Who is a NAS suitable for?

Administrator who needs to restore the journal

Wants to restore a usable earlier copy after deletion, damage or an incident. The Digital Trust Center advises against relying on a single storage location, so plan a separate copy and a recovery test too.

Group with changing editors

Needs a shared storage location, but wants to decide which volunteers can read, edit or manage files. Check that individual accounts and permissions suit the way the group works together.

Treasurer weighing up the total cost

Wants to weigh the cost of the NAS enclosure against drives, a second backup location and possibly a cloud service. The Digital Trust Center says that manually copying files to an external hard drive may be enough if network features aren't needed.

What should you consider when choosing?

NAS with scheduled backups

A good fit when: several volunteers regularly work on the same digital journal and someone takes responsibility for managing it.

Keep in mind: settings, updates and recovery tests still need to be managed; you'll also need a separate copy.

External drive

A good fit when: one administrator maintains the journal and the group doesn't need shared network access or automatic backups.

Keep in mind: it's easy to forget to copy files manually, so agree on a routine and test that you can restore them.

Cloud service as a second location

A good fit when: the group wants to keep a copy away from its own premises and can manage access settings.

Keep in mind: if a service provider processes personal data on behalf of the group, a written data processing agreement is required.

Don't just look at the number of drive bays. First decide how you'll restore an earlier version, who will have access and where the separate copy will be kept.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Restorable copy Check for scheduled backups, versioning or snapshot features, a separate destination and the option to run a recovery test. If I need to restore a journal file after it's been deleted or damaged, I want to know which earlier copy is available. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recovery.
Access for group members Check for individual accounts, folder permissions and how to revoke access for volunteers who leave. When several volunteers use the journal, I want to assign suitable read, edit and management access to each of them. Around 29% of consumers prioritise access management.
Transferable management Check whether scheduled tasks and status notifications can be set up, and whether a second administrator can follow the recovery procedure. When volunteers change roles, I want someone else to be able to take over the backup routine. Around 21% of consumers prioritise easy-to-transfer management.
Total cost Check which drives are included and budget separately for the additional backup destination. I want to weigh up the combined cost of the enclosure, drives and second copy. Around 14% of consumers prioritise total cost.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking two drives for two independent backups

    RAID can help if one drive fails, but the National Cyber Security Centre says it's not a substitute for a backup. Deletion, theft or damage at the same location can still affect both copies.

    Decide where the separate copy will be kept and test that you can restore a journal file.

    A separate storage destination means extra storage and time for recovery tests.

  • Confusing synchronisation with keeping an earlier version

    A central storage location alone doesn't tell you whether you can restore an earlier version after an unwanted change.

    Check which versioning or snapshot features are available, and set up a separate backup task that suits the way the group works.

  • Giving every volunteer the same administrator account

    This makes it harder to assign suitable read, edit and management permissions. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends matching permissions to people's tasks.

    Make it clear who can edit files and who manages the NAS and backups. Revoke access when a volunteer leaves.

    When group membership changes, keeping accounts and access permissions up to date takes time.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay model worth comparing for a small group that wants to share files and schedule backups of computer files.

  • Synology says Synology Drive and Hyper Backup support scheduled or immediate computer backups and copies to multiple destinations.
  • Check that the backup features suit the computers and destination you're using. Snapshots on the NAS are not a separate backup.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model worth comparing if the group wants to set up network storage with individual user accounts.

  • QNAP lists two drive bays, one gigabit network port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory for the TS-233.
  • These hardware specifications don't determine which backup routine is right for the journal; check that the software has the features you need.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is an alternative worth comparing for a group considering snapshots and straightforward drive installation.

  • ASUSTOR lists support for Btrfs/iSCSI snapshots, tool-free installation and gigabit Ethernet.
  • These manufacturer specifications are not an independent recovery test. Keep a separate backup as well.

Products for shared storage and backups

This selection includes Synology NAS models for central storage and a portable external drive for a separate backup. An external drive doesn't offer the same shared network access as a NAS.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A NAS for a group that wants to share files centrally and use backup features.

Five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q NAS

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

A NAS to consider if the group needs shared folders and individual user accounts.

Two drive bays, two network ports and AES-256-bit volume encryption. Drives must be installed separately.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A NAS for central storage and backup features. Decide in advance how many drive bays the group needs.

Eight drive bays, expansion capability and two 2.5GbE ports.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A NAS for a permanent shared storage location with backup features.

Four drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports and SSD cache support. Hard drives not included.

Joybuy
My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive with password protection and automatic backup software

My Passport 6TB White Portable Hard Drive

A portable USB drive for an administrator who wants to keep a separate copy. This isn't a NAS and doesn't offer shared network access.

6 TB, scheduled backups, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up the journal?

No. RAID can keep a NAS running if one drive fails, but the National Cyber Security Centre says it doesn't replace a backup. Keep a separate copy and try restoring a file.

How do you set up a NAS securely for several volunteers?

Give users only the permissions they need and change default passwords. The National Cyber Security Centre advises against making a NAS directly accessible over the internet without good reason. Also agree who will manage accounts and backups.

What costs and support should the group check in advance?

Check which drives are included, what's needed for a separate backup destination, and who will carry out updates and recovery tests. Also read the terms for your chosen model and seller.

Can a community group use a NAS for a journal containing personal data?

A NAS isn't prohibited in itself, but the group must decide on appropriate security measures based on the risks. The Dutch government points out that associations must also handle personal data carefully. If a processor handles personal data on the group's behalf, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says a written data processing agreement is required.