Choose a NAS to suit the way you record and back up your files. Two drive bays can provide drive redundancy, but they don’t replace a separate backup of irreplaceable interviews. Also compare the dimensions, noise levels under the conditions in which you’ll use the NAS, and the cost and space needed for suitable drives. If your recordings feature identifiable people, make sure you have appropriate access controls and security measures in place.
Who is a NAS for interview recordings suitable for?
Creators with irreplaceable interviews
You want to be able to recover original conversations after a drive failure or mistake. Drive redundancy and a separate backup are not substitutes for one another. For important business data, the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping the originals and two backups.
Creators with a small or quiet workspace
You have limited desk space or record close to your storage device. Compare the dimensions, and check the conditions under which noise levels are measured.
Creators who share or restrict access to recordings
You want to manage files from multiple devices or share them with others. If interviewees are identifiable, recordings may contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that security measures should be appropriate to the risks involved in processing that data.
What should you look for when choosing one?
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovering recordings |
Check the storage configuration and make sure you have a backup destination outside the NAS. Test that you can restore a file. RAID 1 provides redundancy in the event of a drive failure, but it isn’t a separate backup. |
If you can’t afford to lose an original interview, you’ll want to know how to recover it if something goes wrong. Recovery is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Space and noise |
Measure the height, width and depth, leaving room for cables and airflow. QNAP lists the TS-233 as 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm; ASUSTOR lists the AS1102TL as 165 × 102 × 218 mm, with a noise level of 18,6 dB when the HDDs are idle. This noise level is not a measurement taken during writing. |
If your desk is cramped or you record close to your storage device, you’ll want a NAS that fits and whose noise levels suit the way you work. For around 27% of consumers, size and noise are the main priorities. |
| Access and security |
Check who needs access and which account, sharing and backup settings are available. Make sure your security measures are appropriate to the risks posed by your recordings. |
If you store identifiable or confidential conversations, you’ll want to decide who can view and share them. Restricting access is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Transfers and drives |
Check that the transfer method you want works with your computer or phone, and find out which drive types the model supports. Compare the complete setup, including the backup destination. |
If you want to save recordings from your devices without a complicated process, focus on transfer options and your choice of drives. Easy transfers are the main priority for around 20% of consumers. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming RAID 1 is a complete backup
RAID 1 provides redundancy if a drive fails, but it won’t protect you against every cause of data loss.
Plan for a separate backup destination, and test that you can restore a recording from it.
A separate backup destination requires extra storage space and management.
-
Comparing only the dimensions of the empty NAS
The enclosure, cables and space needed for ventilation all affect whether the setup will fit on your desk. Supported drive types also vary by model.
Measure the available space, allowing for connections and airflow, and check which drives are compatible and what’s included in the offer.
Compatible drives and any separate backup storage will also take up space.
-
Assuming a noise rating for idle drives reflects noise during transfers
The stated 18,6 dB for the ASUSTOR AS1102TL applies when the HDDs are idle. It doesn’t tell you how much noise you’ll hear during reading or writing.
Compare the conditions under which noise levels are measured, and move the NAS away from your recording area if needed.
-
Keeping recordings indefinitely just because there’s space
If people are identifiable and the GDPR applies, personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary for its intended purpose.
Set an appropriate retention period for those recordings, and manage access in a way that reflects the risks.
Brands to compare
Synology
The DS223j we reviewed is a two-bay NAS for central file management, sharing and backup. It may be worth considering if your workflow involves several devices.
- Synology describes support for Synology Drive and multiple backup destinations.
- You may need to configure these features, and they don’t make a separate backup unnecessary.
QNAP
The TS-233 we reviewed is a two-bay NAS. Its stated enclosure width may be useful to know if desk space is limited.
- QNAP specifies a width of 91,7 mm and support for 3,5-inch SATA HDDs and 2,5-inch SATA SSDs.
- The stated 10,81 W is typical consumption in QNAP’s test setup and won’t predict the power consumption on your desk.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL we reviewed has two bays. Its dimensions and the conditions attached to its noise rating are worth considering when weighing up placement and noise.
- ASUSTOR specifies a width of 102 mm, a depth of 218 mm and a noise level of 18,6 dB when the HDDs are idle.
- The noise rating is not a measurement taken during active transfers. This model’s system memory cannot be upgraded.
NAS models at Joybuy
These Joybuy models are options to consider for central storage of interview recordings. Before choosing your complete setup, check each model’s dimensions, drive options and how it will fit on your desk.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
An option to consider if you want to manage interview recordings centrally in a desk-based setup.
Joybuy lists five drive bays, expandable to 15 with an expansion unit.
For irreplaceable recordings, plan for a separate backup too. If interviewees are identifiable, make sure you have appropriate access controls and security measures in place.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
An option to consider if you’re looking for a two-bay NAS for central storage and file sharing.
Check that the storage configuration you choose and your separate backup plan are right for your recordings.
If interviewees are identifiable, make sure you have appropriate access controls, security measures and retention periods in place.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
An option to consider if you’re looking for central storage and file management.
Check the dimensions and connections in advance to make sure they’ll suit your workspace and network.
Keep a separate backup of important recordings. NAS features don’t replace one automatically.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does a NAS with two drives also count as my backup?
No. With two drives, RAID 1 can protect you against a drive failure, but it isn’t a separate backup. For important business data, the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping the original files and two backups. Also check that you can restore a recording.
Can I put the NAS right next to my microphone?
It depends on your space and how noisy the NAS is during use. The 18,6 dB stated by ASUSTOR for the AS1102TL applies when the HDDs are idle; it doesn’t prove how quiet the model is while writing. If noise is a concern, placing it further away from your recording area may help.
Do I have to delete interview recordings in the Netherlands after a set period?
The GDPR doesn’t set a specific, general retention period for personal data. If interviewees are identifiable and the GDPR applies, organisations must not keep personal data for longer than necessary for its intended purpose. The Dutch Data Protection Authority therefore advises setting an appropriate period and taking any other applicable rules into account.
Is consent always the required legal basis under the GDPR for keeping an interview?
No. Consent is one of the possible legal bases under the GDPR. If the GDPR applies to the way you process the data, assess in advance which legal basis is appropriate. Choosing a NAS doesn’t determine that basis. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that organisations must assess this for their own processing activities.
What should I keep doing after installation?
Regularly check that new recordings are saved in the intended location and that you can restore them from a separate backup. If recordings feature identifiable people, make sure your access controls and security measures are appropriate to the risks, and decide how long you need to keep them.