A NAS is a good choice if you want to store lecture recordings and source files in one place and access them regularly from multiple devices. If you only archive files occasionally from one computer, an external drive may be simpler. Whichever storage option you choose, plan a separate copy that you can restore from.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Creator of irreplaceable recordings
You want to be able to recover raw recordings and source files after a mistake or device problem. Plan a separate recovery copy too; the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important business data.
Manager of a growing lecture archive
You regularly collect large video files and want to know in advance how much usable drive space and network capacity you’ll need. Usable storage depends, among other things, on the drives and configuration; Synology highlights these model-specific differences.
Sharing local study materials
You want to access files from multiple devices while deciding who can view them. If recordings show identifiable people, you’ll also need to consider how they are stored; the Dutch Data Protection Authority offers recommendations for recordings in education.
What should you consider when choosing?
Two-bay NAS
Best for: an ongoing local archive that you want to access and manage from multiple computers.
Consider: check the usable capacity and plan a separate back-up; two drives in one NAS are not the same as a copy stored outside that NAS.
Separate external drive
Best for: archiving from one computer when you only copy files locally now and then.
Consider: manual copying takes discipline and doesn’t automatically offer the same central access as a NAS.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| File recovery |
Check how to set up automatic copies and a separate back-up destination, then test that you can restore your files. |
I want to be able to recover my raw recordings and source files after deletion or a device problem. Around 33% of consumers put file recoverability first. |
| Usable space |
Estimate how quickly your archive will grow and compare usable capacity, drive compatibility and what’s included in the box. |
I want to avoid my growing video archive filling up quickly or overlooking the drives I’ll need when comparing options. Around 27% of consumers prioritise usable space and the overall setup. |
| Access from devices |
Check the network port on the exact model and the connections on your router, switch and computers. |
I want to access my files in one place as I switch between devices. Around 20% of consumers prioritise access from multiple devices. |
| Access and privacy |
Decide who can view the recordings, whether you need remote access and what retention period suits your situation. |
I want to restrict access when recordings show identifiable people. Around 20% of consumers prioritise access management and privacy. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming two drives in one NAS count as two independent back-ups
A problem with the device could also affect the files stored on that same NAS. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important data.
Keep a copy outside the NAS and test that you can restore your source files from it before deleting the originals.
-
Comparing raw terabytes only
Usable capacity also depends on the drives and storage configuration. You may also need to buy drives separately.
Compare the usable space for your archive and check the compatibility list and box contents for the exact model.
-
Assuming a 2.5GbE port guarantees a certain copy speed
The network port is just one part of the connection; your computer and network equipment matter too. Manufacturer test results are also based on specific test conditions.
First check the connections on your router or switch and computer, then decide whether faster transfers are important for the way you use it.
-
Sharing recordings widely because the NAS is local
Local storage doesn’t remove the need to consider access permissions and personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority offers privacy recommendations for recordings in education.
Give access only to the accounts that need it, and assess how recordings are made and stored separately.
Brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model for central storage and back-ups.
- Synology lists a 2.5GbE port and back-up features for the DS225+.
- Usable capacity depends on the drives and configuration. Before buying drives, check the compatibility list for the exact model.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay model for central file storage and local access.
- QNAP lists snapshots and account security features for the TS-233.
- The hardware specifications list one 1GbE port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. Snapshots are not a replacement for a separate back-up.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2, model AS3302T v2, is a two-bay model worth comparing.
- ASUSTOR lists 2.5GbE and snapshots for Btrfs and iSCSI.
- The quoted transfer performance figures are laboratory results and won’t necessarily apply to every home network.
TerraMaster
The F2-424 combines two drive bays with connections and storage options to consider for an archive.
- The official specifications list 8 GB DDR5 and two M.2 slots; TerraMaster describes several back-up applications.
- Extra components aren’t automatically necessary for storing lecture files. Compare what’s included and which drives you’ll need before deciding.
Joybuy products
This Joybuy selection focuses on Synology NAS models for a central archive with file-sharing and back-up features.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
The product information lists file-sharing and back-up features for storing files in one place.
Hard drives are selected and sold separately.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
The product information lists file-sharing and back-up features for storing files in one place.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
The product information lists file-sharing and back-up features for storing files in one place.
Hard drives are not included.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 or a snapshot enough as my only back-up?
No. Also keep a separate copy outside the NAS and test that you can restore your files. A snapshot or real-time copy is not automatically an independent back-up.
How should I start setting up my archive?
First, work out which raw recordings and source files you want to keep. Then check the drive compatibility and box contents for the exact NAS model, set appropriate access permissions and test restoring a separate copy.
What if the NAS breaks down after the manufacturer’s warranty expires?
For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, statutory consumer rights may still apply after the manufacturer’s warranty expires. The Dutch government states that the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; if a product is faulty, the retailer is your point of contact. A hardware warranty does not replace a back-up of your data.
Can I keep or share recordings showing identifiable students indefinitely?
Not simply because the files are stored on a NAS; the rules that apply depend on who processes the recordings and why. An educational institution processing personal data may need to meet requirements for a lawful basis, security and an appropriate retention period; the Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period. The Authority also offers recommendations for recording lessons or lectures. The GDPR’s personal or household activity exemption may apply where the recordings are used solely for personal or household purposes.