Who is a NAS suitable for?

Volunteers managing scans together

A central storage location with individually configurable access can be useful when several volunteers manage documents, rather than leaving files on one computer. The NCSC outlines points to consider for using a NAS securely.

Managers of hard-to-replace documents

If you need to restore scans after deletion, a fault or an incident, you’ll need a separate backup as well as the NAS. The NCSC recommends keeping backups on at least two different types of media.

Groups with confidential records

If scans contain personal data, the group needs to decide who requires access and set appropriate permissions. This consideration doesn’t automatically apply to every collection of scans; the AP provides guidance on access to personal data.

What should you look for in a NAS for group scanning?

First decide how the group will share and restore documents, then choose the enclosure and drives. That way, access and your recovery plan take priority over simply counting the drive bays.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Recoverability Check which backup destinations are supported and plan to keep a copy outside the NAS. The NCSC recommends keeping backups on at least two different types of media. If I need to restore irreplaceable scans, I want to know in advance where the separate copy is and how recovery works. Around 29% of consumers put the ability to restore scans first.
Access permissions Check whether you can configure users and shared folders for different tasks. If scans contain personal data, permissions must be set appropriately in line with AP guidance. If not every volunteer needs the same records, I want to be able to limit access by task. Around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled access to confidential scans.
Working together Look at the options for shared folders and user management; also decide whether access from outside the premises is needed. If several volunteers need to find the same scans, I want them to be able to access one archive with appropriate permissions. This is the top priority for around 24% of consumers.
Overall setup Check the number of drive bays, which drives are included and whether your chosen drives are compatible with the exact model. I want to know in advance which components and management tasks are involved in our setup. Around 18% of consumers put purchase and management costs first.

Common mistakes when buying a NAS

  • Thinking RAID or snapshots count as a full backup

    A problem with central storage can also affect the scans stored on it. The NCSC stresses that a NAS or RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

    Before buying, decide where the extra copy will be kept and who will carry out the recovery. Also test that you can restore a scan successfully.

    A separate backup requires suitable storage, as well as time to set it up and test recovery.

  • Assuming the NAS already includes drives

    Your final shopping list depends on what’s included with the exact product and which drives the model supports.

    Check the product listing to see whether drives are included, then compare compatibility with the manufacturer’s information for the exact model.

    With some models, compatible drives need to be bought separately.

  • Giving every volunteer the same access

    For scans containing personal data, unnecessarily broad access can compromise confidentiality. The AP says organisations must protect personal data appropriately and manage permissions properly.

    Set up folders and permissions according to people’s roles, and review them when volunteers change roles.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model for centralised file management and backup features.

  • Synology lists delegated admin roles and Hyper Backup for the DS225+.
  • Check drive compatibility and set up your backup separately; a product feature alone doesn’t guarantee that your backup will work.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a model worth comparing if your group wants to consider snapshots and user account settings.

  • QNAP lists snapshots, account security and two-step verification for the TS-233.
  • These are model features, not an assessment of how secure your final setup will be; snapshots are no substitute for a separate backup.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model worth comparing if snapshots and a 2.5-gigabit network port are relevant to you.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots and 2 GB of memory for this specific model.
  • Its storage and networking features don’t replace the need for a separate recovery plan.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay model worth comparing if your group is also considering other applications.

  • UGREEN lists two drive bays and a 2.5-gigabit network port for this model.
  • The storage drives are sold separately; also check for yourself how user permissions and backups will be set up.

NAS models at Joybuy for shared document access

This Joybuy selection features Synology NAS models for shared document access and backup. Check which drives are included with each model, and always set up a separate backup.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A good option if your group wants to manage shared documents and allow room for expansion.

The product description lists five drive bays, expansion to fifteen and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included; check the compatibility of your chosen drives.

RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q NAS

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q NAS

A good option if your group wants to manage user accounts and shared folders.

The product description lists two drive bays, AES-256-bit volume encryption, and RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD. Compatible hard drives are required for installation.

RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A good option if your group manages shared documents and wants to compare models with multiple drive bays.

The product description lists eight drive bays, expansion with an expansion unit and two 2.5GbE ports. Compatible hard drives are required for installation.

RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

A good option if your group wants to compare shared document management and separate backup options.

The product description lists four drive bays, expansion to nine and two 2.5GbE ports. The title states that hard drives aren’t included.

RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about a NAS for group scanning

Is RAID enough to protect our scans?

No, RAID is no substitute for a backup. The NCSC recommends keeping a separate copy and storing backups on at least two different types of media. You should also decide how the group will restore a scan.

Should volunteers be able to access the NAS directly from outside the premises?

Not necessarily. First decide whether remote access is needed; the NCSC recommends that, wherever possible, a NAS shouldn’t be made available over the internet because of the increased security risk.

Which access permissions should we set?

Give volunteers access to the folders they need for their tasks. If scans contain personal data, the organisation must protect it appropriately and manage permissions properly in line with AP guidance.

Do we need a data processing agreement for a cloud backup?

You may need one if a cloud service processes personal data on the group’s behalf. The AP requires a written data processing agreement in that situation. Whether this applies to a particular service depends on the actual roles and flow of data.

Does every personal data breach involving scanned documents have to be reported to the AP?

No, not every data breach needs to be reported. According to the AP, a data breach must be reported unless it’s unlikely to pose a risk to the rights and freedoms of the people affected. Whether the people affected must also be informed depends on the likelihood of a high risk; assess each incident on its own facts.