Archivist who prioritises recoverability
You want to be able to retrieve scans if files go missing or the NAS fails. Synology recommends an approach to backups that uses multiple copies and storage media, including a copy kept at another location.
Choose a NAS that lets you set up a separate, recoverable backup alongside your storage: RAID alone isn’t enough. Then match the usable capacity and network connection to your scans. If you handle identifiable family photos for business purposes, restrict access and decide how long you need to keep the files.
You want to be able to retrieve scans if files go missing or the NAS fails. Synology recommends an approach to backups that uses multiple copies and storage media, including a copy kept at another location.
You handle identifiable family photos for a client and want to decide who can view the scans and how long you need them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in photos to be personal data; what applies to the processing depends on the circumstances and the roles involved.
You store a large number of scans, or particularly large files, and want to check the usable capacity and network route in advance. Synology, QNAP and UGREEN outline the storage options for their NAS models; the space left available depends, among other things, on the drives and configuration you choose.
Start by considering how you’ll recover the scans if something goes wrong or a device fails. Then check access, usable storage capacity and the entire network route to the recipient.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverability | Set up a backup to a separate destination as well as the NAS, and test that you can restore files from it. | If I want to retrieve scans after a failure or accidental deletion, I need a separate copy and a restore test. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Access and retention period | Check whether you can set up accounts and sharing permissions, and how you’ll revoke access after the handover. | When I handle identifiable family photos for a client, I want to share them only with the intended people and decide in advance how long I need to keep them. Around 27% of consumers prioritise restricted access. |
| Usable storage capacity | Calculate capacity based on the drives and storage layout you choose; also check whether drives are included and plan a separate backup destination. | If my scan archive is growing, I want to know how much space will actually be available for files. Around 20% of consumers start by considering the storage capacity they need. |
| Network transfer | Compare the connections on the NAS, computer, router and any switches before treating transfer speed as a deciding factor. | When I regularly transfer large scans over the network, I want to know whether the entire connection suits the way I work. Around 20% of consumers prioritise network transfers. |
RAID can offer protection against certain drive failures, but it isn’t a separate, recoverable copy in its own right. Synology and QNAP both point out that you still need a backup.
Set up a backup destination outside the NAS too, and try restoring files before handing them over.
The available space depends on the installed drives and the configuration you choose. A NAS enclosure may also be supplied without drives.
Calculate capacity using the drives and layout you actually plan to use, and check what’s included with the exact model.
You may need to buy drives separately, and not all raw capacity is available for files in every configuration.
The NAS connection doesn’t tell you how fast the entire route to your computer or recipient will be.
Check the ports across your whole network setup before treating a faster connection as a deciding reason to buy.
If your current network equipment doesn’t support the connection you’ve chosen, you may need additional equipment.
The DS223 is designed for centralised photo and backup management. According to Synology, the DS225+ also has a 2.5GbE connection.
According to QNAP, the TS-233 is designed for centrally storing and sharing files and photos.
The NASync DXP2800 has two drive bays and a 2.5GbE connection, making it an option if you want that network connection as well as storage.
According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) combines two drive bays with 2.5GbE and snapshot features.
These NAS models are designed for centralised file management and network transfers. Match the storage layout and connection to your scan archive, and set up a separate backup as well.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to combine a central archive with regular network transfers; check that the entire network route suits the way you use it.
Hard drives aren’t included with this version. Remember to allow for a separate backup destination too.
No image available
Consider this model if centralised file management and network transfers are important; check the connection on every device in your transfer chain.
Plan for a separate backup destination alongside the NAS, and test that you can restore files from it.
No image available
An option for centralised photo and file management; decide in advance how much usable storage your archive needs and how you’ll keep a separate copy.
The product title states that hard drives aren’t included. Also check which network connection is suitable for your transfers.
No, RAID 1 isn’t a separate backup in its own right. It doesn’t protect against every cause of data loss, such as deletion or losing the entire NAS. Synology and QNAP therefore recommend a separate backup; also test that you can restore files from it.
Check that the intended files are on the NAS, back them up to a separate destination and try restoring a file from it. Then set up only the access needed for the agreed handover.
No, it varies by model and version. UGREEN describes the DXP2800 as diskless, and QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without an HDD. Check which drives are included with the exact model and which are compatible.
Not necessarily if you handle them as personal data for business purposes. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that identifiable people in photos are personal data and that organisations must not keep them for longer than necessary; the GDPR doesn’t set one general retention period. For the project, decide on the purpose, the roles involved and how long you need to keep the photos.
That depends on the roles involved and how the data is actually processed. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, a data processing agreement is required when one party processes personal data on behalf of a data controller. Don’t assume the roles of the parties involved in your project just because you’ve bought a NAS.