Who is a NAS for music projects suitable for?

Creator working to a deadline

You want to be able to recover an earlier version or a complete project folder if something goes wrong. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre describes a backup as a copy used to restore data; keep that copy separate from the files on your NAS.

Music group sharing files

You want to access project files from several computers and avoid missing audio when someone opens the project. Ableton points out that audio files can be stored outside a Live Set file.

Creator with a growing archive

You store recordings, samples and earlier versions, and want to weigh up usable storage capacity against the cost of suitable drives. ID.nl lists drive bays, RAID and backup among the things to consider when choosing a NAS.

What should you consider when choosing one?

Ableton recommends transferring complete project files, while the Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre describes a backup as a copy that can be used to restore data.

Priority What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Recovering projects Check which backup tasks the model supports and where the separate copy will be stored. Test that you can restore a file. If a deadline is approaching, I want to restore an earlier version rather than start again. Around 36% of consumers put recovery at the top of their list of concerns.
Sharing files Check access for multiple users, and gather the audio files you’ve used in the project folder before transferring it. When we work on the same project on different computers, I want the necessary files to be available on the other computer. Around 29% of consumers make sharing their top priority.
Storage capacity and drives Add up your existing project folders, allow for growth and check whether suitable drives are included. As my archive grows, I want to retain enough usable space without losing track of drives or copies. Around 21% of consumers put capacity and overall cost first.
Transfer time Check the network connections on the NAS, computer and any other equipment in between; a port specification doesn’t guarantee a particular copying speed. When transferring large project folders, I want to know whether my entire network can make use of the connection. Around 14% of consumers name transfer time as their main concern.

Common mistakes when buying a NAS

  • Mistaking two drives for two independent backups

    Mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it isn’t a separate recovery copy if files are deleted or become unusable.

    Plan a separate backup in addition to any mirroring, and try restoring a file before your deadline.

    Collected audio files and project copies need extra storage space.

  • Comparing an empty NAS enclosure with a complete solution

    Some versions are supplied without storage drives. Without suitable drives, the NAS can’t store your project files.

    Check what’s included with the exact version you’re buying, and allow for suitable drives and a separate backup solution.

    A mirrored setup needs two suitable drives.

  • Assuming 2,5GbE guarantees a particular copying speed

    A faster network connection won’t automatically make copying faster if other parts of the network are slower.

    Check the connections on every device in the setup before considering extra network equipment.

    You may need suitable network equipment to make full use of the connection.

NAS brands worth considering

Synology

Synology describes the DS223j as a two-bay model, with backup options for computer folders via Synology Drive and for the NAS via Hyper Backup.

  • The manufacturer describes features for backing up computer folders and the NAS.
  • The presence of backup features doesn’t prove that your chosen recovery setup is configured properly. Also check whether the offer includes suitable drives.

QNAP

QNAP lists two SATA drive bays, 2 GB of built-in memory and one gigabit network port for the TS-233.

  • The listed specifications give you specific details to compare against your drive and networking requirements.
  • The port specification alone doesn’t determine how quickly your music project will transfer. Also check which drives are compatible with the version you’re buying.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR lists two drive bays and a 2,5GbE network port for the Drivestor 2 AS1102T.

  • The 2,5GbE specification is relevant if the other equipment on your network supports that speed.
  • A stated port speed doesn’t tell you how quickly your own project files will transfer in practice.

UGREEN

UGREEN describes the NASync DXP2800 as a two-bay model with 2,5GbE and space for additional M.2 SSDs.

  • The manufacturer mentions both the network connection and the option to add M.2 SSDs.
  • UGREEN states that storage drives aren’t included. The extra expansion options don’t automatically make a model more suitable for a school project.

NAS models at Joybuy

These NAS models from Joybuy are designed to store and share music project files centrally. Check which drives are included with each version and how to arrange a separate backup.

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Could suit you if you want to store and share project files centrally; the product information describes this enclosure as diskless.

The product name lists Intel Celeron J4125 Q. According to the product information, suitable storage drives aren’t included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A NAS worth considering if you want to share project files centrally and set up a backup system.

The product information states that hard drives aren’t included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Could be a good choice if you want to store and share project files centrally. Check the specifications for the exact version and plan a separate backup.

Model designation as listed in the product name: DS1825+.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A NAS option to consider if you want to share project files centrally and choose your own suitable storage and backup setup.

The product name lists DS925+ and states that hard drives aren’t included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about a NAS for music projects

Is RAID or mirroring the same as a backup?

No. Mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it isn’t a separate recovery copy if files themselves are deleted or become unusable. Keep a separate backup as well, and check that you can restore it.

Why are audio files missing after I move a music project?

In Ableton Live, audio files may be stored somewhere other than the Live Set file. For a Live project, use ‘Collect All and Save’ before transferring it; this doesn’t copy plug-ins, which need to be available on the other computer. For other music software, check its own export instructions.

How do I set up a NAS for my school project?

First, check which drives are suitable for the exact model and follow the manufacturer’s installation guide. Set up a backup only using the features available on your chosen model, then test sharing and restoring with a copy of a project.

Should I allow for extra purchases and warranty cover when buying a NAS?

Check whether the version you’ve chosen is supplied without drives, and allow for a separate backup solution. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, not every product has a fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years; for a purchase by a consumer in the Netherlands, the retailer is the point of contact for statutory warranty claims.

Can a school store pupils’ data on a NAS?

If a school processes pupils’ personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must be able to demonstrate that it has appropriate technical and organisational measures in place. If the school uses an external processor, there are also requirements for a data processing agreement. This does not, in itself, mean that a specific NAS model complies with the GDPR.