Project group sharing recordings
Looking for one managed place where group members can find files, with access tailored to their role.
A NAS is a good fit when project members regularly need to manage recordings over a network. For one person with a modest archive, an external drive with a separate backup may be simpler. Bear in mind that mirroring gives you less usable capacity than the combined capacity of both drives. RAID is not a substitute for a separate backup, as QNAP also explains.
Looking for one managed place where group members can find files, with access tailored to their role.
Wants to plan space for existing and future recordings, and be able to recover files after a mistake.
Needs to agree how recordings can be accessed and used, and how long they will be kept when people can be identified in them.
A good fit when: several project members need files over a network, or you want to use two compatible drives in a mirrored setup.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to choose and manage the enclosure and drives. Mirroring uses up some usable capacity and is not a substitute for a separate backup.
A good fit when: one person manages a limited number of recordings and continuous network access isn’t needed.
Bear in mind: sharing files between devices takes an extra step. This setup also needs a recent, separate backup.
Decide which need matters most for your project: recovery, usable space, sharing, total cost or managing access to identifiable recordings.
| Concern | What should you check? | Who should give this more weight? |
|---|---|---|
| Recovering recordings | Whether you keep a recent copy outside the NAS and can restore it. | If something goes wrong, I want to be able to restore a copy from outside the NAS, not rely on two drives in one device. Around 26% of consumers put recovery first. |
| Enough usable space | The size of your existing files, how many new recordings you expect, and the usable capacity of your chosen drive configuration. | I want to know how many of my existing and future project files will actually fit. Around 21% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Sharing files | Whether the network connection suits your equipment and whether you can set user permissions. | It matters to me that project members can find recordings without giving everyone access. Around 16% of consumers prioritise shared access. |
| Total cost and drive choice | Whether drives are included, how many you need and which drives are compatible with the exact model. | I want to weigh up the enclosure, the drives I need and a separate backup against a simpler storage solution. Around 21% of consumers put total cost first. |
| Access and retention period | Who manages the recordings, who gets access and which institutional policy applies. | When people can be identified, I want to agree in advance who can access the recordings and how long they are needed. Around 16% of consumers prioritise privacy management. |
RAID does not protect against every cause of file loss. QNAP makes clear that RAID is not a backup; accidental deletion, damage or theft call for a separate copy.
Compare the usable capacity of your chosen configuration and plan a backup outside the NAS that you can restore.
A separate backup requires extra storage. Mirroring also gives you less usable space than the combined capacity of both drives.
Some versions are supplied without storage drives. You may therefore need to buy compatible drives and separate backup storage as well.
Check what’s included and the compatibility information for the exact model before choosing drives.
The models listed have different network ports, but transfer speeds also depend on the rest of your connection and the workload.
Compare the connection with your network equipment, and don’t treat the manufacturer’s test results as a guaranteed speed for your project.
The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model worth comparing if you’re looking for network archiving and backup features.
The TS-233 is a two-bay model for central storage and network access.
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay alternative for comparing network ports and drive support.
This selection on Joybuy features NAS models for central archiving and file sharing. For each version, check the drive bays, included drives and connections to make sure they suit your project.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing, shared folders and backup features for central archiving.
Five drive bays; support for 2.5- and 3.5-inch drives; 2.5GbE and Gigabit network connections. This version is supplied without drives. Plan a separate backup too: RAID is not a substitute.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing and backup for a centrally managed archive.
Five drive bays and expansion with additional drives are listed. HDDs are not included, so choose compatible drives and plan a separate backup.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing and backup features for central storage management.
Eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports are listed, along with expansion using an expansion unit. Keep a separate backup as well.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing and data management for shared project recordings.
Four drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports and expansion to nine bays are listed. Hard drives are not included, so choose them separately and plan a separate backup too.
Use the file size of your existing recordings as a starting point, then estimate how many new files you’ll add. Compare the total with the usable capacity of your chosen configuration, not just the drives’ raw capacity.
No, RAID 1 is not a substitute for a separate backup. QNAP points out that RAID doesn’t protect against every cause of data loss, such as accidental deletion, theft or damage. Keep a recent copy on separate storage too, and check that you can restore it.
Don’t assume you can. The Synology DS225+ installation guide warns that a drive containing existing data will be formatted during installation. Make a separate copy beforehand and follow the guide for the exact model.
Storing recordings on a NAS doesn’t in itself give you permission to record a lecture or share it further. Check your educational institution’s policy and the rights of everyone involved. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises agreeing on matters such as the purpose, informing those involved, secure storage and retention period for online teaching recordings. The Dutch Government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing copyright-protected work.
According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR does not set one general retention period for personal data. An organisation must not keep data for longer than necessary for its purpose. Check the relevant institutional policy for the specific recordings, and don’t infer a retention period from rules for other educational records.