Who is a NAS suitable for?

Administrator of a growing recording archive

You regularly add recordings and want to be able to restore files after they’ve been deleted or changed. The National Cyber Security Centre of the Netherlands recommends protecting important files with backups.

Volunteer who shares recordings

You want to make files available to the right group members without giving everyone administrator permissions. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that audio recordings in which people can be recognised may constitute personal data.

Administrator weighing up storage options

You want to check whether shared network storage is necessary, and which drives and separate backup solution you’ll need.

What should you look for in a NAS?

What to consider What to look for Who it matters most to
Recording recovery Check that backups go to a separate destination, and try restoring a recording. If I need to retrieve a recording after it’s been deleted or lost, I want to test recovery in advance. An estimated 31% of consumers put recoverability first.
Access management Check user and folder permissions, and decide who can upload or share files. If recordings with recognisable voices are intended for certain group members only, I want to be able to manage access by user or folder. An estimated 25% of consumers put access management first.
Submitting files Test the transfer method volunteers will use with a few recordings. If different volunteers regularly submit recordings, I want to bring them together in one place without a cumbersome transfer process. An estimated 25% of consumers prioritise straightforward copying.
Complete storage setup Check the number of drive bays, which drives are included and what separate backup destination you’ll need. If I want to understand everything the storage setup requires, I want to assess the drives, backup and management together. An estimated 19% of consumers mainly want to get a clear picture of the complete setup.

Common purchasing pitfalls

  • Mistaking two mirrored drives for a complete backup

    Mirroring can help if a drive fails, but it isn’t a separate backup and won’t automatically protect you if files are deleted or the NAS is lost.

    Also make a copy in another location and regularly test whether you can restore a recording from it.

  • Assuming the enclosure is a complete storage solution

    A NAS enclosure may be sold without drives. Recovering data if the NAS is lost also requires another copy.

    Check which drives are included with each version and plan for a separate backup destination.

  • Assuming a shared folder means you’re allowed to distribute recordings

    Technical access doesn’t determine the privacy grounds or rights that apply to recordings. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers audio recordings in which people can be recognised to be personal data.

    Decide who should have access and check what rights are required for the copying and sharing you have in mind.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay option for sharing files and scheduling backups of PC folders.

  • Synology describes support for Synology Drive and backing up the NAS to other destinations.
  • Check which features you set up; having the software doesn’t mean your group recordings are already backed up safely.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay option with a USB Copy button for groups that want to submit recordings via USB.

  • QNAP lists two drive bays, one Gigabit Ethernet port and a USB Copy button for the TS-233.
  • These are model specifications, not an independent test of speed or ease of use; check the copying settings.

TerraMaster

The F2-212 is a two-bay option for which the manufacturer describes sharing, synchronisation and snapshot features.

  • The manufacturer describes file-sharing and synchronisation features.
  • Check current software support and the backup setup you’ll need; a snapshot on the same NAS isn’t a separate backup.

NAS products at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are Synology NAS models for central storage and file sharing. Check which drives are included with each version, and also set up a separate backup that you’ve tested.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option to consider for central storage of group files; also set up a separate backup for recovery.

The product listing specifies five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. HDDs are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to consider for central storage of group files; check in advance how users will access them and how you’ll restore files.

The product name identifies this model as a Synology DiskStation.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

An option to consider for central storage of group files; also plan a separate backup destination for recovery.

The product name states that hard drives are not included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are RAID or synchronisation enough to back up recordings?

No. A RAID setup is no substitute for a separate backup, and a real-time copy won’t necessarily let you return to an earlier version. Make a copy in another location and test whether you can restore a recording. The National Cyber Security Centre of the Netherlands recommends testing recovery from a backup.

How should you start transferring existing recordings?

Start with a consistent folder structure and decide who can add files. Test the transfer method and restore a few recordings from the backup before moving the whole archive.

Do you need to buy anything else with your NAS?

Check whether drives are included with the version you’ve chosen and decide which separate backup destination you’ll need. If you don’t need shared network access, an external drive may be enough for a simple backup.

Can you store recordings with recognisable voices on a NAS and share them with members?

Audio recordings in which people can be recognised are personal data, but whether a particular recording can be stored or shared depends on its purpose, the applicable GDPR legal basis and the arrangements for that recording. The Dutch Data Protection Authority makes clear that personal data cannot simply be shared with others; decide this before the group processes or distributes the recordings.

Can you copy copyrighted language recordings for the group?

A private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public. The Government of the Netherlands advises you to respect copyright: check who owns the rights and what permission or licence covers the copying and sharing you have in mind. A NAS doesn’t change those rights.