Who is this buying guide for?

Managing a growing recording archive

You’re storing more and more lectures and large project folders, and want to factor in expected growth before choosing the number of bays and drives.

Managing recordings that are hard to replace

You want to be able to restore deleted or damaged files, and plan to use a separate backup destination alongside your NAS. Synology also recommends backing up NAS files to another location.

Creating large video projects

You regularly move large folders and want to check whether a faster network connection is compatible with your computer and other network equipment.

What should you look for?

First, estimate growth and usable storage capacity. Then decide how you’ll manage backups and recovery, and finally check whether a faster network connection could benefit your entire setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Usable capacity and growth Add up your current folders, estimate what you’ll add and compare the usable space available with your chosen drives and RAID configuration. Also check whether drives are included in the offer. If I add recordings and project folders every semester, I want to know in advance how much space will be left after choosing a drive layout. Around 31% of consumers prioritise capacity and growth.
Recovery and separate backups Check which snapshot and backup features are available for each model, choose a second destination and test that you can restore your files. I want to be able to restore important lectures and project versions, even if something happens to the NAS itself. Around 31% of consumers give recovery and separate backups top priority.
Transferring large folders Compare the NAS connection with your computer and the rest of your network. A port specification doesn’t guarantee a particular copy speed. When I regularly move large folders, I want to know whether the entire connection is up to the task. Around 19% of consumers prioritise transfer speed.
Access and privacy Decide who can open, edit and share files. If an institution processes personal data, make sure storage, security and retention periods comply with the relevant policies. I want to share recordings in a controlled way and respect the privacy of identifiable participants. Around 19% of consumers prioritise access management and privacy.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking the total drive capacity for usable archive space

    Usable space depends in part on the drives and RAID configuration you choose. With drive redundancy, you may have less space available than the combined capacity of the drives.

    Calculate the usable space for the exact drives and configuration you’re considering, and check which drives are included in any bundle.

  • Relying on RAID or snapshots as your only protection

    Local versions and drive redundancy can help with certain problems, but they won’t prevent every kind of data loss. Synology also recommends backing up to another location.

    Set up a separate backup destination and regularly check that you can restore your files from it.

  • Assuming a fast network port guarantees fast copying

    A port specification doesn’t equate to a fixed file transfer speed. Drives, configuration and other network components also play a part. ASUSTOR notes that results from optimised test conditions may differ from those achieved elsewhere.

    Check the entire connection between the NAS and your computer, and don’t base your choice solely on the speed quoted for a port.

  • Sharing recordings of identifiable participants without agreeing access and retention rules

    When an organisation processes personal data, it must take appropriate security measures. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also states that personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary.

    If recordings contain personal data, make sure access rights, retention periods and deletion comply with your educational institution’s policies.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS224+ has two bays and the DS423+ has four, so you can compare which layout suits the size and growth of your archive.

  • Synology describes file management and backup features for these product ranges.
  • The number of bays and the drives you choose both affect the setup. Synology also recommends keeping a backup in another location, even when using local versions.

QNAP

The two-bay TS-264 is worth comparing if you regularly move large folders over a compatible, faster network.

  • QNAP specifies two 2.5GbE ports.
  • Drives and SSDs are sold separately. QNAP’s stated maximum transfer speed via port trunking depends on the configuration and isn’t the same as a standard copy speed.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model to compare if you’re looking for 2.5GbE and Btrfs snapshots.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5GbE and Btrfs snapshots for this model.
  • ASUSTOR’s published speeds come from tests under optimised conditions and won’t necessarily apply to every setup.

UGREEN

The four-bay NASync DXP4800 Plus is worth comparing if you want multiple drive bays and a faster network connection.

  • UGREEN lists one 10GbE and one 2.5GbE connection for this model.
  • Check separately that the software features you need and your other network equipment are suited to the way you work.

Joybuy products

This selection includes NAS models to compare for growing archives and large file transfers. Check the drive layout, included drives and connections for each product to make sure they suit your network.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Worth comparing if your archive is growing and you regularly move large folders. Check that the network connections are compatible with your entire network.

Also check which drives are included in the offer and calculate the usable space for your intended configuration.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS423+ with 4 × 12 TB HDDs

Synology DiskStation DS423+ (4 × 12 TB HDD bundle)

A four-bay option to compare if you want more drive-layout options for a growing archive.

Synology’s Joybuy product listing describes a bundle with four included 12 TB HDDs (4 × 12 TB). Check that this configuration meets your usable space requirements and backup plan.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth comparing for an archive that’s expected to grow significantly and involves regular transfers of large folders.

Check the drive layout, included components and network connections for the configuration on offer before deciding whether it suits your needs.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID the same as backing up my lecture recordings?

No. Drive redundancy and local versions can help with certain faults, but they won’t prevent every kind of data loss. Synology also recommends backing up to another location.

How should I get started setting up a NAS?

First, decide on your drive and storage layout. Create separate user accounts and shared folders, then set up a backup to another destination. The steps and features available vary by model and operating system.

Should an educational institution keep lecture recordings indefinitely?

Not if the recordings contain personal data: according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary. The GDPR doesn’t set a single general retention period. For educational recordings, the Authority recommends agreeing on the purpose, retention period, secure storage and deletion.

What security measures are required for recordings containing personal data?

An organisation that processes personal data must take appropriate security measures. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the specific measures depend on the risks involved in the processing. Buying a particular NAS model or enabling a single feature doesn’t, on its own, prove compliance.

If my NAS breaks, should I contact the manufacturer or the seller?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller is your point of contact for your statutory guarantee rights. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period; a manufacturer’s guarantee is in addition to your statutory rights.