Choose a NAS based on how you want to restore earlier project versions. Scheduled backups with versioning keep previous versions, while snapshots provide restore points on a suitable volume. Synology documents multiple backup versions in Hyper Backup; for QNAP HBS 3, Smart Versioning is available from version 24.0, while TerraMaster requires Btrfs and TOS 5.0 or later for the snapshot feature described here. Also keep a separate copy off the NAS, as restore points on the NAS won’t protect you if the NAS itself is lost.
Who is this NAS choice relevant to?
Photo project creator working with revisions
You regularly edit scans, captions or selections and want to be able to retrieve an earlier project version. Synology documents multiple backup versions in Hyper Backup; QNAP describes versioning for HBS 3 from version 24.0.
Keeper of an irreplaceable archive
You want to make sure a faulty or lost NAS doesn’t take your only collection of historical canal photos with it. VeiligInternetten describes storage on another device as one option for keeping a separate copy.
Collaborator on a photo archive
You share project folders with others and want to consider access permissions and publication carefully. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people in images may be considered personal data; the Dutch government distinguishes between private use and distributing photos.
What should you look for in photo backups?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Earlier project versions |
Check whether backup tasks keep multiple versions, how rotation works and whether you can restore a file or project version. Synology documents multiple versions for Hyper Backup; QNAP describes Smart Versioning for HBS 3 version 24.0 or later. |
If I edit scans or captions at different times, I want to be able to retrieve an earlier project version; around 36% of consumers give version recovery top priority. |
| Copy off the NAS |
Check which external drive, second NAS or cloud service can be used as a backup destination, and schedule a recovery test. |
If my NAS fails or is lost, I want to keep my photo archive on another destination; around 29% of consumers prioritise having a separate copy. |
| Usable capacity and storage costs |
Work out the current size of your projects and how much they’re expected to grow. Check the usable capacity of your chosen drives and configuration. Synology notes that usable capacity can vary depending on the drives and RAID configuration. |
If my photo archive grows and older versions take up space, I want to know in advance how much storage will be usable; around 21% of consumers prioritise capacity and storage costs. |
| Access and sharing |
Check user permissions and sharing settings. Identifiable people may be considered personal data under the Dutch Data Protection Authority’s guidance. As the Dutch government explains, keeping photos private is not the same as distributing or publishing them. |
If I share project folders with others, I want to decide who can access them and which images can be published; around 14% of consumers prioritise controlled collaboration. |
Buying pitfalls when choosing a NAS for photo archives
-
Mistaking a snapshot on the NAS for a copy stored elsewhere
Local restore points can help after an unwanted change, but they still depend on the same NAS. Synology warns that problems with the NAS or storage can lead to data loss.
Combine local version recovery with a verified copy stored at another destination.
-
Assuming any drive of the right size will work
The Synology DS225+ has model-specific compatibility requirements; Synology notes that support is more limited for drives not on its compatibility list.
Before buying, check the full drive model and the latest compatibility requirements for your chosen NAS.
-
Confusing advertised capacity with usable archive space
Usable capacity can vary depending on your chosen drives and RAID configuration. Keeping project versions also takes up storage space.
Work out your current files, expected growth, version retention and chosen drive configuration separately.
Brands to compare for photo and project backups
Synology
The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS for those who want to combine photo backups with multiple restorable project versions.
- Synology says Hyper Backup can keep multiple versions; it also documents backups with Synology Photos.
- Check the compatibility of the full drive model. Usable capacity also depends on the drives and RAID configuration.
QNAP
The TS-264 is a two-bay NAS for those considering configurable versioning in HBS 3.
- QNAP documents Smart Versioning for HBS 3 version 24.0 or later, with configurable retention.
- Check which version of HBS 3 is installed and whether the retention method you want is available. The two drives are sold separately.
TerraMaster
The F2-424 is a two-bay option for those who want to use snapshots as local restore points alongside a separate backup plan.
- TerraMaster documents support for two SATA drives and for Btrfs or EXT4.
- The snapshot feature described requires Btrfs and TOS 5.0 or later. A snapshot on the NAS is not a separate copy.
ASUSTOR
The AS5402T is a two-bay NAS for those looking for snapshots and extra connectivity options in a photo and project workflow.
- ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports and USB connections. On compatible models and volumes, Snapshot Center can restore earlier versions of files.
- Check that your chosen volume is suitable for the snapshot workflow you want. A speed achieved in laboratory tests isn’t a direct indication of the speed you’ll get on your own network.
UGREEN
The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay alternative for photo storage and backups. Check separately whether it supports the version recovery workflow you want.
- UGREEN lists an Intel N100 processor, 2.5GbE and drives sold separately.
- Don’t assume general backup features include recovery of multiple project versions. Confirm in advance how your chosen model stores and restores versions.
Joybuy products for this photo project
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID or a snapshot on the same NAS enough as a backup?
No, not if you also want protection against losing the NAS. Use local restore points for quick recovery, and keep a copy at another destination as well. Synology warns that problems with the NAS or storage can lead to data loss.
How do I set up recovery for different project versions?
Set up a scheduled backup task, choose a retention policy and test a restore. Synology describes multiple versions with configurable rotation in Hyper Backup. QNAP describes Smart Versioning for HBS 3 version 24.0 or later; check that the version and settings suit your workflow.
What should I check besides the NAS enclosure?
Check whether drives are included, which drives are supported and how to set up a separate backup destination. QNAP notes that the drives for the TS-264 are sold separately. Also plan how you’ll test recovery regularly.
Can I store identifiable historical photos on the NAS and share them online?
Keeping photos private and sharing them online are two different things. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people may be considered personal data. For photos protected by copyright, the Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distribution or publication. Assess the rights and intended distribution of each photo.