Who is this relevant for?

Anyone responsible for irreplaceable recordings

You want to be able to recover original lecture recordings after an error or hardware failure, so you need a separate backup in addition to NAS storage. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that a NAS is not a replacement for a backup.

Anyone collecting recordings in mixed file formats

You store different audio and video files and want to understand the difference between storing, previewing and playing files on a particular device. QNAP distinguishes between storage and thumbnail generation for certain functions.

Anyone managing a shared educational archive

You need to consider who can access identifiable recordings and how long they should be kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority discusses arrangements for recordings in education and notes that the GDPR does not set a specific general retention period for personal data.

What should you consider when choosing?

Start with recoverability, how you’ll use the files, room for future growth and access management. Then choose a NAS setup that suits those priorities.

Consideration What to look for Who is this important for?
Recoverability Compare usable capacity with your chosen drives and RAID setup. Also arrange a separate backup destination and consider how you’ll check that recovery works. If I don’t want to lose original recordings, I look beyond drive mirroring. For around 29% of consumers, recoverability is the top priority.
Mixed file formats Make a list of the extensions and codecs used in important recordings. Test them on the device you intend to use, and check preview features and any app or licence requirements separately. I want to be able to find and open my recordings on the devices I use. Around 29% of consumers prioritise format compatibility and playback access.
Storage and room to grow Calculate the space needed for existing and expected files on the same capacity basis. Then compare the number of drive bays, the chosen setup and whether drives are included. As my recording archive grows, I want to weigh up the space and drive setup I’ll need in advance. This is the top buying concern for around 18% of consumers.
Access and privacy Decide who can view or edit files and whether access is needed outside the local network. For an educational archive, consider its purpose and retention period. For a shared archive, I want to limit access to the right people and agree how long files will be kept. Around 24% of consumers prioritise access management.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking a two-drive mirror for a complete backup

    RAID can help keep files available in the event of certain drive failures, but it doesn’t protect against every cause of data loss. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that RAID is not a replacement for a backup.

    Keep a separate copy and check that you can restore your recordings from it.

  • Assuming every recording will play straight away

    Storing a file on a NAS is not the same as being able to generate a thumbnail or play it on every device. QNAP lists additional requirements for generating thumbnails for certain file formats, sometimes including a licence.

    Test representative files on your own playback device and check app and licence requirements for each format.

  • Assuming a NAS enclosure is a complete archive

    Usable capacity depends in part on the drives and the RAID setup you choose. If you buy a diskless model, you’ll need to source suitable storage drives separately.

    Compare complete setups by usable capacity and check which drives are included with the model you choose.

  • Opening up a shared archive without access and retention policies

    The National Cyber Security Centre warns of security risks when a NAS is accessible directly over the internet. For an educational archive containing identifiable people, you should also consider its purpose, access and retention period.

    Restrict access rights and decide whether external access is needed. Educational institutions should make sure the setup and retention period suit the purpose of the archive.

Brands to compare

Synology

According to Synology, the DiskStation DS225+ is a NAS with two drive bays, 2.5GbE and backup applications. It’s an option to consider if you want to manage recordings from a single NAS environment.

  • Synology states that usable capacity depends on the drives used and the RAID configuration.
  • Before installation, check that your chosen drives are compatible with the exact model.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-233 is designed for centralised file storage and has two drive bays, USB and one gigabit network port.

  • QNAP describes snapshot and access features for the TS-233.
  • Generating thumbnails for some video formats may require extra settings and a licence. This doesn’t confirm that all recordings can be played.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a model with 2.5GbE and snapshots, worth comparing if transfer speeds and management are important to you.

  • The manufacturer lists 2.5GbE and snapshots for this model.
  • Check the full model number: AS3302T v2 is not necessarily the same model as AS3302T. The listed features are not a measure of performance with an educational archive.

UGREEN

UGREEN describes the NASync DXP2800 as a diskless NAS with two drive bays, an Intel N100, 8 GB of memory and 2.5GbE.

  • This configuration is worth comparing if you’re looking for a NAS setup with 2.5GbE.
  • Drives are sold separately. Check which model and availability apply to your purchase.

Joybuy products

This Joybuy selection includes Synology NAS models for centralised file storage, with room for expansion as one factor to consider. Check which drives are included with each model and arrange a separate backup if needed.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Suited to anyone who wants to combine centralised file sharing with room to expand a growing archive.

Hard drives are not included; choose suitable drives separately.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Suited to anyone who wants to store original recordings centrally and choose an archive setup with room to expand.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Suited to anyone looking for centralised storage who wants to put together their own diskless setup.

Hard drives are not included; suitable drives must be purchased separately.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up lecture recordings?

No. Drive mirroring is not a replacement for a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre points out that RAID doesn’t protect against every cause of data loss, so keep a separate copy and check that you can restore your recordings from it.

Can I play any recording as soon as it’s on the NAS?

Not necessarily: storing a file, displaying its thumbnail and playing it are different functions. QNAP lists additional software and a licence for generating thumbnails of certain HEVC files, so test important files on the devices you intend to use.

What should I check before installing drives?

Check compatibility with the exact NAS model and back up any drives that already contain data. Synology warns in the DS225+ manual that installation formats a drive containing existing data and erases it.

What should an educational institution consider when storing identifiable lecture recordings?

The institution should carefully consider the purpose of processing and who can access the recordings, then set an appropriate retention period. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR does not set a specific general retention period for personal data; what is appropriate depends on the purpose and circumstances.

Can I freely share a stored lecture recording that contains copyrighted material?

No. Making a copy for personal use does not automatically give you permission to distribute or make copyrighted material available to the public. The Dutch Government makes this distinction when discussing copying for personal use; also check the rights to the recording itself.