Who is this choice relevant to?

Makers who want to be able to restore their work

If you store designs, photos or project files, you need more than central storage: you also need to be able to restore an earlier, usable version. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important files; the Digital Trust Centre recommends testing recovery regularly.

Makers with a growing portfolio

If you expect your collection to grow significantly, it’s worth considering the number of drive bays, usable capacity and the cost of buying drives separately in advance. Synology recommends checking the compatibility list for your chosen model.

Administrators of a shared archive

If you’re managing access for several contributors, you’ll also need to decide who can view which files. If the archive contains personal data, you’ll need to consider privacy and security guidance from the Dutch Data Protection Authority.

What should you consider when choosing?

Start with your recovery plan and the amount of usable space you need. Then decide how you’ll share files and consider what the complete setup requires in terms of drives and management.

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit if: your current portfolio and expected growth fit within the usable capacity, and you also arrange a separate backup.

Bear in mind: with mirroring, usable capacity isn’t the combined capacity of both drives; mirroring doesn’t replace a separate backup.

NAS with four drive bays

A good fit if: you want more drive bays to allow for a growing collection.

Bear in mind: extra bays can make the purchase and setup more expensive; you’ll still need a separate copy stored elsewhere.

NAS with a second copy stored elsewhere

A good fit if: being able to recover from errors or damage at one location matters, as well as having central access to your files.

Bear in mind: an external drive or storage service requires extra management and may involve additional costs.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Recoverable backups Check scheduled backups, versioning or recovery options, a second storage location and whether you can restore files. If I need an earlier version of my portfolio after a mistake, I want to be able to test a recovery rather than simply have an extra copy. Around 33% of consumers give recoverability top priority.
Usable capacity and growth Estimate your future storage needs and compare the usable space for your chosen setup; check the model’s compatibility list. As new projects and image files grow my collection, I want to know in advance how much space my chosen setup will actually provide. Around 27% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Shared access and privacy Check user and folder permissions. If you process personal data, also assess the applicable legal basis and security measures. If several archive members need files, I want to manage access by role and handle images of identifiable people carefully. Around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled collaboration.
Total cost of the setup Check whether drives are included, and factor compatible drives and a separate backup into your comparison. If I want to plan a working setup, I look beyond the enclosure and include the storage and second copy in my costs. Around 20% of consumers prioritise total cost.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming mirroring is a complete recovery plan

    An extra drive in the same NAS won’t protect against every incident that affects your files or location.

    Keep a copy at another location too, and test restoring it before you rely on the NAS as an archive backup.

    A separate backup destination needs to be managed in addition to the NAS.

  • Comparing only raw capacity or the enclosure

    Usable space depends on the drives and storage configuration. Some NAS models are sold without hard drives.

    Compare complete configurations by usable space and check the compatibility list for the exact model.

    Allow for the compatible drives you’ll need and any potential expansion.

  • Confusing access with permission to publish everything

    Identifiable people in images are personal data. Storing them and sharing them publicly each require a separate assessment.

    Agree access permissions and, before processing any personal data in the archive, establish which legal basis applies.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS925+ has four. These model features don’t, on their own, say anything about every product from the brand.

  • Synology lists one 2,5GbE port for the DS225+ and two for the DS925+. Manufacturer throughput figures may differ from real-world performance.
  • Before buying hard drives, check the compatibility list for your chosen model.

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-264 as a model for file management, backup and collaboration.

  • The official specifications for the TS-264-8G list two 2,5GbE ports.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. Check the specifications for the exact version.

ASUSTOR

The DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2, model AS3302T v2, has two drive bays.

  • ASUSTOR lists one 2,5GbE port for this model, along with support for 3,5-inch and 2,5-inch SATA drives.
  • According to ASUSTOR, the 2 GB of memory can’t be expanded. Bear this in mind if upgrading the memory is important to you.

UGREEN

According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay model for tasks including backups and file sharing; the DXP4800 Plus has four drive bays.

  • UGREEN lists an Intel N100, 8 GB of memory and 2,5GbE for the DXP2800.
  • Check that your chosen drives are compatible with the exact model. Manufacturer information is not an independent assessment of reliability.

NAS models at Joybuy

These NAS models are worth comparing if you want to manage, back up and share a makers’ portfolio from one central location.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option to consider if you want to manage and back up a growing portfolio from one central location.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option for anyone looking for a NAS with four drive bays for shared files and backups.

According to the product title, this version is supplied without hard drives. Bear this in mind when planning your setup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

An option to compare if you want to manage a growing portfolio from one central location and share files.

The product title states that this version is supplied without hard drives. Synology recommends checking the model’s compatibility list.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is mirroring two drives the same as having a backup?

No. Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but it doesn’t replace a separate backup. Keep a copy at another location too, and test that you can restore your files.

What should you do before handing over the portfolio?

Set up your storage and scheduled backups, restrict access to authorised people and test restoring a few files. This lets you check the recovery process; on its own, it doesn’t prove that the NAS is configured securely.

Are hard drives included with every NAS?

No, it varies by model and version. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives; the product title for the Synology DS925+ at Joybuy also lists a version without drives. Check the version you’re choosing and include the drives and a separate backup in your plans.

Can a community archive store and share identifiable photos?

Identifiable people in photos are personal data. If an organisation processes this data, it must establish an applicable legal basis and protect the data appropriately. Publishing photos publicly is a separate decision and doesn’t automatically follow from storing files.

Does a community archive automatically fall under the Archives Act?

No, not simply because it’s called an ‘archive’. The Dutch Data Protection Authority’s guidance on the Archives Act concerns archiving by public authorities; don’t assume those rules apply to a private community archive.