Who is this buying guide for?

Administrator who needs to restore older versions

You want to restore an earlier spreadsheet after an accidental change or deletion, and are prepared to arrange recovery tests. The National Cyber Security Centre advises checking that files can be opened from a backup.

Group with confidential membership records

You need to decide who can view the files and how any personal data should be protected. The Information Commissioner's Office stresses that organisations must protect personal data appropriately; using a NAS does not remove that responsibility.

Volunteer with little time for administration

You want scheduled copies and a straightforward way to check backup tasks, without features that aren't needed for your group's records. The National Cyber Security Centre also describes manually copying files to an external drive as a possible backup method.

What should you look for?

NAS with scheduled backups

Choose this option when: several authorised people use files centrally and someone can check the tasks and test recovery.

Bear in mind: you'll need to manage the system, choose suitable drives and set up a separate backup destination; RAID alone isn't a backup. The National Cyber Security Centre makes this distinction too.

External drive

Choose this option when: one administrator looks after a small collection of files and can follow a manual process consistently.

Bear in mind: it's easy to forget to copy files manually. Sharing and backing up from several computers require additional arrangements.

Cloud storage or cloud backup

Choose this option when: you need access from different locations or a backup stored away from your own premises.

Bear in mind: check the recovery options and your agreement with the service provider. If you use a processor to handle personal data, the Information Commissioner's Office says a written data processing agreement is required.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Restoring older versions Check version history, retention period, recovery process and a second destination. Test that a restored spreadsheet opens. If a change or deletion goes wrong, I want to be able to restore a usable earlier version. Around 36% of consumers put recoverability first.
File access Establish whether the files contain personal data, and check accounts, folder permissions, updates and whether internet access is needed. If the files contain members' details, I want to limit access to the volunteers who work with them. Around 29% of consumers prioritise access security.
Managing backups Check how the NAS receives files from the computers in use, how tasks are scheduled and who follows up on notifications. With little time for regular administration, I want copies to run to a set schedule and someone to check for errors. Around 21% of consumers put keeping administration to a minimum at the top of their list.
What you need Identify suitable storage drives, a separate backup destination and any cloud storage you may need. Before choosing a setup, I want to know what I'll need in addition to the NAS enclosure to store and restore spreadsheets. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a complete, easy-to-understand setup.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking two drives for two independent backups

    RAID can help you keep working if a drive fails, but it doesn't protect against every type of data loss and isn't a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre makes this distinction.

    Find out how you can restore both a deleted spreadsheet and data if the entire NAS is lost.

    A separate destination means keeping and managing an additional copy.

  • Assuming a successful task means recovery is proven

    A backup task may have run without you checking whether the right spreadsheet can be restored and opened.

    Regularly restore a test file and check that its contents are correct. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing recovery.

    Set aside time for recovery tests and decide how many older versions you want to keep.

  • Making the NAS accessible over the internet without weighing up the risks

    The National Cyber Security Centre warns that internet access can bring additional security risks. If personal data is involved, the group must decide on appropriate security measures.

    First decide whether remote access is necessary, then limit accounts and permissions to what users need.

Brands to consider

Synology

Synology describes the DS223j as a two-bay model with options for backing up PC folders and backing up to multiple destinations; the DS225+ belongs to a different product range.

  • According to Synology, the DS223j supports scheduled backups of PC folders and Hyper Backup.
  • Check the features and drive compatibility of the exact model. Two drive bays alone do not provide a separate backup.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 for central file storage and sharing.

  • QNAP lists snapshots, user accounts and two-step verification for the TS-233.
  • Snapshots can help you return to an earlier version, but they don't replace a copy stored in another location.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay model. ASUSTOR also offers a programme for scheduled backups from Windows PCs to a NAS.

  • The official specifications list two bays and a 2.5-Gigabit network port for the AS1102T; ASUSTOR describes scheduled backups and recovery through Backup Plan.
  • Check that the described process suits the group's computers and arrange a separate second copy.

UGREEN

The NASync DH2300 is a two-bay model for file storage and backups; its product information is aimed mainly at home use.

  • UGREEN describes access from different types of devices.
  • Storage drives aren't included. Also check that the backup and recovery process suits the group's needs.

Products for this use case

This selection includes NAS enclosures for central storage and external drives for straightforward file backups.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Suited to a group that wants to manage centralised file sharing and backups through DSM.

The product description lists five bays, expandable to fifteen with an expansion unit. Hard drives aren't included; setup involves configuring DSM and installing updates.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Suited to a group that wants to manage centralised files and backups on a NAS.

The product description lists eight bays, with expansion available using an expansion unit. Setup requires suitable hard drives and DSM configuration; updates remain part of ongoing management.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, hard drives not included

Synology DiskStation DS925+, hard drives not included

Suited to a group that wants centralised file sharing and can organise its own storage and maintenance.

The title states that hard drives aren't included. The description lists four bays, expandable to nine with a DX525; setup involves configuring DSM and installing updates.

Joybuy
My Passport 6TB White portable external hard drive

My Passport 6TB White

Suited to an administrator who wants to keep a scheduled file copy on a portable external drive.

The product information lists 6 TB, password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and automatic backups using the included Acronis software. This isn't a NAS for centralised network file sharing.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive, 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB

Suited to an administrator who wants to copy spreadsheet files from a computer to an external drive.

The product information lists 4 TB, a portable 2.5-inch design and a USB connection. This isn't a NAS for centralised network file sharing; safely eject the drive before disconnecting it.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID with two drives count as a backup?

No. The National Cyber Security Centre describes RAID as a way to keep working if a drive fails, not as a replacement for a separate backup. Make sure you can also recover files after deletion or if the NAS is lost.

How can we check that spreadsheets can really be restored?

Restore a test file and open the recovered spreadsheet to check its contents. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backups; make these checks part of the group's routine.

What else do you need besides the NAS enclosure?

Check whether storage drives are included and decide where to keep the separate second copy. Also agree who will deal with updates, task notifications and recovery tests. If you use a cloud destination, the group should assess the recovery options and the agreement with the service provider.

Which Dutch privacy rules apply to spreadsheets containing members' details?

If the association processes personal data, it must choose appropriate security measures for the processing and the risks involved. If it uses an external processor to handle that personal data, a written data processing agreement is required. The Information Commissioner's Office gives associations that process members' details as an example; the law does not prescribe a specific NAS model.