You may need additional or larger compatible drives.

    First, take stock of the collection and allow for expected growth. Then calculate the usable capacity for your chosen configuration.

  • Assuming the NAS enclosure is a complete archive setup

    An enclosure without drives provides no storage space and isn’t a separate backup in itself. Someone also needs to keep managing the setup.

    Allow for internal drives, a separate backup destination and the time needed for ongoing administration.

    Check which components are included and appoint someone to handle updates, backup tasks and recovery tests.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS for centralised files and backup tasks. The DS925+ has four drive bays and is an option if your measured growth calls for more space.

  • According to the product specifications, the DS225+ has a 2.5GbE port. The DS925+ can be expanded with a separately available unit.
  • Check drive compatibility and calculate the usable capacity for your chosen configuration; the maximum raw capacity doesn’t guarantee how much space will be available.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for centralised photos and files when shared storage is your starting point.

  • QNAP lists snapshots and account security among the TS-233’s features.
  • Feature descriptions don’t guarantee that you’ll be able to recover your files. Arrange a separate backup copy too, and test that the files can be restored.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay alternative for a smaller shared collection.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs/iSCSI snapshots and Gigabit Ethernet for this model.
  • The stated throughput figures are laboratory results under optimised conditions and may not reflect the network used by an archive.

NAS products at Joybuy

These NAS products are designed for central storage of catalogue files and photos, with options for a growing collection. Whichever model you choose, arrange a separate backup copy and test recovery too.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

Suitable for an archive that wants to share catalogue files centrally and allow for future expansion.

Hard drives aren’t included, so you’ll need to choose them separately. A NAS doesn’t replace a separate backup copy, so plan a recovery test too.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to consider if your inventory points to a larger or growing collection and you need to share files centrally.

The drives need to be chosen and installed separately. Plan a separate backup copy and test recovery as well.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, diskless

Synology DiskStation DS925+, diskless

An option to consider if you want to weigh up four drive bays against the measured size of your collection and its expected growth.

Hard drives and the expansion unit aren’t included. You’ll still need a separate backup copy and a recovery test.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about NAS backups for an archive

Is RAID 1 enough to back up the catalogue?

No. Mirrored drives in a single NAS aren’t a separate backup. Keep another copy on a different medium or at another location, and test that catalogue files and photos can be restored. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed warns that RAID is no substitute for a backup.

What should volunteers do regularly after installation?

Appoint someone to manage access and maintenance, check that backup tasks are succeeding and carry out recovery exercises. During a test, open relevant files too, to check that the right parts of the collection have been included. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing recovery.

Are hard drives and a separate backup included with a NAS enclosure?

Not necessarily. Check which components are included with each product and, if needed, arrange internal drives and a separate backup destination. An enclosure on its own isn’t a complete backup setup.

Does the GDPR apply to photos or names in a community archive?

If photos show identifiable people or information can be linked to living people, it may be personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations must protect personal data properly. Appropriate measures and retention periods depend on the content and how it is processed; the GDPR doesn’t set a specific retention period for all personal data.

Is a NAS on its own a complete system for long-term digital preservation?

No. Long-term accessibility may also require agreements on metadata and file formats, regular checks and responsible ongoing management. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed describes a digital repository as a combination of software, rules and processes.