Choose a NAS setup that helps you organise, find and restore files, but plan for a separate backup too: RAID alone is not a complete archiving strategy. A two-bay NAS may suit an archive that fits within its usable capacity; four or more bays give you more scope to build a larger storage setup. Also consider who needs access, which drives the model supports and the speed of your existing studio network.
Who is this guide for?
Keeper of fragile scans
Wants to be able to find and restore digitised records, photographs and research notes in the future. The National Archives of the Netherlands stresses that digital archiving also involves selecting, organising and describing files. So consider the NAS alongside a separate backup and a plan for file names and folders.
Coordinator of shared research
Needs to decide which studio users can view or edit records, especially when information could identify living people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses the importance of appropriate security and well-managed access rights for organisations.
Manager of a growing archive
Expects more scans or users and therefore compares usable storage, expansion options and network ports across the exact models. Synology, QNAP and ASUSTOR specifications vary by model; on their own, they don’t tell you which configuration will work faster in a studio.
What should you look for in a NAS?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovery and retention |
Check the recovery and snapshot features of the exact model, and set up a separate backup too. |
If you want to restore scans after an error, rather than protect only against drive failure, recovery is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Access rights |
Check whether you can set permissions separately for users, groups and folders. |
Do you want researchers to see or edit only the records intended for them? Restricted collaboration is the top priority for around 27% of consumers. |
| Usable capacity |
Work out the available space after choosing your drives and RAID configuration, and check which drives the model supports. |
If you expect your archive to grow, usable space matters more than the total capacity shown on the drive labels. Room to grow is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Network and working speed |
Check the ports on the NAS, switch and workstations, and assess the speed of the complete network setup. |
When several people share or transfer large scans, you’ll want the network to suit the way they work. Working together is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming a mirrored NAS is a complete archiving strategy
RAID can help if a drive fails, but it doesn’t protect against every cause of data loss. An archive also needs to be organised and described so you can find files later.
Plan a separate backup destination and test that you can restore your files. The National Archives of the Netherlands describes organising and describing files as part of digital archiving; Western Digital says RAID is not a backup.
Allow for a separate backup destination and time to carry out recovery tests.
-
Counting raw terabytes as available archive space
With RAID 1, two identical drives give you the capacity of just one drive to use. A redundant setup can therefore leave less room for scans than the combined drive capacity suggests.
Work out the usable space for your chosen drives and configuration before selecting a model. Synology distinguishes between usable capacity and protection against drive failure when describing RAID options.
Expanding capacity later may require different or additional drives, or a larger system.
-
Assuming every NAS drive is supported in the same way
For the DS925+, Synology notes limited support for drives that aren’t on its compatibility list.
Before choosing, check the compatibility list for the exact NAS and drive models.
Your choice of drive may depend on the support Synology lists for that combination.
-
Giving every studio user access to the same folder
A general shared folder can make records visible or editable to people who don’t need them. Genealogical information about people who have died may also reveal something about their living relatives.
Decide who will use the files and give each user or folder only the access they need. The Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of appropriate security and well-managed access permissions for organisations.
Relevant NAS brands
Synology
For the DS223, Synology describes Btrfs and snapshot features. The DS925+ has four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. With the separately sold DX525 expansion unit, the model supports up to nine drives, according to Synology.
- The features and expansion options give you specific points to compare with your studio’s requirements for each model.
- These are model specifications, not independent performance test results. Synology notes limited support for drives outside the DS925+ compatibility list.
QNAP
QNAP lists two drive bays and dual 2.5GbE ports for the TS-264. Consider these ports alongside the studio’s network equipment and connections.
- The two 2.5GbE ports are a model specification worth considering if your network setup supports them.
- QNAP says the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives. The port specification doesn’t determine the speed you’ll get in the studio.
ASUSTOR
The ASUSTOR Nimbustor 2 Gen2 AS5402T is a two-bay NAS. ASUSTOR lists dual 2.5GbE ports and M.2 slots for this model.
- The ports and M.2 slots are model specifications to compare with your preferred storage and network setup.
- According to ASUSTOR’s specifications, hard drives aren’t included. These features apply to the AS5402T and not automatically to other ASUSTOR models.
NAS systems at Joybuy
This selection focuses on Synology NAS systems with four or more drive bays, for shared archives where room to expand matters.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
May suit a shared archive where five drive bays and the option to expand later are important.
Five drive bays; expandable to fifteen drives; two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included. Plan for a separate backup destination too.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
May suit a large or growing studio archive where eight drive bays and file sharing are important.
Eight drive bays; expandable with an expansion unit; two 2.5GbE ports. A RAID configuration doesn’t replace a separate backup destination.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
May suit a shared archive where four drive bays and room to expand are important.
Four drive bays; expandable to nine drives; two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included. Synology notes limited support for drives outside this model’s compatibility list. Plan for a separate backup destination too.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough for a backup?
No. RAID 1 provides redundancy if a drive fails, but it doesn’t replace a separate backup. Set up a second destination and test that you can actually restore your files.
How do you get started with a shared family history archive?
Organise and describe the files so researchers can find them later. Then set up individual access and decide who can read or edit each folder. Any further security measures you need will depend on the data and how it’s used.
Do I need to buy drives as well as the NAS?
Check this for each model and offer before you choose. QNAP says the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives; ASUSTOR says the same for the AS5402T. Also check which drives are supported by your chosen NAS model, and allow for a separate backup.
Does the GDPR apply to family history records in a shared studio?
That depends on the data, who has access and how it’s used. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exemption for purely personal or household use, as well as conditions for limited private publication. For professional use or wider sharing, you can’t simply assume that the exemption applies. Information about people who have died may also reveal something about living relatives. So assess your specific circumstances before arranging access or publication.