Photographer looking for reliable recovery
You want to be able to restore your catalogue data and original photos after an error or hardware failure. So think of the NAS as part of a backup plan, not just a device with mirrored drives.
Choose a NAS that lets you back up both your catalogue data and original photos, and don’t count drive mirroring as your only backup. Synology Knowledge Center recommends keeping multiple copies, including one in a different location. Also measure the full space needed for the enclosure and cables. If you use Lightroom Classic, Adobe says your active catalogue must not be stored on a network drive, although your photo files can be.
You want to be able to restore your catalogue data and original photos after an error or hardware failure. So think of the NAS as part of a backup plan, not just a device with mirrored drives.
You want to place the NAS on or near a small desk. Check the full enclosure dimensions, and allow for cables and space around the device.
You want to allow for a larger photo archive or additional applications. Consider the storage configuration, network connection and the drives you’ll need to buy separately.
First decide how you’ll restore both your catalogue and original photos. Then compare the storage you need with the space available on your desk. Choose network features to suit your existing computer and network equipment.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who should consider this? |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable backups | Check which folders your photo software needs, how your computer backs up to the NAS, and how you’ll create a separate copy and test the recovery process. | I want to be able to restore both catalogue data and photos, rather than relying on the NAS alone. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Size and placement | Measure the width and depth, including space for plugs and cables. Also follow the model’s placement instructions. | The NAS needs to fit on a small desk with its cables connected and enough clearance around it. Around 27% of consumers prioritise the desk space available. |
| Usable storage and configuration | Work out the size of your current archive and how much it’s likely to grow. Check how many drives you’ll need and compare usable capacity, not just the combined drive space. | I want to know how much space I can actually use with my chosen drive configuration and which components I still need. Around 20% of consumers start with capacity and the total budget. |
| Photo software and network | Check where your active catalogue can be stored and which devices support the network speed you want. A 2,5GbE port alone doesn’t guarantee faster speeds in your setup. | I want to use my photos and catalogue in line with my photo software’s requirements, and avoid choosing a connection that my network can’t make use of. Around 20% of consumers prioritise workflow and network compatibility. |
For Lightroom Classic, Adobe distinguishes between the active catalogue, which can’t be stored on a network drive, and photo files, which can be stored on a network. Dimensions and ports vary by model. For example, QNAP lists the TS-233 as measuring 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm (height × width × depth), excluding any feet; ASUSTOR lists the AS1102T as having a depth of 218 mm. Measure the available space for the model you’re considering.
Mirroring within a single NAS isn’t a separate copy stored elsewhere. Synology Knowledge Center recommends the 3-2-1 backup strategy, which includes keeping a copy in a different location.
Plan an additional backup destination and test that you can actually restore your files.
A separate backup destination requires additional storage and needs to be set up as part of your backup process.
Catalogue data and original photos are separate parts of a photo collection. Keeping just one may mean you can’t restore everything you need.
Check which catalogue data and image files your photo software needs for a complete recovery.
A NAS may be supplied without storage drives. Usable capacity also depends on the drives and the configuration you choose.
Check what’s included with the model and work out how much usable storage you need.
Separate storage drives and, potentially, an additional backup destination mean you’ll need more storage.
Depth and space for cables can determine whether a NAS will fit on a small desk. A quoted noise level for an idle hard drive doesn’t describe how loud it will be during a backup.
Measure the available space, including room for cables, and check the conditions used for any noise ratings.
Synology describes the DS223j as a two-bay model for files, photos and scheduled backups of PC folders using Synology Drive.
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model with one gigabit Ethernet port. Its listed dimensions are 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm (height × width × depth), excluding any feet.
According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 AS1102T combines two drive bays with a 2,5GbE port. Its listed enclosure depth is 218 mm.
UGREEN positions the NASync DH2300 for photo storage and backups, and lists features for the DXP2800 including a 2,5GbE port and support for additional applications.
This selection includes Synology NAS models for anyone looking for backup and file features. Check carefully that the enclosures will fit in the space available on a small desk. If a model doesn’t include drives, you’ll need to arrange the required storage separately.
No image available
Worth considering if you’re looking for photo management and backup features, and have room for a larger enclosure.
Hard drives aren’t included, so factor them in when putting together your storage and backup setup.
No image available
Worth considering if you’re looking for backup and file sharing, with room to accommodate a growing archive.
Hard drives aren’t included, so check which drives you’ll need to get the usable capacity you want.
No image available
An option for anyone looking for multiple backup tasks and plenty of storage, provided it fits your workspace.
The listed enclosure measures 45 × 36 × 30 cm, so it takes up a lot of desk space.
No. Don’t rely on mirrored drives as your only protection. Synology Knowledge Center also recommends keeping a backup in a different location, as an issue affecting the NAS could still result in data loss.
According to Adobe, the active Lightroom Classic catalogue can’t be stored on a network drive. Photo files can be stored there; this restriction applies specifically to Lightroom Classic.
It depends on the model and the offer. UGREEN says that the DH2300 doesn’t include storage drives. Check what comes with the model you choose and which drives you’ll still need.
Check that backup tasks are completing successfully, test that you can restore files and keep the NAS software up to date. VeiligInternetten also recommends changing the default login details.
The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exception for purely personal or household use when photos remain private or are shared only with a very limited group. That exception doesn’t apply to wider distribution or business use; it isn’t a blanket exemption for every NAS or photo archive.