Who might need a NAS for a music archive?

Keepers of unique recordings

You store irreplaceable sessions and want to be able to recover files if they are lost or changed. The Digital Preservation Coalition highlights the importance of keeping multiple copies, including one off-site.

Growing archives

You regularly record new projects and need to weigh up storage capacity, drive configuration and future expansion. Synology recommends checking drive compatibility for your chosen model.

Volunteer teams

Several people contribute files, but not everyone needs to view or edit every project. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must protect access to personal data appropriately.

What should you look for when choosing a NAS?

Compact two-bay NAS

A good fit when: your estimated collection and future growth will fit within the usable capacity of two drives, and you have separate backups in place.

The trade-off: with a mirrored configuration, the second drive does not add usable capacity. Snapshots stay on the NAS and are not an off-site copy.

NAS with four or more drive bays

A good fit when: you expect your collection to grow or want more flexibility in how your drives are configured. The Synology DS925+ has four internal bays, while the DS1525+ has five.

The trade-off: more bays may mean buying more drives. Check compatibility and continue to make separate backups.

NAS as a central archive

A good fit when: you want to manage projects centrally and can also arrange separate copies, recovery tests and integrity checks.

The trade-off: copies stored away from the NAS need extra storage and management, but they prevent your archive from depending on just one device or location.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recovery after loss or changes Check which files are copied, where an off-site copy is stored and whether you can restore files from it. If I want to recover a unique recording after an error or deletion, I want to know in advance where the separate copy is and whether recovery works. Around 31% of consumers put recovery first.
Usable capacity and future growth Measure your collection and expected growth, then compare the usable capacity for each drive configuration. For new projects, I want to leave enough room without looking only at the drives’ raw capacity. Around 25% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Volunteer access Check who can read, upload, edit and delete files in each role. Consider extra security if you process personal data. When several volunteers are working together, I want to be able to set permissions for each task rather than give everyone the same access. Collaboration is the top priority for around 19% of consumers.
Understanding and checking projects later Keep relevant descriptions of works, creators and versions, and plan checks of your stored copies. I want to be able to identify which project files belong to later and check whether they have changed. Around 13% of consumers give archive usability top priority.
Complete storage setup Consider the enclosure, compatible drives and separate backup destination together. To keep the whole setup manageable, I want to factor in the drives and backup destination, not just the NAS enclosure. Around 12% of consumers prioritise total costs.

Common pitfalls when buying a NAS for a music archive

  • Mistaking a mirrored configuration for a full backup

    A copy on the same NAS does not adequately protect you if the device or location is lost. Synchronisation can also replicate a deletion.

    Plan a separate copy, preferably off-site, and test at the same time that you can restore your files.

  • Comparing only the NAS enclosure’s capacity

    An enclosure without hard drives is not a complete, working storage setup. Usable capacity also depends on the drives and configuration you choose.

    Check which drives are compatible with the model and compare complete setups, including the separate backup destination.

  • Giving every volunteer full access

    Not everyone who uploads files needs to be able to view, edit or delete every project. Organisations must protect access appropriately when personal data is involved.

    Assign permissions by task and review them when roles change.

Brands to compare for a music archive

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model for central storage, file sharing and snapshots.

  • Snapshots may help you find earlier versions, where supported by the model and configuration.
  • Snapshots on the NAS are no substitute for a separate copy stored elsewhere.

ASUSTOR

The manufacturer describes the DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) as a two-bay model with 2.5GbE and Btrfs snapshots.

  • The stated network connection and snapshot support are worth considering when comparing the connections and recovery options you need.
  • A quoted transfer speed under optimised test conditions is not a guaranteed speed on a volunteer network.

Synology

The DS925+ has four internal drive bays and the DS1525+ has five. Both may be suitable for a collection that continues to grow.

  • The number of bays gives you a practical starting point for assessing your preferred drive configuration and room to grow.
  • Synology recommends checking drive compatibility before you buy. Support for unlisted drives may be limited and can depend on the model and software version.

TerraMaster

The manufacturer describes the F2-424 as a two-bay alternative with backup applications and two 2.5GbE ports.

  • The connections and stated applications are worth considering for your network and management needs.
  • More network ports do not automatically mean a faster connection for a single workstation.

NAS models on Joybuy for a growing archive

These NAS models are options to consider when weighing up central storage, collaboration and room to grow for a music archive. Plan separate backups too, and check the details of the version you choose.

Synology Diskstation DS1525+ NAS

Synology Diskstation DS1525+ NAS

An option to compare if you expect your archive to grow; the DS1525+ has five internal drive bays.

Hard drives are not included and must be chosen separately.

View on Joybuy
Synology Diskstation DS1825+ NAS

Synology Diskstation DS1825+ NAS

An option to consider if you want central storage for a shared archive. Check which drives and management features are right for your setup.

View on Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

An option for an archive you expect to grow; this model has four internal drive bays.

The NAS is supplied without hard drives. Synology recommends checking the compatibility of your chosen drives in advance.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about NAS storage for music projects

Is RAID 1 or synchronisation enough as a backup?

No. Keep separate copies too, preferably with at least one copy off-site, and test that recovery works. Synchronisation can also replicate a deletion.

What should I arrange when first setting up a NAS for volunteers?

Set up accounts and folder permissions to suit each person’s tasks, and make it clear who can edit the originals. If the collection contains personal data, decide which security measures are appropriate; the Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that access must be protected appropriately.

How can I keep stored music projects verifiable?

Keep descriptive metadata with the works and record checksums that you can compare again later. The Digital Preservation Coalition describes checksums as a way to check file integrity. Also test that you can open or restore your copies.

What should I include when buying a diskless NAS?

As well as the enclosure, factor in suitable, compatible drives and a separate backup destination. The Synology DS925+ is sold without hard drives, so check which drives are compatible with the model before you buy.

Can our Dutch community archive share music projects with everyone?

Not automatically: according to the Dutch Government, copyrighted music may only be used with the creator’s permission. If the archive contains personal data, rules on processing it also apply; the Dutch Data Protection Authority notes, among other things, that you need a legal basis. Check the rights and legal basis for each project.