A NAS makes sense if you want to manage scans, family tree files and project versions centrally across multiple devices, or share selected files. For a small, temporary project, a well-backed-up folder may be simpler. Compare the file management software, recovery options and access settings, and factor in both internal drives and a separate backup. Consider permission to use data about living people separately from your choice of NAS.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Keeper of irreplaceable scans
You want to be able to recover documents and family tree files after a mistake or device failure, while also keeping a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important files.
Collector of lots of sources
You bring scans and notes together and want to be able to find the right source and version later. The National Archives describes archiving as selecting, organising and describing information so you can find it again later.
Sharer of family information
You want to give selected people access, but not make information about living people public without first assessing the situation. The Dutch Data Protection Authority makes clear that the circumstances and purpose of sharing matter.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start with what you want to do with your files: recover them, find them again, share them privately or keep the whole set-up within your budget.
| Consideration |
What to look for when buying |
Who should give this greater priority? |
| Recovery after loss or overwriting |
Check whether you can keep a copy in a separate location and actually restore files from it. |
If I don’t want to collect scans or notes all over again, recovery comes first. Around 33% of consumers give recovery the highest priority. |
| Finding scans and sources again |
Check how you can organise folders, file names and source notes; don’t assume that text in scans will be searchable. |
If I want to be able to check where a document came from later, organisation and source references matter to me. Around 25% of consumers give finding files again the highest priority. |
| Restricting access to family information |
Check whether you can set up separate users and folder permissions, and decide in advance who you’ll share each type of information with. |
If my project contains information about living family members, I want to restrict access carefully. Around 25% of consumers prioritise sharing files privately. |
| Overall set-up and storage |
Check whether drives are included, whether they’re compatible with the NAS and where you’ll keep a separate backup. |
If I want to understand the cost of the complete set-up, I include the enclosure, internal drives and backup. Around 17% of consumers give the overall set-up the highest priority. |
Pitfalls when archiving and buying
-
Thinking two internal drives are a complete back-up strategy
Drive mirroring or snapshots are no substitute for a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important files.
Keep a copy outside the NAS too, and test that you can restore files from it.
-
Assuming a NAS without drives is a complete set-up
With a diskless model, you’ll need to choose the internal drives separately. The drives you choose will partly determine the capacity available in your configuration.
Check what’s included in the offer, whether the drives are compatible and where you’ll keep a separate backup.
-
Assuming scans are automatically shareable or searchable
Usage rights vary from one scan to another, and a saved image isn’t automatically searchable text.
Check the rights for each collection. If you need text recognition, check that the exact NAS set-up supports it for the way you work.
Relevant brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay option for central file management and backing up PC folders.
- According to Synology, this model offers Drive access and scheduled backups of PC folders.
- Check which drives you’ll need, and keep a separate backup as well.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a home NAS for sharing and syncing files.
- QNAP lists account protection, two-step verification and snapshots for this model.
- Snapshots are part of the NAS set-up and don’t replace a separate backup.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is an option with two bays for internal drives.
- ASUSTOR specifies Btrfs, RAID 1, USB ports and SMB file access for this model.
- According to the specifications, the internal drive bays are designed for 3.5-inch SATA HDDs; check that your drives will fit.
UGREEN
UGREEN describes the NASync DH2300 as a two-bay option for home files and photo backups.
- The manufacturer lists home file storage and photo backups as uses for this model.
- According to the product information, storage drives aren’t included. Check what’s included in the offer you’re considering.
Products for archiving and back-ups
This selection includes NAS models for central file management and an external drive for a simpler storage or back-up option.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+
A good fit if you want to manage project files centrally and are looking for a NAS with multiple internal drive bays.
The product description lists five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
A good fit if you’re looking for a central NAS set-up for project files and want to choose the drives separately.
The product information lists a NAS with two drive bays, an Intel Celeron J4125 and 2 GB DDR4 memory. This model is sold without drives. RAID 1 is no substitute for a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
A good fit if you specifically need a central storage set-up with plenty of internal drive bays.
The product description lists eight drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports and expansion with an expansion unit. Work out in advance how much capacity your project really needs.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
A good fit if you want to manage project files centrally and put together the drive set-up yourself.
The product description lists four drive bays, expansion options and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black
A good fit for a simpler project archive or as a separate copy; this isn’t a NAS for central network access or file sharing.
This is a portable external hard drive with 2 TB of storage. The product description lists backup software with a scheduling feature and hardware-based 256-bit AES encryption.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID or a snapshot enough to back up your family tree?
No. Keep a separate backup too, and check that you can restore files from it. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions and a copy in another location; this is security advice, not a legal requirement for buying equipment for a school project.
How do you get started with archiving scans?
Set up a clear system for organising scans, source information and project versions. The National Archives distinguishes selecting, organising and describing information from simply making a backup.
Can you share information about living family members for your school project?
It depends on what information you process and who you share it with. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exception for use solely for personal or household purposes. If a school is involved or you plan wider publication, don’t assume that the exception applies without first assessing the situation. A NAS doesn’t in itself give you permission to make information public.
Can you include downloaded archive scans in your project?
Check the rights for each collection. According to the National Archives, the stated option to reuse scans freely applies to scans with a download button and the label ‘Public Domain’ or ‘CC0’; this doesn’t apply to scans from other providers.
What do you need to arrange besides the NAS enclosure?
Check whether drives are included in the offer, whether the drives you choose are compatible and where you’ll keep a separate backup. Make a recent copy regularly and try restoring a file.