Looking after irreplaceable scans
You want to be able to recover scans if a drive, device or working copy is lost. A separate backup matters more than simply having disk redundancy: Seagate distinguishes between RAID and a backup.
Start with a process for organising and describing scans, keeping a separate recovery copy and managing access. The National Archives of the Netherlands stresses that digital archiving involves more than simply making a backup. Then choose a NAS based on the usable capacity you need and the growth you expect. As Seagate explains, RAID is not a substitute for a separate backup.
You want to be able to recover scans if a drive, device or working copy is lost. A separate backup matters more than simply having disk redundancy: Seagate distinguishes between RAID and a backup.
You want future administrators to be able to find and understand the scans. The National Archives of the Netherlands describes organising and documenting files as part of digital archiving.
You want to make scans available to others, but sharing them internally and publishing them publicly are two different things. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that security measures should reflect the risks involved in processing personal data.
A good fit when: the usable capacity you calculate is enough for your scans and expected growth, and you also arrange a separate backup.
Consider: two bays limit your options for expansion. With a mirrored configuration, the second drive does not add extra usable storage.
A good fit when: several families will continue adding scans, or the collection includes other large files.
Consider: more bays give you more configuration options, but also mean more drives and administration. You’ll still need a separate backup.
| Consideration | What to check before you buy | Who should give this more weight? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverability | Check whether the NAS can back up to a separate destination and how to restore files. | If I don’t want to lose my only scan, I need a recovery copy stored outside the NAS. Around 36% of consumers rank recoverability as their top priority. |
| Findability and handover | Agree how volunteers will manage and hand over files and descriptions. | If future volunteers need to find and understand the scans, clear organisation matters. Around 29% of consumers prioritise findability and ease of handover. |
| Controlled sharing | Check accounts and access permissions; assess rights and an appropriate legal basis before publishing anything publicly. | If I’m sharing the collection with a community but don’t want to make it public by default, I’ll look at access management. Around 21% of consumers say controlled sharing is their top priority. |
| Growth and purchase | Estimate the collection’s size and growth, calculate usable capacity, and check whether drives are included and compatible. | If you want enough usable capacity without buying unnecessary drives or bays, compare expected growth with the configuration. Around 14% of consumers prioritise room to grow and the purchase decision. |
A NAS or drive can fail; RAID does not automatically give you a separate recovery copy. Seagate points out that RAID does not protect against every type of hardware failure.
Set up a separate backup destination and periodically try restoring a scan.
A separate backup destination requires additional storage and management.
The number of bays and the raw drive capacity don’t tell you how much usable space you’ll get from your chosen configuration.
Estimate the size of the collection and expected additions in advance. Then check the usable capacity and drive compatibility for the exact model.
Bear in mind that you may need to buy drives and a separate backup destination.
Giving volunteers access and putting a photo online for everyone to see are different things. Personal data and copyright may also be relevant.
Keep internal management separate from public access until you have assessed the applicable legal basis and the rights to the photo.
The DS225+ is a two-bay model, while the DS925+ offers four bays for a collection that may grow.
The TS-233 is a two-bay model for shared storage.
The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model that you can compare for features such as snapshots.
The F2-424 is a two-bay model with backup features listed by the manufacturer.
The NASync DXP2800 is a diskless two-bay model to consider if you’re also looking for photo management features.
These models are suited to an expandable NAS setup for a collection that may grow. Compare the capacity you need and your approach to shared management, and always plan for a separate backup destination as well.
Image unavailable
For a collection that may grow and needs to be shared. Work out how much usable space and what backup setup you’ll need in advance.
Hard drives are not included. Plan for a separate backup destination: RAID alone is not a backup.
Image unavailable
For a collection that needs plenty of space or is continuing to grow. First, calculate the capacity you need and check that the configuration is suitable.
Also plan for a separate backup destination: RAID alone is not a backup.
Image unavailable
For anyone looking to manage and share a growing collection of photo scans. Check the capacity you need and your intended drive configuration in advance.
Hard drives are not included. Also plan for a separate backup destination: RAID alone is not a backup.
No. RAID 1 is not a separate backup. Seagate explains that RAID does not protect against every hardware failure. Keep a copy outside the NAS too, and check that you can restore it.
Agree which scan is the version to keep, organise and describe the files, set appropriate access permissions and practise restoring a copy. The National Archives of the Netherlands distinguishes digital archiving from simply making a backup.
Check whether the NAS is supplied without drives, which drives are compatible with the exact model, and what you’ll need for a separate backup destination. Also review the terms for the specific version you’re considering.
Not automatically. If people in the photo can be identified and the processing falls under the GDPR, the archive must assess whether there is a valid legal basis. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, consent is required in most cases for online publication. You should also assess the copyright in the photo: the Dutch Government says that permission from the creator is required to use copyright-protected photos. The exception for purely personal or household use does not automatically apply to publication on behalf of a community archive.
Not just because an organisation manages an archive. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes the Archives Act requirements in relation to government information held by public authorities. According to that source, the new Archives Act will come into force on 1 January 2027; an individual organisation’s legal position depends on its circumstances.