Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Administrator of a growing recording archive

Wants to store lecture recordings centrally and plan storage based on usable capacity. Synology notes that capacity depends on the drives used and the RAID configuration.

Team using a shared workstation

Wants authorised colleagues to be able to find recordings without giving everyone the same administrator rights. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises organisations to manage staff access rights properly.

Administrator of recordings containing personal data

Must assess appropriate access, a lawful basis and a retention period if students or lecturers are identifiable in recordings. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains these responsibilities for organisations that process personal data.

What should you look for?

Start by working out how much usable storage you need and what recovery options you want. Then consider shared access, privacy and what you need to complete the NAS setup.

Key consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Usable archive space Estimate your existing recordings and expected growth, then compare this with the capacity available after choosing your drives and RAID configuration. If I want to store recordings centrally for a long time, I need to know how much space my chosen setup will actually provide. Around 26% of consumers prioritise usable archive space.
Recovery and backup Check which storage configurations are supported and plan a separate backup destination and a recovery test. If files are accidentally deleted or the NAS fails, I want to be able to restore a separate copy. Around 21% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Workstation access Check that shared folders and individual user permissions are available, and that the network connection suits your equipment. When colleagues use the same workstation, I want to share recordings without giving everyone administrator rights. Around 21% of consumers prioritise shared access.
Privacy and access Establish whether people are identifiable and what rules apply to the lawful basis, permissions, retention period and deletion. If recordings show identifiable students or lecturers, I want to manage access and retention in line with my institution’s policies. Around 16% of consumers prioritise privacy management.
Purchase and management Check the exact model, which drives are included, drive compatibility and who will manage backups, updates and permissions. Before choosing a complete setup, I want to know which components and management tasks are involved. Around 16% of consumers prioritise purchase and management.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing raw capacity with usable archive space

    Available space depends on the drives you choose and the RAID configuration. The stated raw capacity is therefore not necessarily the amount of space you can use for recordings.

    Estimate your storage needs and compare them with the usable capacity of the complete setup you have chosen.

    If your estimate does not fit, you may need extra drives or to expand the system later.

  • Treating a multi-drive NAS as a complete backup

    Depending on the configuration, RAID can protect against certain drive failures, but it is not a separate copy. Accidental deletion, damage or loss of the NAS calls for a separate recovery plan.

    Include a backup to a separate destination and a recovery test in your plan, whatever the number of drive bays.

    A separate backup destination also needs to be set up and managed.

  • Relying on a retailer’s description without checking the model and contents

    A shortened product title may not give you enough information to identify the exact model variant or the parts included.

    Before you buy, check the full model number, what’s included and drive compatibility.

  • Assuming network speed means guaranteed transfer speed

    Transfer speeds are affected by the connection and the test setup used. A manufacturer’s measurement in RAID 0 does not automatically reflect the speed of a different archive setup.

    Check the network path between the NAS, switch and workstation, and compare speed claims only under the test conditions stated.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ and DS425+ have two and four drive bays respectively, making them worth considering if you’re weighing up centralised storage against room to expand.

  • Synology says both models have a built-in 2.5GbE port.
  • Raw capacity is not the same as usable space; this depends on the drives and RAID configuration.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G and TS-464-8G have two and four drive bays respectively, for file sharing and archiving.

  • QNAP specifies two 2.5GbE ports for these variants.
  • QNAP says these models are supplied without HDDs. Hardware Info tested the TS-464 in one configuration in 2023; that measurement is not a performance guarantee for other drives or networks.

TerraMaster

The F4-424 has four drive bays and is worth comparing if you’re considering expanding a local recording archive.

  • The manufacturer lists several RAID configurations.
  • The stated transfer test used four drives in RAID 0; don’t take that speed as an indication of performance in a redundant archive setup.

ASUSTOR

The Nimbustor 2 Gen2 (AS5402T) and Nimbustor 4 Gen2 (AS5404T) are two-bay and four-bay alternatives.

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE connections for this product range.
  • The published performance figures come from optimised laboratory conditions. Check the exact variant and your own network if speed is important.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay alternative for centralised storage where you choose compatible drives yourself.

  • UGREEN lists a 2.5GbE port.
  • Drives are sold separately. Consider the manufacturer’s speed and usage claims in the context of your own setup.

NAS models at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are options for centralised file sharing and a recording archive. When comparing them, look at the number of drive bays and the specifications of the exact configuration.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

An option for a growing archive if five drive bays and centralised file sharing suit your setup.

Five drive bays; according to the product description, it can be expanded to fifteen with an expansion unit. The description lists two 2.5GbE ports.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS423+ with four included 12TB drives

Synology DiskStation DS423+

A four-bay option for an archive that needs multiple drives and shared folders.

The product description lists four included 12 TB SATA drives and two 1GbE LAN ports. Check the model variant and what’s included with the offer.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to compare if your archive needs plenty of drive bays and centralised file sharing.

Eight drive bays; the product description lists two 2.5GbE ports and an expansion option for storage.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to store lecture recordings?

No, RAID is no substitute for a separate backup. Depending on the configuration, RAID can protect against certain drive failures, but you should also plan a copy on a separate destination and check that you can restore it.

How do you set up a NAS for a shared workstation?

Give authorised users suitable accounts and folder permissions rather than giving everyone administrator rights. Check the default settings and passwords, and consider whether internet access is needed. The Dutch National Cyber Security Centre recommends avoiding direct exposure to the internet where possible.

Does a NAS come with hard drives?

It depends on the model and the offer. QNAP says the TS-264-8G and TS-464-8G are supplied without HDDs; check the exact model and what’s included with the offer.

How long can identifiable lecture recordings be kept?

The GDPR does not set a specific general retention period for personal data. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the institution responsible for the data must set a period that suits the purpose and any other applicable rules, and document its reasoning.

Is consent always required to archive lecture recordings?

No. The fact that a recording contains personal data does not automatically mean consent is required. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, processing requires an appropriate GDPR lawful basis; consent is one possible basis. The institution must also consider appropriate security and access rights.