Who is this for?

Project archive manager

You want to be able to find research files and previous versions after a mistake or system failure. So work out the usable capacity you need and set up a separate backup alongside the NAS. Make sure you also test that you can restore files from it. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups by carrying out a restore.

Frequent file transfer user

You regularly move large photos, measurement data or other project files, and want to know whether 2.5GbE could make a difference across your entire network. Compare the connections on the NAS and computer, as well as those on any network equipment in between.

Shared project folder manager

Several people use the archive, and they may need different access and editing permissions. If an organisation processes personal data, its security measures must be appropriate to the risks, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by working out how much capacity your archive and saved versions will need. Then compare the network connection and access settings, and include a separate backup destination in your setup.

What to consider What to look for Who should prioritise this?
Restoring files Copy important folders to another destination and test that you can restore files. If I want to be able to retrieve research files after a system failure or mistake, I’ll set up a restorable copy in addition to the NAS. Around 33% of consumers say the ability to restore files is their top priority.
File transfers Compare the network ports on the NAS and computer with the equipment in between. A port specification doesn’t guarantee real-world speeds. If I often move large files, I want to know whether my entire network supports the connection I’ve chosen. Around 27% of consumers say transfer speeds are their top priority.
Shared access Check whether you can assign appropriate access and editing permissions to users and shared folders. When several people use project folders, I want to tailor access to their tasks. Around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled sharing.
Usable capacity Add up your current files, saved versions and expected growth. Then calculate the usable space available with your chosen drives and configuration. If the archive is growing, I want to plan for enough usable space, taking compatible drives and a separate backup destination into account. Around 20% of consumers start by considering room for growth and the overall setup.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming two mirrored drives count as two independent backups

    Mirroring the drives inside a NAS is a storage configuration, not a separate copy stored elsewhere. This means a problem with the NAS could affect more than one drive.

    Set up a copy at another destination and try restoring important project files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing with a restore.

    Allow for an extra backup destination and time to test restores.

  • Assuming a 2.5GbE port guarantees a particular file transfer speed

    File transfer speeds depend on more than the port on the NAS. Your computer and any network equipment in between also play a part, and manufacturers’ test results may not reflect your setup.

    Check the entire connection before choosing a NAS based on a faster network port.

    You may also need a compatible network connection on your workstation or suitable network equipment.

  • Comparing NAS enclosures alone

    Hard drives aren’t included with some models. Your choice of drives and storage configuration will affect how much space is available for files and versions.

    Make a parts list first, check drive compatibility and calculate the capacity you’ll need, including a separate backup destination.

    Compatible hard drives and a separate storage destination are part of the overall setup.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay option for centralised files, syncing and backups. Synology lists a built-in 2.5GbE port.

  • Usable capacity depends on your choice of drives and configuration.
  • Check drive compatibility before you buy. Synology’s throughput results come from its own tests and may differ in another setup.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-264-8G has two drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports and USB connections.

  • These ports and connections are worth considering when comparing network connectivity and local copying options.
  • QNAP says the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives, so check the compatibility list. QNAP advises against connecting the NAS directly to the internet.

ASUSTOR

The DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay alternative that, according to ASUSTOR, offers 2.5GbE and supports Btrfs snapshots.

  • Snapshots may be useful if you want to retrieve previous file versions.
  • ASUSTOR’s published RAID 1 throughput was measured in a laboratory under optimised conditions, so it may not be comparable with results from another setup. Snapshots aren’t a substitute for a separate backup.

UGREEN

According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP2800 has two drive bays and 2.5GbE, while the DH2300 is a two-bay option with 1GbE.

  • The difference in network connections gives you practical points to weigh up against the size and frequency of your file transfers.
  • UGREEN says that drives aren’t included with either model. Check which drives are compatible and what’s included in the offer.

Joybuy products

These NAS options are aimed at growing project archives and frequent file transfers. Compare the number of drive bays and listed network connections with your capacity and networking needs.

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to consider if you need plenty of drive bays and network connections for your project archive.

The product description lists eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. These connections alone don’t guarantee a particular transfer speed, so check your computer and any network equipment in between too.

Also plan for a separate backup destination and test that you can restore files.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

An option to consider if you want to look at multiple drive bays and 2.5GbE connections for a growing archive.

The product description lists five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included, so check compatibility and plan capacity for your files and versions.

A NAS isn’t a substitute for a separate backup destination. Keep a copy elsewhere and test that you can restore files.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

An option to consider if four drive bays suit the planned capacity of your project archive.

The product description lists four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included, so check which drives are compatible with the configuration.

A NAS isn’t a separate backup destination in its own right. Keep a copy elsewhere and test that you can restore files.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up a garden research archive?

No. Treat mirroring as a storage configuration and also make a copy at another destination. Test with a trial restore to check that you can retrieve important project files.

How can you avoid losing existing files on a drive when setting up a NAS?

First, make a copy elsewhere of any files on a drive you plan to reuse, and check compatibility before installation. Synology’s product guide for the DS225+ warns that an installed drive containing existing data will be formatted.

Are hard drives included with a NAS?

It varies by model and offer. QNAP says the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives, and UGREEN says the same of the DXP2800 and DH2300 reviewed here. Check what’s included in the offer, drive compatibility and your separate backup destination.

Which privacy rules apply to research photos and other personal data?

If an organisation processes personal data, its security measures must be appropriate to the risks involved, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. The GDPR household exemption applies to personal or domestic use only. So establish who is carrying out the project and what data will be stored; there isn’t one NAS specification that suits every garden project.

Does a NAS need to be accessible directly from the internet to share files?

No. QNAP advises against connecting a NAS directly to the internet. First decide whether you need access from outside your local network, then choose a suitable, secure method of access in line with the manufacturer’s guidance.