Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Administrator of a growing lecture archive

You regularly store new recordings and want to work out in advance how much usable space and room to expand you’ll need. ID.nl highlights storage space and backup options as important considerations when choosing a NAS.

Volunteer responsible for recovery

You want to be able to recover deleted or lost recordings and need a backup and recovery routine the group can realistically follow. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important data.

Coordinator of shared access

Several group members need to be able to find recordings, but recordings featuring identifiable voices or images aren’t necessarily intended for everyone. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data.

What should you look for?

Compact NAS with two drive bays

A good fit when: the archive is expected to stay within the usable capacity of two drives and the group wants centralised access.

Trade-off: mirroring can protect against a drive failure, but it reduces usable space and leaves little room to expand within the same enclosure.

NAS with more drive bays

A good fit when: an inventory of existing recordings and expected growth shows that two bays won’t provide enough capacity or room to expand.

Trade-off: extra bays also mean buying more drives; a different storage configuration is no substitute for a separate backup.

External drive

A good fit when: one administrator archives material occasionally and shared network access isn’t needed.

Trade-off: files are less suited to independent, shared management; you’ll still need a separate backup.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recovering recordings Check whether you can create and restore a separate backup; snapshots on a supported model are not a copy stored outside the NAS. If I need to recover a deleted recording or files after a failure, I want a recovery routine the group can follow. Around 33% of consumers put recovery options first for this archive.
Usable space and growth Count your existing files and estimate future growth based on your own recordings and how often you make them; compare this with the usable capacity of the drives and configuration you’re considering. If new lectures are added regularly, I want to avoid running out of usable archive space. Around 27% of consumers give capacity and growth the highest priority.
Access and protection Check user accounts and folder permissions. Separately decide whether access outside your own network is needed and how the association will meet its privacy obligations. If several volunteers manage files, I want to make sure only designated people can access recordings that aren’t intended for everyone. Around 20% of consumers put controlled shared access first.
Complete setup Consider the enclosure, compatible drives and separate backup storage together; check exactly what’s included in the box. If I need to budget for the complete storage setup in advance, I want to know what else I’ll need in addition to the enclosure. Around 20% of consumers put the total cost of the setup first.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking mirrored drives for two backups

    Both drives are still part of the same NAS. Deletion, damage to the NAS or loss of the location calls for a separate, recoverable copy.

    Budget for a separate copy and regularly check that you can restore a recording.

  • Confusing raw drive capacity with usable space

    Usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration you choose. With mirroring, you can’t simply add the capacity of both drives together.

    Compare models after checking your existing files and expected growth against the usable capacity of the configuration you’re considering.

  • Comparing the enclosure alone

    UGREEN states that storage drives aren’t included with the NASync DXP2800. What’s included can vary between products.

    Check what comes with each model and factor compatible drives and separate backup storage into your decision.

  • Assuming shared access means recordings can be shared widely

    Identifiable voices or images may be personal data. Copyright may also apply to the lecture or any content used in it.

    Before sharing recordings, decide who needs access, what legal basis applies to processing the data, and what permissions or other rights you need.

NAS brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model to consider if centralised management and a compact setup are important to you.

  • Synology lists a 2.5GbE connection for this model.
  • The manufacturer says usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration. Published throughput figures don’t guarantee the speed you’ll get for your archive.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 for first-time NAS users and highlights centralised storage, sharing and synchronisation.

  • The manufacturer describes features for centralised storage and collaboration.
  • This product information doesn’t prove that the association already has a suitable backup in place. Check the drive setup and recovery routine separately.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model to consider if restoring earlier versions is a priority.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots and a 2.5GbE connection for this model.
  • Snapshots aren’t a copy stored outside the NAS, and ASUSTOR’s quoted speed figures are based on laboratory results.

TerraMaster

According to TerraMaster, the F2-424 has two drive bays and is available with various backup applications.

  • The manufacturer specifies compatibility with 3.5-inch SATA HDDs, 2.5-inch SATA HDDs and 2.5-inch SATA SSDs.
  • The maximum raw capacity doesn’t automatically translate to the same amount of usable space; app features don’t mean a separate backup is already in place.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay model to compare if you’re considering more demanding applications as well as archiving.

  • UGREEN lists an Intel N100, 8 GB of memory and 2.5GbE.
  • The European product page says storage drives aren’t included. This extra hardware isn’t necessarily needed just to store lecture recordings.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do you work out how much NAS capacity you need?

Start with the actual size of your existing recordings and how much you expect the archive to grow. Compare this with the usable capacity—not the raw capacity—of the drives and storage configuration you’ve chosen. Don’t count a second mirrored drive as an equal amount of extra archive space.

Is a mirrored NAS enough as a backup?

No, not if your recovery plan also needs to cover losing the NAS. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important data: the original files and two backups. Set up a separate copy and test that you can restore a recording.

What should you arrange when setting up and maintaining a NAS?

First, check drive compatibility and what’s included in the box. Then set up access permissions and a separate backup, assign responsibility to volunteers and practise restoring files.

Can recordings featuring identifiable voices or images be kept and shared without limits?

No. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data. An association must establish an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR for processing, protect the data appropriately and avoid keeping personal data for longer than necessary. The GDPR doesn’t set a general fixed retention period. The appropriate legal basis and retention period depend on how the data is being used.

Does buying a NAS give you permission to make a lecture public?

No. Storing and making something public are two different things. The Dutch government says that using copyright-protected material may require the creator’s permission. Check the rights to the lecture and any images or music used before sharing recordings.