Who is a NAS suitable for?

Scans on a cramped desk

You want to keep documents accessible locally, but first you’ll need to check whether the enclosure, cables and noise levels are suitable for your workspace. QNAP publishes the dimensions of its models, while Synology lists drives, fans and vibration as potential sources of noise.

Scans you need to be able to recover

You store documents that you want to be able to open again after an error or hardware failure, and are prepared to set up a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that centralised storage, including RAID, is no substitute for a backup.

Scans across multiple devices

You want to access the same files from more than one computer and need to decide how to share them and who should have access. A NAS provides network storage; access permissions need to be set up separately.

What should you consider when choosing?

Single bay

Choose this when: saving desk space is your top priority. QNAP lists the TS-133 as 66,1 mm wide, excluding any feet.

Bear in mind: there’s no second internal drive bay for RAID 1, so arrange a separate backup.

Two bays

Choose this when: you want room for a second drive or drive redundancy. QNAP lists the TS-233 as 91,7 mm wide, excluding any feet.

Bear in mind: two drives take up space, and RAID 1 is no substitute for a backup stored elsewhere.

First, work out how much space you have and how you’ll restore your scans. Then check that your scanner, computer and security settings suit the way you work.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Space and noise Check the height, width and depth of the exact model. Measure the space needed for cables and ventilation too, and bear in mind noise from drives and fans. If I have limited desk space, I want to know whether the enclosure, cables and noise will be manageable. Around 31% of consumers put space and noise at the top of their list.
Recovering scans Decide where the separate backup will be stored and how you’ll restore a file from it. Only then consider whether you also want RAID 1. If I might need my scans after an error or hardware failure, I want to be able to restore a copy from outside the NAS. Around 31% of consumers give recoverability top priority.
Access from devices Check whether your scanner model can write directly to a network folder. If not, decide how you’ll transfer scans via a computer. If I want to collect or open scans from different devices, I want to know which transfer method will work. Around 19% of consumers prioritise access from multiple devices.
Access to confidential scans Set up user permissions and individual accounts, change default passwords, and decide whether internet access is necessary. If my scans contain confidential information, I want to decide who can open them and whether access from outside my network is needed. Around 19% of consumers put confidentiality first.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Mistaking two drives for two backups

    A second drive and RAID can help if a drive fails, but they don’t protect against every cause of data loss. The National Cyber Security Centre makes clear that RAID is no substitute for a backup.

    Plan to keep a copy somewhere else and test whether you can restore a scan from it.

  • Measuring only the width

    Depth, cables and ventilation space also affect whether a NAS will fit in your workspace. Noise can also come from the drive, fan or vibration; a manufacturer’s figure for an inactive drive doesn’t tell you how loud the device will be in use.

    Measure the whole space available and consider the noise from the drives and the way you plan to use the NAS.

  • Assuming any drive or scanner will work

    The ASUSTOR AS1102TL lists 3,5-inch SATA HDDs as a compatible drive type. The fact that a NAS supports network access doesn’t prove that your scanner can write directly to a network folder.

    Check drive compatibility for the exact NAS model and the network features of your scanner model. If direct saving isn’t possible, be prepared to transfer files via a computer.

Brands to compare

QNAP

The TS-133 and TS-233 offer a clear comparison for a small desk: the first model has one drive bay, while the second has two. The dimensions below are QNAP model specifications.

  • According to QNAP, the TS-133 is 66,1 mm wide and the TS-233 is 91,7 mm wide. Both measurements exclude any feet.
  • QNAP lists support for a 3,5-inch SATA HDD or 2,5-inch SATA SSD for the TS-133; the TS-233 has two drive bays.
  • These specifications don’t tell you how noisy a model will be with your drives or whether your scanner can save files directly to it.

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay NAS. Synology describes file-sharing and backup features for this model, which are useful if you want to manage scans across multiple devices.

  • The manufacturer describes file-sharing and backup features for the DS223j.
  • Synology warns that RAID and local copies don’t rule out data loss, and recommends using another backup destination. Also check that your chosen drives are compatible.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model to consider if you’re comparing SMB file access and RAID 1.

  • ASUSTOR lists two drive bays, SMB file access and RAID 1 support.
  • ASUSTOR lists 3,5-inch SATA HDDs as a compatible drive type. The stated 18,6 dB applies when the HDD is inactive and isn’t a noise measurement during use.

NAS models at Joybuy

The NAS models below have multiple drive bays, so you’ll need to consider their dimensions. Measure the available desk space carefully, including room for cables and ventilation.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

With five drive bays, this model is worth considering if you’re looking for more storage bays and have enough room for a larger NAS.

Stated dimensions: 165.5 × 241 × 297.9 mm. Hard drives are not included. The product description lists two 2,5GbE ports.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

This four-bay model is an option if you need multiple drive bays and have room for the enclosure.

The stated dimensions are 29 × 26 × 24 cm. Hard drives are not included; the product description lists expansion to nine bays and two 2,5GbE ports.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

With eight drive bays, this model is designed for a setup with lots of internal drives. First, check that the enclosure will fit in your workspace.

The stated dimensions are 45 × 36 × 30 cm. The product description lists two 2,5GbE ports.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can my scanner scan directly to the NAS?

It depends on the features of your scanner model; the NAS specifications alone won’t tell you. Check whether the scanner can write to a network folder and which protocol and login details it requires. Otherwise, you can transfer scans via a computer.

Does a NAS have to sit on my desk?

No. A NAS is network storage, so it doesn’t necessarily have to sit on your desk. Consider another suitable location if your network and connections allow it, and make sure there’s enough ventilation and room for the cables.

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my scans?

No. The National Cyber Security Centre distinguishes between drive redundancy and a backup. Keep a copy somewhere else and test whether you can restore a file from it.

Do I need to make my NAS accessible over the internet?

Not if you only use the NAS locally. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends that you don’t make a NAS accessible over the internet, as this adds a security risk. First decide whether you really need access when you’re away from home.

What privacy measures are relevant for scans containing personal data?

For business processing of personal data, the organisation must decide for itself which security measures are needed, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. Restrict access with individual accounts and permissions, and think carefully about whether access from outside your own network is necessary.