If your NAS will sit next to your microphone, a fanless SSD model such as the QNAP TS-410E is worth considering. QNAP specifies four bays for 2.5-inch SSDs, but the enclosure is 244 mm deep and is supplied without drives. If desk depth is your main concern, compare it with a more compact two-bay NAS such as the QNAP TS-233; this model has a fan, and its stated depth excludes the feet. You should also plan for a separate backup and test your DAW workflow with a copy of a project before using network storage for active sessions.
Who is a NAS on a compact recording desk suitable for?
Music-maker storing files next to the microphone
Needs space for a NAS on a small desk and wants to consider the noise produced by the chosen drives and cooling system. QNAP describes the TS-410E as fanless; this is not a measurement of its noise level in your own recording room.
Music-maker with a valuable recording archive
Wants to be able to find and restore sessions and the audio files used in them after a loss or mistake. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre emphasises that centralised NAS storage is not, on its own, a backup.
Music-maker sharing projects between computers
Wants to open project folders on multiple devices and check that all the media used has been included. Ableton and Apple highlight considerations around plug-ins and externally stored audio files respectively.
What should you consider when choosing a NAS?
Start by thinking about where the NAS will go and what you need from your backup; then check how much storage you need and whether you need access from other computers.
For consumers in the Netherlands choosing a NAS for music recording on a compact desk, there are four distinct priorities to consider.
| Consideration |
What to look for |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Noise and placement |
Measure the available depth and space for cables. Check the fan type and the conditions of any noise measurements; QNAP gives the TS-233 a depth of 157,6 mm, excluding the feet. |
If my NAS is next to my microphone, I want to know how much space it takes up and what kind of cooling it has. Around 33% of consumers put noise and placement first. |
| Restoring recordings |
Plan a backup to a separate destination and try restoring a complete project folder. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre says RAID is not a substitute for a backup. |
If I can’t recreate a session, I want to check that its files can be restored too. Around 27% of consumers give recoverability top priority. |
| Storage and drives |
Check the number of drive bays, compatibility and whether drives are included. Synology lists a separately available holder for 2.5-inch drives in the DS223j; QNAP supplies the TS-410E without drives. |
As my recording archive grows, I want to know which drives I need and how much storage the chosen configuration offers. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on capacity and drive costs. |
| Sharing projects |
Test access on your own computers and check that the media used is in the project folder. Ableton says that plug-ins are not copied with Collect All and Save; Apple warns that externally stored audio files are not automatically included in a Logic project folder. |
If I open projects on multiple computers, I want to avoid missing media or plug-ins. Around 20% of consumers put sharing between computers first. |
What pitfalls should you avoid when buying a NAS for music recording?
-
Assuming a low dB rating guarantees quiet recording
A noise figure may apply to a specific configuration and a measurement taken at idle. It does not automatically tell you how loud the NAS will be during a recording.
Compare the measurement conditions and the drives and fan in the model you’re considering. Don’t choose based on a single dB figure alone.
-
Confusing RAID with a restorable backup
Mirroring drives does not protect against every cause of data loss. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre warns that centralised storage and RAID are not a substitute for a separate backup.
Keep a copy at a different destination and check that you can restore a complete session.
A separate backup destination requires additional storage and management.
-
Comparing the NAS enclosure alone
Your complete setup may also require compatible drives, a separate holder or storage for backups. QNAP states that the TS-410E is supplied without drives; Synology lists an optional holder for 2.5-inch drives in the DS223j.
Before buying, make a parts list for the exact model and storage configuration you want.
-
Assuming a copied DAW project is complete
A project may refer to audio stored outside the project folder. Ableton also says that plug-ins are not copied with Collect All and Save.
Gather the media you’ve used with your DAW’s tools, then open a restored copy of the project to check that everything is there.
Which NAS brands are worth considering?
QNAP
According to QNAP, the TS-410E-8G is a fanless model with four bays for 2.5-inch SATA SSDs. The TS-233 is a two-bay enclosure with HDD options.
- QNAP specifies a depth of 157,6 mm for the TS-233, excluding the feet.
- The TS-410E is 244 mm deep and is supplied without drives; a fanless design is not an independent noise measurement in a recording room.
Synology
According to Synology, the DS223j is a two-bay model for central storage, synchronisation and sharing between devices.
- The DS223j can be compared as an option for storing and sharing project files.
- Synology lists a separately available holder for 2.5-inch drives. The stated 18,2 dB(A) applies to an idle measurement with specific HDDs and does not predict noise during a recording.
ASUSTOR
ASUSTOR specifies two bays for 3.5-inch HDDs, SMB file sharing and a 2,5GbE port for the Drivestor 2 AS1102T.
- The 2,5GbE connection is a specification to consider if network connectivity is important to you.
- ASUSTOR specifies a fan and a depth of 218 mm. The stated 18,6 dB applies to an HDD at idle and does not prove that the device is quiet during recording.
UGREEN
UGREEN describes the NASync DXP2800 as a two-bay model with 2,5GbE and support for SATA drives and M.2 SSDs.
- The listed connectivity and storage options can be considered when comparing the configuration you need.
- Check compatibility and which drives are included for the specific model.
NAS products on Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions about NAS devices for music recording
Can you save an active recording session directly to a NAS?
That depends on your DAW and network setup, so don’t treat it as a general guarantee. Test a copy of a project on your own computer and check that the project folder contains all the media it needs. Ableton says that plug-ins are not copied with Collect All and Save.
How can you stop a moved project from missing audio files?
Check that all the audio you’ve used is in the project folder before moving it. Ableton users can use Collect All and Save for this; in Logic Pro, check whether files stored elsewhere have been included in the project.
Are two mirrored drives enough for a backup?
No, RAID is not a substitute for a separate backup. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping a separate copy; store it at a different destination and test that you can restore it.
What costs and warranty rights should you consider in addition to the NAS enclosure?
Check whether drives and any necessary holders are included, and allow for storage for a separate backup. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the statutory guarantee does not have a fixed general term of two years; it is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.
Which rules apply when buying a NAS in the Netherlands or storing other people’s recordings?
Electrical appliances sold on the EU market must meet applicable product requirements, including the required CE marking; check this for the specific model. If your organisation processes personal data in recordings or project files, the GDPR requires appropriate security measures based on the risks.