Who is a NAS suitable for?

Source recording manager

You want to keep original interviews, transcripts and descriptive information together, and be able to find them again later. Sprekende Geschiedenis explains that metadata helps people find and manage interviews within an oral history collection.

Manager of irreplaceable interviews

You want to decide in advance how you’ll recover recordings after drive failure, deletion or encryption. A separate backup is not the same as drive mirroring.

Project team with restricted access

You work with others on interviews, but want to set access according to people’s roles and how the recordings will be used. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable audio recordings may constitute personal data; the appropriate level of security depends on how they’re processed.

What should you look for in a NAS for oral history audio?

One drive with a separate backup

Suitable when: you want to store a small collection centrally and can accept downtime if a drive fails.

Trade-off: there’s no drive redundancy; recovery depends on your separate backup.

Two drives with mirroring and a separate backup

Suitable when: availability during a single drive failure matters, and you can also keep a copy outside the storage pool.

Trade-off: two mirrored drives of the same size won’t give you twice the usable space, and mirroring is no substitute for a backup.

NAS with more drive bays

Suitable when: the measured size and expected growth of your recordings, transcripts and derivative files justify extra space or room to expand.

Trade-off: usable capacity depends in part on the drives you choose and your RAID configuration; extra bays don’t automatically take care of archiving or privacy.

Sprekende Geschiedenis highlights the importance of metadata for finding and managing recordings, while QNAP warns that RAID isn’t a backup against deletion or encryption. So compare more than just the number of drive bays: consider how you’ll manage files, recovery and access too.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Source files and metadata Check that you can manage original recordings, transcripts and project documents clearly; you’ll need to add the metadata yourself. I want to keep source recordings and descriptions together so I can find interviews again later. Around 40% of consumers prioritise searchability and metadata.
Recovery after data loss Plan a backup outside the storage pool and test that you can restore files; separately decide whether availability during a drive failure is important. I want to know how to recover irreplaceable interviews if files disappear or a drive fails. Around 30% of consumers put recoverability first.
Team access Check user permissions and whether external access is needed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable audio recordings may constitute personal data. I want staff or project partners to have access that’s appropriate to their role and the interview. Around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled collaboration.
Complete setup Check which drives are included and compatible, how much space will be usable with your chosen setup, and whether a backup destination requires a subscription. I want to understand what my complete storage and backup setup requires in advance, not just which NAS enclosure I’m buying. Around 10% of consumers prioritise keeping total costs manageable.

Pitfalls when buying and using a NAS

  • Treating two mirrored drives as two independent copies

    Drive mirroring isn’t separate protection against accidentally deleting or encrypting files.

    Arrange a backup outside the storage pool and test that you can restore your files.

  • Comparing only the price of the NAS enclosure

    The drives you choose, the usable capacity after setting up RAID and a separate backup destination all affect the total cost. For Synology C2 Storage with Hyper Backup, Synology lists a separate monthly or annual subscription.

    Compare complete setups with the same required usable capacity and a suitable recovery plan.

  • Confusing a central folder with a searchable archive that’s accessible in the right way

    You’ll need descriptive metadata to find files again, and appropriate settings to control access to identifiable interviews.

    Record your metadata and sharing arrangements, and set folder permissions before sharing recordings.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model for file management and backup tasks; the features listed here apply to this model.

  • Synology lists a built-in 2.5GbE port and backup features for the DS225+.
  • Stated transfer performance figures aren’t measurements for oral history files. Check drive compatibility; Synology C2 Storage for Hyper Backup requires a separate subscription.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for central file storage; the features below apply to this model.

  • QNAP specifies 2 GB of fixed, non-expandable memory.
  • QNAP warns that RAID isn’t a backup against deletion or encryption. Assess your separate backup setup independently of the NAS.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2, model AS3302T v2, is a two-bay model whose network connection is worth considering.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5-gigabit Ethernet for this model.
  • Comparative speed and value claims are manufacturer claims, not independent tests for audio archiving. A faster NAS port won’t automatically speed up a slower network.

TerraMaster

The F2-424 is a two-bay alternative with several backup applications listed by the manufacturer.

  • TerraMaster lists Centralized Backup, Duple Backup and CloudSync, among others.
  • Having backup options doesn’t mean an external copy is already set up, or that every destination is suitable for confidential interviews.

NAS models at Joybuy

These NAS models are designed for central file storage and can be considered as part of your own backup setup.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Ideal if you want to manage interview files centrally and choose your own backup setup.

Hard drives aren’t included; check that your chosen drives are compatible.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Ideal if you want to manage files centrally and tailor a backup setup to your collection.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS, without hard drives

Ideal if you want to manage interviews centrally and choose your own separate backup setup.

Hard drives aren’t included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough as a backup?

No. Mirroring can help keep your files available if a drive fails, but QNAP warns that RAID doesn’t protect against files being deleted or encrypted. Arrange a separate backup as well, and test that you can restore your files.

Should I keep edited audio instead of the original recording?

No. Don’t treat an edited version as a replacement for the original source file. Keep the source recording clearly separate from working versions, and store relevant descriptions and project documents alongside it.

Can I put a drive containing existing interviews into a new NAS without preparing it first?

Don’t assume you can: the Synology DS225+ manual warns that a drive containing existing data is formatted during installation. Make a separate copy first and follow the manual for the model you actually choose.

What extra costs should I check before buying?

Check whether drives are included, which drives are compatible and what you’ll need for a separate backup. If you choose Synology C2 Storage with Hyper Backup, Synology lists an additional monthly or annual subscription; other destinations have different terms.

Can I share identifiable oral history recordings with anyone?

Don’t assume you can: the Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable audio recordings may constitute personal data. Before sharing interviews, consider the purpose, who should have access and whether the GDPR applies to how you process them.