Project archivist
You want to organise and store documents and photos from a garden research project, and be able to restore them later. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a NAS is not automatically a separate backup.
Choose a NAS based on the files you want to keep, the space you have and your plan for a separate backup. Then compare the number of bays and network connections. A NAS can make project files available in one central place, but it isn’t automatically a recoverable second copy. You’ll also need to consider suitable drives, space for cables and ventilation.
You want to organise and store documents and photos from a garden research project, and be able to restore them later. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a NAS is not automatically a separate backup.
You have limited space next to your computer, so you’ll want to consider both the dimensions of the enclosure and the room needed for cables and ventilation.
You want to access files on several devices or share them with others. In that case, access settings matter, as does how you share images if they show identifiable people.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverable archive | Check for scheduled file backups, a separate backup destination and the ability to restore a file. | I want to be able to recover deleted or damaged project files rather than rely on a single NAS. Around 33% of consumers with this archiving goal give recoverability top priority. |
| Desk space | Measure the width, depth and height, and leave room for connections and ventilation. | If my desk has limited space, I want to know whether the enclosure will fit with cables attached and enough room for ventilation. Around 27% of consumers with this archiving goal put available space first. |
| Access and sharing | Check compatibility with your devices, user permissions and the remote access you need. | I want to be able to find project files on my devices and share them only with the people who need them. Around 20% of consumers with this archiving goal give access, organisation and controlled sharing top priority. |
| Total purchase and running costs | Check which drives are compatible, whether they’re included and what you’ll need for a separate backup. | I want to know in advance which drives and backup destination I’ll need, rather than focus only on the enclosure. Around 20% of consumers with this archiving goal put total purchase and running costs first. |
A second drive in the same NAS is no substitute for a separate copy that you can restore files from. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping a separate backup and testing your recovery process.
Plan for a separate backup destination and periodically try restoring a project file.
As well as storage, a separate backup destination also takes time to test for recovery.
Specified depth varies by model, and you’ll also need room for cables and positioning. So a narrow enclosure won’t necessarily fit on a shallow desk.
Measure the entire space where you plan to put it and compare this with the dimensions of the exact model, allowing room for connections and ventilation.
Supported drive types vary by model. For example, the ASUSTOR AS1102T specifications list 3.5-inch SATA HDDs, while Synology refers to its compatibility list for the DS225+.
Before buying, check the drive type and confirm that your drives are compatible with the exact model. If your existing drives aren’t suitable, you may need to buy compatible ones.
The DS223j is worth considering if you’re looking for file management and scheduled backups of PC folders. The DS225+ is a separate model to consider if you also want a 2.5GbE port.
The TS-233 is a two-bay enclosure to compare if you have limited space for it.
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay option to compare if 2.5GbE is relevant to your network.
The Joybuy options shown are Synology NAS systems for centralised file sharing and backup. Compare the number of bays and stated dimensions with the space available on your desk.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing and backup features for a central project archive. Consider this model only if five bays will fit in your available space.
Five bays and two 2.5GbE ports. The stated dimensions are 165.5 × 241 × 297.9 mm. Hard drives are not included.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file sharing and backup for central archive management. Check that eight bays and the stated dimensions will fit in your available space.
Eight bays and two 2.5GbE ports. The stated dimensions are 45 × 36 × 30 cm.
Image unavailable
The product description mentions file and photo management and data protection. Compare the four bays and stated dimensions with your archiving needs and desk space.
Four bays and two 2.5GbE ports. The stated dimensions are 29 × 26 × 24 cm. Hard drives are not included.
No. Don’t treat a mirrored pair as your separate recovery copy. Keep a backup on a different destination too, and test that you can restore files. The National Cyber Security Centre describes separate copies and recovery testing as part of a backup strategy.
Compare the height, width and depth of the exact model, and allow for connections and ventilation. Manufacturer noise measurements are taken under specific test conditions, so they don’t necessarily predict how loud the device will be on your desk.
Before buying, check whether compatible drives are included and what separate backup destination you’ll need. ACM Consumer Information explains that your statutory guarantee applies alongside any manufacturer’s warranty; if a product is faulty, the seller is your point of contact.
Photos showing identifiable people contain personal data. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use may apply if you keep images private or share them with only a very limited group. This exception doesn’t apply to business use or wider publication. What applies depends on who is carrying out the research and what happens to the images.
Don’t automatically enable public internet access to share files. QNAP recommends, among other things, disabling UPnP port forwarding on its NAS systems. Check the current access settings for the model you choose too.