Start by deciding which files you need to be able to restore and how many devices should copy files to the NAS automatically. A two-bay NAS may be enough for local backups; a model with more drive bays or a faster network port is worth comparing if you have a larger collection or use your network more intensively. RAID and snapshots are no substitute for a separate backup outside the NAS, as the Synology Knowledge Center and the Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre also advise.
Who is NAS backup suitable for?
Photographers who prioritise recovery
If you want to be able to recover deleted or damaged photos, keep a separate copy alongside your NAS, offline if necessary. The Synology Knowledge Center and the Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre describe backup and recovery as parts of a backup strategy.
Photographers with an editing catalogue
Check that both the catalogue file and the original and exported photos are included. Adobe states that a backup from Lightroom Classic includes only the catalogue file; the active catalogue cannot be stored on a network drive.
Photographers with a growing collection
If you’re storing more and more photos or adding files from several devices, compare usable capacity, the number of drive bays and the network connection. Synology and QNAP describe different configurations for their NAS models.
What should you look for?
Two-bay NAS
A good fit if: you mainly want to back up an existing photo collection and a small number of computers locally.
The trade-off: you’ll still need an external copy to protect against problems with the NAS itself.
Faster two-bay NAS
A good fit if: large files or several devices make heavy use of your network.
The trade-off: any speed gains also depend on the rest of your network; a faster port doesn’t give you an extra backup copy.
NAS with more drive bays
A good fit if: your collection is growing and the usable capacity of a two-drive setup may not be enough.
The trade-off: more drive bays may mean buying extra drives, and they don’t replace a separate backup.
External drive
A good fit if: you use one computer and manual or scheduled copying is enough. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre notes that copying files to an external hard drive can sometimes be sufficient.
The trade-off: you’ll need to organise the copying and storage of a separate backup yourself.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovery and versions |
Check for version history, a backup destination outside the NAS and the ability to restore your files. |
If I want to recover photos after deletion, damage or a failure, I need more than one way to restore them. Around 36% of consumers say recovery is their top priority when buying. |
| Catalogue and photos |
Check which folders and file types the backup software actually copies. |
If I work with an editing catalogue, I don’t want to keep just the catalogue or just the photos. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a complete backup of both. |
| Usable capacity |
Work out the available space based on your chosen drives and storage configuration, allowing for growth and versions. |
As my photo collection grows, I want enough usable space for files and saved versions. Around 21% of consumers prioritise capacity and room to grow. |
| Copying from multiple devices |
Check the software available for your devices and whether your router, cabling and computer support the network speed you want. |
If I want to back up photos from several devices without transferring them manually each time, I look for supported automatic tasks. Around 14% of consumers make access from multiple devices their top priority. |
Common pitfalls
-
Mistaking RAID for a separate backup
A problem with the NAS could also affect the copies stored on it. The Synology Knowledge Center and the Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre recommend having a separate recovery option.
Alongside any mirroring or snapshots, keep a copy on another device or medium and test that you can restore your files.
Allow for a separate backup medium and space for earlier versions.
-
Copying only the photo catalogue
Adobe states that a backup from Lightroom Classic includes only the catalogue file, not the photos themselves.
Include the catalogue and photo files separately in your backup plan, and test that you can restore both.
Your backups will also need space for originals and relevant exports.
-
Confusing raw drive capacity with usable space
Usable capacity depends on your chosen drives and storage configuration; simply adding up the drive capacities won’t tell you how much space you’ll have available.
Work out the planned configuration before choosing your drives, and allow space for growth and versions.
As your collection grows, you may need a larger or additional compatible drive.
Brands worth comparing
Synology
The DS223j is a two-bay model worth comparing for a compact local setup; according to Synology, the DS225+ has a 2.5-gigabit Ethernet port.
- Synology describes Btrfs and snapshots on the DS223j from DSM 7.2 onwards.
- Usable capacity depends on your chosen drives and RAID configuration.
QNAP
The TS-233 and TS-264 are two-bay models; the manufacturer lists different network ports and memory specifications.
- QNAP lists two 2.5-gigabit ports for the TS-264-8G.
- According to QNAP, the TS-233 has one gigabit Ethernet port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives.
ASUSTOR
The ASUSTOR DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model worth comparing if Btrfs snapshots and 2.5-gigabit Ethernet matter to you.
- ASUSTOR describes scheduled or manual Btrfs snapshots for this model.
- The manufacturer’s transfer rates may differ in a different setup.
UGREEN
The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay model with a 2.5-gigabit connection worth comparing for local storage.
- UGREEN lists an Intel N100 and 8 GB of memory for the DXP2800.
- Check drive compatibility, as well as the specification and warranty terms that apply to your purchase.
NAS products at Joybuy
These Joybuy products are NAS models with more drive bays, suited to photo collections that may grow.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+
A model worth comparing if your photo collection may grow. The product description states that hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
A NAS worth comparing for local backups of photos and files. Check the product page to see which drives and backup features are included with this version.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
A model worth comparing if you want to back up a larger or growing photo collection locally. Check the drive configuration and usable capacity for the version you choose.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
A model worth comparing for a growing local photo backup. The product title states that hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does RAID make a separate backup unnecessary?
No. Keep a copy on another device or medium as well. A copy or version on the same NAS won’t protect you against every problem with that NAS, so test that you can restore your files.
Can I store my active Lightroom Classic catalogue on the NAS?
No. Adobe states that Lightroom Classic catalogues cannot be stored on a network drive. You can store photos there, but backing up the catalogue to the NAS is different from using the active catalogue from the NAS.
What should I check during setup and maintenance?
Check which drives are suitable for your exact NAS model and calculate the usable capacity of your storage configuration. Set up the copying task and test restoring a catalogue file and a few photos. For business use, the Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre recommends automating and testing backups.
Does the GDPR apply if I store photos at home without cloud storage?
The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exception for personal or household use when someone keeps photos private or shares them only with a very limited circle. This does not necessarily apply to business use or sharing more widely; the storage location alone does not determine this.