A NAS is worth considering if you regularly want to access scans from several devices or save them centrally and automatically. For a small project on one computer, an external drive may be simpler. Synology describes automatic backups of computer folders, while the National Cyber Security Centre’s backup guidance stresses the importance of checking that you can restore your files. RAID or synchronisation is no substitute for a separate backup.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Student with irreplaceable scans
You want to be able to retrieve scans and earlier project versions after a mistake or equipment failure. So, look beyond the number of drive bays and consider the backup and recovery options too. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a backup must also be usable for recovery.
Student on a tight budget
You’re storing a specific project and want to weigh up whether network storage is worth the extra drives and management. Check whether the enclosure comes with drives, and factor in a separate backup as well.
Student who works across several devices
You want to access and organise scans from, for example, a laptop and a home computer. Synology and QNAP describe file-sharing features; check that the software and access options suit the devices you use.
What should you look for when buying?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Being able to recover scans |
Check for automatic backup from your computer, backup to another destination, and whether you can restore a file. |
If losing a scan could delay your project, you’ll want to know how to get it back. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recovering project scans. |
| Total storage costs |
Check which drives are included, how much usable storage you need and how you’ll make a separate backup. |
If you’re working on a small project on one computer, you’ll want to compare the full NAS set-up with a simpler solution. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the total cost of their project. |
| Access across several devices |
Check access from your devices, connection to your home network and whether you need access when you’re away from home. |
If you regularly use scans on different devices of your own, keeping them in one central project folder could be useful. Around 21% of consumers prioritise access across several devices. |
| Access to sensitive scans |
Check user permissions and updates; only enable internet access if you need it. |
If your scans contain other people’s details, you’ll want to decide carefully who can view them. Around 14% of consumers give access management top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Thinking two mirrored drives are two independent backups
Mirroring can help keep your data available if one drive fails, but both drives are still part of the same NAS. It won’t protect against every type of data loss.
Keep a copy outside the NAS too, and test that you can restore a scan. Synology and the National Cyber Security Centre explain the importance of having a separate, recoverable backup.
You may need a separate backup medium or another backup destination.
-
Comparing enclosures only
A NAS enclosure without drives isn’t ready for storage. What’s included varies by model.
Before buying, check whether drives are included and what else you’ll need for your storage and backup plan.
If the model doesn’t include drives, you’ll need to choose suitable ones. You may also need extra storage for a separate backup.
-
Enabling internet access when you only need access at home
Access over the internet makes managing accounts and security settings more important.
Start with access over your own network, set up accounts carefully and keep the NAS up to date. VeiligInternet advises changing default login details and choosing a strong password.
NAS brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-drive option for central document management and backups of computer folders.
- According to Synology, this model supports Synology Drive for real-time or scheduled backups of PC folders. The manufacturer also describes backups from the NAS to another destination.
- Check the software version you need and which drives are compatible. The features described are not independently measured recovery results.
QNAP
According to QNAP, the TS-233 is designed for home users who want to store and share files centrally.
- QNAP lists snapshots and account security; the hardware specifications state that it has two SATA drive bays.
- Snapshots and any internet features are no substitute for a separate backup. Check your access and security settings.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-drive option to consider when comparing network connectivity and drive compatibility, among other things.
- ASUSTOR specifies two bays for 3.5-inch SATA HDDs, a 2.5GbE port and RAID 1 support for this model.
- A 2.5GbE port alone doesn’t guarantee higher speeds on your existing home network; your other network components matter too.
Products for storing scans
This selection includes NAS devices for central storage, plus an external drive as an alternative for a project mainly used on one computer.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
A NAS option for storing and sharing project files centrally.
Hard drives are not included and must be chosen separately.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
A NAS for storing and sharing files centrally.
The enclosure is supplied without drives; compatible drives must be installed.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
A NAS option for storing and sharing project files over your network.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives
A NAS for managing and sharing project files centrally.
Hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive
An external storage option for a project mainly used on one computer.
6 TB of storage. This use case requires a USB connection to a computer.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 enough to keep my scans safe?
No, RAID 1 is no substitute for a separate, recoverable backup. Mirroring can help keep your data available if one drive fails, but it won’t protect against every type of data loss. So, test that you can restore a scan.
How do I start storing my scans after installation?
Create a clearly named project folder, decide which computer you’ll add scans from, and set up a suitable automatic backup. Then check that you can restore a file. Synology describes scheduled backups of PC folders for the DS223j; the exact steps depend on the model you choose.
Do I need to buy hard drives separately, and what about the warranty?
Check whether hard drives are included with each model. For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, the law provides a guarantee that products must be of satisfactory quality, but there is no single statutory guarantee period for all products. The Dutch government advises contacting the retailer if there is a fault.
Can I store scans containing classmates’ details on my NAS?
That depends on the data and your role. For schools processing pupil records, the Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of restricted access and security, among other things. This doesn’t automatically make a personal NAS an approved place to store them. If school documents contain personal data, ask which storage and access methods the school allows.
How long should I keep scans containing personal data?
There is no single, specific retention period that applies to all personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that an organisation’s retention period depends on the purpose and any specific rules that apply. Check which rules and agreements apply to your project.