Who is a NAS for group recordings suitable for?

Keeper of irreplaceable recordings

Wants to store rehearsals or performances in one central place and be able to retrieve deleted or damaged files. Synology describes backups to another destination as an extra layer of protection alongside local copies.

Group file coordinator

Wants designated members to be able to find and share recordings, with access rights suited to their roles. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that organisations must protect personal data properly.

Manager of a growing archive

Wants to estimate the required usable storage capacity and check whether extra drive bays will make it easier to expand later. Synology notes that usable capacity depends on the drives and the storage configuration you choose.

What should you look for in a NAS for group recordings?

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit when: the usable capacity you’ve calculated, including expected growth, will fit on two suitable drives and the group wants to store and share files centrally.

Bear in mind: there’s less room for future expansion inside the enclosure; mirroring uses storage space and isn’t a separate backup.

NAS with four drive bays

A good fit when: the archive is expected to grow and the group wants more internal drive bays to expand storage later.

Bear in mind: extra bays don’t remove the need for a separate backup; first decide whether the additional expansion room justifies the cost and setup.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recovering recordings Check which backup destinations the exact model supports, assign someone to manage recovery and test restoring a file. Synology describes a copy to another destination as an extra layer of protection. If we can’t record rehearsals or performances again, I want to be able to restore a copy after accidental deletion or a fault too; around 36% of consumers prioritise recovery.
Access and collaboration Check user accounts, folder permissions and the supported devices and sharing methods. Only set up remote access once it’s clear who needs it. If several members use the files, I want everyone to be able to find the right recordings without sharing everything with everyone; around 29% of consumers prioritise collaboration and shared access.
Usable capacity and growth Add up your existing files, estimate future growth and calculate usable capacity based on your chosen drives and storage configuration. Raw capacity isn’t the same as the space available for files. If our archive keeps growing, I want to plan for the files we can actually store; around 21% of consumers prioritise archive growth.
Restricted access Decide who needs access to each collection and whether recordings feature identifiable people or include music that can’t be shared freely. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable audio recordings may constitute personal data. If not every recording is intended for the whole group or for sharing outside it, I want to be able to choose who can access each folder; around 14% of consumers prioritise restricting access.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking drive mirroring for a complete backup

    Mirroring or keeping a local copy on the NAS isn’t the same as having a copy at another destination. Synology recommends backing up to another location as well as keeping local copies.

    Before buying, check which backup methods the exact model supports and assign someone to carry out a test recovery regularly.

    Allow for a separate backup destination and time to run recovery tests.

  • Assuming raw capacity is the same as usable archive space

    The space available for files depends, among other things, on the drives and storage configuration you choose. Synology distinguishes between raw and usable capacity.

    Calculate the space available with the drives and configuration you’ve actually chosen, and factor in the archive’s expected growth.

  • Assuming the NAS enclosure comes with drives

    The manufacturer states that the QNAP TS-264 is supplied without hard drives. For the models mentioned, Synology refers customers to a compatibility list.

    Check what’s included with the exact version and whether your chosen drives are compatible. Bear in mind that you may need to buy the drives separately.

  • Making all recordings available in one general shared folder

    According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, a recording in which someone is identifiable may constitute personal data. The Dutch government says that permission from the creator is the starting point for using other people’s copyright-protected music.

    Give access to each collection only to the intended people, and check the rights before sharing material more widely.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS425+ has four. Both are worth considering for groups looking to combine central storage with a separate backup plan.

  • Synology describes Hyper Backup as a way to copy data to external destinations.
  • Usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration; check that your chosen drives are compatible.

QNAP

The TS-264 is a NAS with two drive bays for groups who also want to explore network and storage expansion options.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports and M.2 slots for the TS-264.
  • The manufacturer states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives. The network ports alone don’t guarantee speed; your other network equipment and workflow matter too.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL and Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 are two-bay models for central storage.

  • ASUSTOR lists Gigabit Ethernet and Btrfs/iSCSI snapshots for the AS1102TL; the manufacturer lists 2.5GbE for the AS3302T v2.
  • The stated speeds are manufacturer measurements taken under optimised conditions, and don’t directly indicate the speeds a group can achieve in its own setup.

NAS options on Joybuy

These models are designed for central storage and sharing group files, with options for growing archives and different numbers of drive bays.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Worth considering if you’re looking for central file sharing and room for a growing archive.

Five drive bays, expandable to fifteen with an expansion unit; two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Worth considering if the group wants to use shared folders and user accounts to access files.

Two drive bays; the description lists RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD. This version is listed without drives. RAID 1 is not a substitute for a separate backup.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth considering if your archive needs a lot of drive bays and the group wants to share files centrally.

Eight drive bays, expandable with an expansion unit, and two 2.5GbE ports.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Worth considering if you’re looking for four internal drive bays and may want to expand your archive later.

Four drive bays, expandable to nine with an expansion unit, and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up our recordings?

No, RAID 1 isn’t a copy stored at another destination. Set up a separate backup as well and test restoring a file regularly; Synology also recommends backing up to another location.

How should we set up access for group members?

Give members individual accounts and only the permissions they need for their role. Where personal data is involved, the appropriate measures depend on the risks associated with the specific recordings and processing.

Do identifiable voices in our recordings count as personal data?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, a recording in which someone is identifiable may constitute personal data. The group needs an applicable legal basis under the GDPR for processing it; consent is one possible basis, but isn’t automatically the only one.

How long can we keep recordings containing personal data?

Don’t keep personal data for longer than necessary for its purpose. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that the GDPR doesn’t set a specific general retention period, so decide on and justify an appropriate period for the collection in question.

Can we automatically share recorded music with all members or online?

No, a storage device doesn’t grant you the right to use the music. The Dutch government says that permission from the creator is the starting point for using other people’s copyright-protected music; a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public. Check the rights for the specific recordings and the sharing you have in mind.