Who is this NAS choice relevant to?

Volunteers looking to safeguard recordings

You need a central place for irreplaceable recordings, as well as a separate copy that you can use to restore files. The National Cyber Security Centre of the Netherlands emphasises that central NAS storage is not a backup in itself.

Managers of a growing collection

You regularly add recordings, so you’ll need to assess the collection’s current size, file formats and expected growth before choosing your storage capacity. The Dutch Digital Heritage Network recommends taking stock of your collection and the storage media you use.

Coordinators managing shared access

You want to give volunteers access to the files they need without giving everyone access to every recording or administrator privileges. The National Cyber Security Centre of the Netherlands and the Dutch Data Protection Authority offer relevant guidance on security and personal data.

What should you look for in a NAS for music recordings?

Start with recoverability and usable capacity. Then decide who needs to be able to find which recordings and what else you’ll need for your complete storage setup.

Priority What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Recoverability Plan for a separate backup destination and check that you can restore files from it. I want to be able to recover recordings after a loss or mistake, not just store them on the NAS. Around 33% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Usable capacity and growth Take stock of the collection and expected additions; check the usable space and drive compatibility of the exact model. If the collection keeps growing, I want to know how much space the chosen drives and configuration will actually provide. Around 27% of consumers prioritise capacity and expandability.
Access and findability Check user permissions and logging, and agree how recordings will be described and found. When several volunteers use the files, I want to be able to set access limits by role and find recordings later. Around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled access and findability.
Complete setup Check whether the enclosure comes with drives and include a separate backup destination in your plans. I want to weigh up the enclosure, suitable drives and backup together before we choose. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the total cost of buying and managing the setup.

Common pitfalls when choosing a NAS for a music archive

  • Relying on RAID as your only backup

    In a suitable setup, RAID can help keep your NAS available if a drive fails, but it isn’t a substitute for a backup. A separate copy also needs its own destination and regular recovery checks.

    Set up a separate copy before using the NAS as your only storage location, and check that you can restore files from it.

    A separate backup destination and recovery tests require extra storage space and time to manage.

  • Comparing raw capacity or just the enclosure

    Usable storage depends on the drives and configuration you choose. Some NAS enclosures are sold without drives, so the enclosure alone isn’t a complete storage setup.

    Compare the usable space offered by complete setups, and check the contents of the box and drive compatibility for the exact model variant.

    Suitable data drives and a separate backup destination also need to be included in your setup.

  • Assuming easy sharing means you can publish freely

    Giving volunteers access doesn’t automatically mean you can share recordings publicly. Recordings of identifiable voices may contain personal data, and music and performances may also be subject to usage rights.

    Decide who needs access to each recording and what can be accessed internally or shared externally. Where possible, set access by user or folder.

  • Thinking that buying a NAS is a complete preservation plan

    Hardware alone won’t ensure that recordings remain understandable and easy to find in the future. You’ll also need an inventory, descriptive information and regular file checks.

    Record which recordings and file formats the archive holds, and how administrators can find files.

    Creating an inventory, describing files and checking them regularly all take time.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ has two bays and the DS425+ has four. Both are worth considering for a limited or growing collection.

  • Synology lists a built-in 2.5GbE port and backup and sharing features for both models.
  • Usable capacity depends on the drives and RAID configuration you choose. Check the compatibility list. Published speeds are based on Synology’s internal tests and don’t directly indicate performance on your own archive network.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option if two 2.5GbE ports and M.2 slots suit your planned setup.

  • QNAP specifies two 2.5GbE ports and two M.2 slots for this model.
  • The enclosure is sold without hard drives. The ports alone don’t guarantee faster transfers on your own network.

ASUSTOR

The AS5404T is a four-bay option to compare if you also want two 2.5GbE ports.

  • ASUSTOR specifies four SATA drive bays, four M.2 slots and two 2.5GbE ports.
  • The stated maximum raw capacity isn’t the same as the usable space you’ll get with your chosen drives and storage configuration.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 has two bays and a 2.5GbE port. It’s worth considering if support for selected third-party drives is important to you.

  • UGREEN lists support for selected third-party drives.
  • Storage drives are sold separately. Check the compatibility list for your chosen model. Speed and ease-of-use claims come from the manufacturer and aren’t an independent assessment of archive use.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions about NAS devices for music recordings

Is RAID enough to keep your recordings safe?

No. The National Cyber Security Centre of the Netherlands distinguishes between drive redundancy and a backup, and recommends keeping backups in multiple locations. You should also test whether you can restore a recording from those copies.

What should you do before installing drives and transferring recordings?

First, take stock of the formats, locations and file sizes, then check drive compatibility for the exact NAS model. In the DS425+ installation guide, Synology warns that a drive containing existing data will be formatted during installation.

Which audio format is suitable for long-term preservation?

Where possible, keep the original recording and document which formats the archive uses. For digitally submitted audio, the Library of Congress prefers formats such as WAVE with embedded metadata over WAVE without metadata. This is a preservation guideline, not a requirement when buying a specific NAS model.

Are you automatically entitled to a two-year legal guarantee on a NAS in the Netherlands?

No. According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory guarantee period; what you can expect from a product also depends on the product itself. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. A manufacturer’s guarantee is in addition to your statutory rights. Also check the terms and conditions for the specific product variant you’re buying.

Can you store identifiable voices and share music online?

A recording in which someone can be identified may contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that organisations must identify an appropriate GDPR legal basis for processing and put suitable security measures in place. Storing music or performances on a NAS doesn’t grant you the rights to publish or use them; what you need depends on the recordings and how you want to share them.